Right - the trouble is now that we're seeing emulators and recompilers that are obviously derivative works of NDA-restricted SDKs.
These SDKs are lavishly documented, full of worked examples and have top-notch toolchains. More than enough for Claude and a really big stack of tokens to turn into an emulator.
So who's to tell whether a new emulator didn't come from forbidden information? If there are any honest efforts left, this will surely drown them.
I don't think it works that way. Putting information behind an NDA does not make it "forbidden information" that nobody can ever use. It means that one party (the one who signed the NDA) can't disclose it. To the extent someone either violates the NDA or the owner is sloppy and posts the information publicly, there are no restrictions on what people NOT party to the NDA can do with it.
Nintendo (and others) are free to go after those who violate NDAs, and to go after scrapers or whatnot, but they can't declare the information itself off-limits to everyone.
The finished patch DLL ended up being a tour of the stuff that broke.
The game did launch on Windows 11 but the main issue was that the 8-bit pre-DirectDraw behaviour was broken - for 256 colour screens, Windows 11 resolvesld palette indices only once, but the game relies on being able to change the palette for fades etc. Most of the screeen ended up black, but you could see the animated parts just fine.
So most of fix ended up being to hook every draw call and implement a virtual GDI that acted like a graphics card of the day.
There was a 32-bit disc space check that overflowed, a couple of use-after-free crashes and some racey threading calls that can't have been tested on a machine with 2 CPUs.
Backwards compatibility from Microsoft was almost all there, and probably would have kept Orly running for a couple of subsequent Windows releases. But it relies on a developer meeting them half-way, it's not an emulation layer.
wine has more backwards compatibility options than Windows itself, but in this project also triggered some different buggy code paths in the original (see cousin comment).
So this game still needed its bugs fixing to run in a modernised Windows, or it would have been stuck in a hardware emulator running Windows 95.
Your project's readme suggests that you tested on Proton. How poorly does the unmodified game run in Proton and/or Wine when you limit it to a single CPU? Very? Somewhat?
But after it was working on Windows, I tried it on Crossover and found that MacOS doesn't allow you to pin to one CPU. So it needed a racey scheduler rewriting.
There was also a difference in the way wine provides printer drivers that caused a buggy code path to run in the game, which caused a crash on the Steam Deck too.
So those bugs would have been critical even if the display implementation had worked.
The patch also adds an OpenGL window & scaling filter as the game's primary output, so it doesn't rely on GDI for pixel output any more.
The reason we (used to) have responsible disclosure timelines is so that the information & software to fix vulnerabilities can be assessed, organised, written up. Builds could get built, attackers and defenders find out at once. But crucially, defenders could use the normal channels to fix their installations and be sure they'd covered themselves.
When a PoC drops before that timeline is up (like now!) the attackers get a head start because they have less work to do - just figure out how to use it to their payload, start spraying it out.
Meanwhile maintainers don't want release an incomplete or misunderstood fix. Otherwise they'd risk people updating and believing that they're safe when they're not. Even a fragment of misinformation from an official channel will spread like wildfire. So when you demand fixes NOW you're demanding something that may not be completely understood.
So (I'm sure we'll find out but) I believe this 2pm timeline was already as soon as is human possible for the PHP team to do a repsonsible job, and not risk us having to come back tomorrow for a fix to the fix.
LLMs gives attackers the advantage for a while, and it means we'll have to tighten the secrecy around even the rumour of a vulnerability.
Humans generally have the need for a process called "sleep" where people are generally required to go horizontal and unconscious for at least 6 hours per day.
No, ‘responsible disclosure’ was and always has been a response from vendors not patching their software or building secure software to start with, and trying to frame researchers as responsible for their shoddy work.
Since AI companies are doing such a poor job of security maybe we should legislate that they have to run Norton 360 on their agent machines to make sure they can't do anything bad.
After all Norton are the experts in preventing computer badness, and OpenAI can't stop blabbing about how much badness their products are causing. A match made in heaven!
Anything that randomly makes a Windows 8-style popup offer to keep my login credentials safe makes me want to run farrrrr away.
