This seems the most plausible. I highly doubt all these traditional, slow moving enterprises were token-maxing this past spring and these outages being the outcomes of that and latent bugs. If anything they have very slow, controlled releases of system/software updates. Maybe MSFT is the exception because they are a tech company.
As with any food or drink that a human would like to convince others that its elevated (aka better than similar ones) there needs to be pretension and gatekeeping.
An interesting deep dive would be when this came about with humans, was there "mead with notes of huckleberry" in medieval times or did it start farther back in history? When did this concept originate? Is it called by different names in different cultures?
This is the biggest shift in software engineering. Working with LLMs is more like managing a junior engineer that has amnesia but also has instant access to the most mediocre (i.e. statistical median) known solutions humans have produced and can produce syntax-error free code.
Its not that circular financing is sinister or illegal, its that its very risky. If the startups that are purchasing the product are also getting a loan from the company making the product and that loan is also backed by that same company then if that startup is unprofitable and has massive debt at interest rates like 15% or has near junk bond ratings then the company that built, financed and backed the products is on the hook for it all.
Sure they have customers pounding at their door for more product. At some point the hype machine stops and new neocloud startups can't get funding because its too expensive or banks don't trust them. Then what happens? The circular financing starts to unwind itself and NVidia is the "bag holder". If you look up Lucent or Nortel this happened to them during the dot com boom. There is a positive difference here with NVidia, they have so much demand and usage this can probably go on for a while. Lucent and Nortel were bit by dark fiber and the usage/demand just wasn't there.
If Jensen at the helm of NVidia is bullying/convincing companies into purchasing more than they need, financing it, etc. and creating the hype machine himself and NewCEO ain't going to play that game, then it could be an end to the circular financing.
NVidia was financing up to about 25% of purchases -- less than its margin. It's true this might be more risky than other sales strategies, but not enough to create a moral hazard of selling oversubsidized deals.
I haven't checked what companies exactly are they funding, but IMO that's the easiest way for Nvidia to have a high stake at a real future competitor for OAI or Anthropic, in whatever form, new proprietary or open sourced models. Besides the training data, compute is the biggest barrier to entry to this market. So bet on a few talented teams, give the tools, and see what happens..
I agree with you completely and this is the real problem. Somewhere people were accusing them of accounting fraud, or this is because of the perils of effective altruism, or .. pick you poison. Capitalism is a great system but it carries within it the seeds of its own destruction.
Circular financing and various forms of booking sales ahead of or for future delivery are things that have caught up with other companies in the past and/or were straight-up SEC violations. Enron is an example.
Does Jensen's replacement have the industry connections, clout (or bully factor depending on perspective) and appetite to continue the circular financing? Its the CFO I think that is replacing him and they may have objected to these things all along and might have been over-ruled.
>Circular financing and various forms of booking sales ahead of or for future delivery are things that have caught up with other companies in the past and/or were straight-up SEC violations. Enron is an example.
But circular financing isn't illegal, unlike all the other things you listed
Whether its legal or not isn't really the point. The point is with Jensen out and someone else in, they may not like all those circular financing arrangements and may not do more of them. Or another way to phrase is the board and the executives could be less risky with these arrangements. NVidia CEO change (and end of circular financing and/or a cautious board/CEO) could be a funding shock to its weakest customers (unprofitable, debt laden companies like CoreWeave) which would hit NVidia hard because it is the supplier, investor, and loan backer (i.e. they are