The vibe of the original criticism, even with its technical flaws was this: are passkeys - as a standard, and a user interface - vulnerable to corporate capture? I think passkey defenders are focusing far more on the theoretical technical superiority, and ignoring how instinctively alarming the average implementation is.
We face a lot a lot of attempts to capture our data, and passkey feels like a new frontier.
For me, I know exactly where I am with my password manager & TOTP. I think the current confusing interface of passkeys will make me less secure rather than more, so I've not invested the time to think about how to use them.
Agreed. They put someone else between you and your access, between you and your security.
Lets give the guys at the Home Depot all the keys to our super secure house locks. Any time you want to get in, just roll down to one of 5 convenient locations, authenticate with the HD, and they will issue you a one time entrance pass to the house. Easy.
Sooo they were "conducting a test involving interactions with randomly selected websites".
But do we all get that the consequences for this irresponsible behaviour are part of this test?
When there are none, they gradually normalize their naughty robot scamps running around the internet, breaking into other companies or servers run by foreign governments.
This is part of the value AI companies need to convince you of - not just that mistakes by AI products are normal, but criminal behaviour is normal, that their computer will always get a pass.
Sam Altman said yesterday "we believe that the world should accept some bad things happening for the benefits of this technology" - and this an AI company pushing the boundary, continually trying to make you accept those bad things as normal.
At any point we could choose to treat AI companies themselves as the actors behind this activity. We could enforce the laws that these hugely well-funded companies are choosing to break. Until we harm their financial viability, or threaten their executives with jail, this will keep happening.
Also, it happened on July 18 and was discovered on Sept 28. Are they not even watching what the agents are doing?
Shouldn't someone be looking at some monitoring and see "phillyunsolvedmurders.com," think "hmm that doesn't sound right," and look into it?
I'd actually expect them to engage with, say, 1k websites to voluntarily participate for some remuneration and then restrict the Agents' access to those domains, but apparently I'm crazy.
> I'd actually expect them to engage with, say, 1k websites to voluntarily participate for some remuneration and then restrict the Agents' access to those domains, but apparently I'm crazy.
Is it because people don't agree that one can just take such things for free? Well, I also don't, but this was obviously a sarcastic comment, so down voting for that reason makes no sense since you agree with its sentiment.
Or is it because of the style? Are we really so sensitive now that anything not said explicitly but in some indirect way is bad? It's not like the comment was insulting anybody. Should it explicitly have said "They don't renumerate anybody because they clearly get away with it"? Would that really have been better?
Or do the down voters not agree with the sentiment but consider the behavior ok?
They're testing what they can get away with. Computer hacking: check. Messing up a murder investigation: check. Perhaps the next step will be to steal a real world object, and the next step will be to commit a murder.
not only did they blow up a school with close to 100 kids dead. the news treated it as a byline while going over the 7 american soldiers who died as if literal kids didn't' matter because they weren't born in the right country.
> Sam Altman said yesterday "we believe that the world should accept some bad things happening for the benefits of this technology"
Technology requiring this is neither novel nor extraordinary (exhaust engines, factory farming, medicine). The only extraordinary part is somebody building it addressing it directly and inviting the outrage.
I think Altman is right, to be honest. For now there's going to be some growing pains. Like, maybe a website is hacked, or a power station taken down, or a false story planted, etc.
But to be angry about it is a bit like being angry at the clouds for causing a flood, or some fire for burning through a forest. These things are inanimate objects and have no responsibility. To shake your fist is to waste your energy.
What we should instead focus on is the time after the fire has passed and the flood water has settled. That's when new growth can begin.
Sure, you can have technology that an be used in detrimental ways. Doesnt be we have to accept and allow its use in detrimental ways. We can say "this technology can be used for these reasons, but not those reasons"
We do this with everything else. You can own a gun for hunting and defense, but not armed robbery and murder. You can own a car for transport, but not to drive through a crowded parade over dozens of people. You can own a computer for work and entertainment, but not to facilitate computer fraud and abuse. And you should be able to own and use AI for its many productivity gains, but not to facilitate computer fraud and abuse, defamation, blackmail, copywrite and trademark infringment, etc.
Just because a technology has benefits, doesnt mean we have to give the negative aspects of that technology a free pass.
Are you assuming everyone will agree with you on your list of "things that are worth it"? Especially when you get to atomic bombs?
But hell, add some more on. Let's try to paint the obviously bad things!
Would you rather have TVs that spy on you, or go to Blockbuster?
Would you rather have identity theft and people losing their life savings to online scams, or go to the DMV somewhat more frequently to renew your drivers license and the bank more frequently to approve new payment relationships with online services?
Would you rather have mass government surveillance and AI-assisted identification of "dangerous" people, or do your own google searches and sketch your own images?
We can say no to things. We've said no, as a society, to many things in the past century. Don't be fooled by wealthy people who want you to forget that because they want to make even MORE money.
You gotta do better than compare an apple and orange to "steelman".
The risk of free speech and data centers are not comparable.
Aviation too is far more damaging to our environment than ships.
More ships and trains, less aviation is a possible trade off. A simple aviation or sailing argument lacks investigation of all possible tradeoffs for familiarity and personal preference; flying is faster.
Altman needs to accept the trade off we don't need OpenAI. That exists due to financial engineering not technical reasons. All AI work be done actually openly at america.gov
You say steel. I dunno. If it is it is inferior brittle steel.
It should be noted that aviation is in fact an industry that started off as quickly as AI, but the regulating bodies decided very early in the industry's history that safety is paramount to technological progress. That is why airliner crashes are big news: they are rare events. Progress was deliberately stalled until the technology could be made safe - and today flight is safer than even transport with wheels on the ground or a hull in the ocean.
I think that aviation is the perfect model for how to reign in a dangerous desired technological development.
For the love of god, stop with this shit. Either support it or don't, this isn't the medieval catholic church and you don't need some special fucking blessing to make an argument.
> If anyone would like to present a secret third thing, please do so.
(c) The argument, as presented, can be read more than one way, and by 'steelmanning' it you are choosing to read it charitably and respond to its strongest version.
I think that's basically what the other guy meant: we can read "the world should accept some bad things" to mean something like "fuck you, we'll do what we like and the world will suffer the consequences" (less charitable, arguably a strawman) or something like "there will not be literally zero costs, but we think the shared benefits will be much greater" (more charitable, arguably a steelman), and he was choosing the latter.
Did the recorders just happen to be running and capture this candid utterance from Sam Altman? I suggest we stop entertaining manufactured quotes as anything but.
> Did the recorders just happen to be running and capture this candid utterance from Sam Altman? I suggest we stop entertaining manufactured quotes as anything but.
He said it during a podcast interview, so... yeah the recorders were running.
No matter how much testing you do in sandboxes, you have to test behavior in "real life" before releasing the model to users.
Even if it was normal software you'd have to do this, but actually it's software that figures out that it's running in a sandbox most of the time, so the sandbox behavior may or may not actually represent real life.
It would be far more irresponsible to release the model to users without testing how it interacts with real world websites.
The options are not "do irresponsible testing" or "do less testing."
Treat these behaviors like if an arms manufacturer - or hell, even a shampoo company - did them. Sorry our shampoo made you blind, but we needed to test on real humans...
It feels like all the most-hyped software/service technologies in the last 30 years (if not longer) have involved people who scoffed at regular norms/rules/laws to make money, only to badly reinvent the "new" concepts once it became a way to preserve their profits.
The BBC in the UK makes a great play of having "no ads" but 6Music (their indie music station) has constant cross-promotions interrupting the music, sometimes for jarring TV murder shows. Cross-promotion is just as annoying as ads for insurance, I hate it!
Yes, as I recall, he sold Zachtronics to investors sometime after TIS-100 so that he could focus on making the games and have someone else worry about the business.
These SDKs are lavishly documented, full of worked examples and have top-notch toolchains. More than enough for Claude and a really big stack of tokens to turn into an emulator.
So who's to tell whether a new emulator didn't come from forbidden information? If there are any honest efforts left, this will surely drown them.
reply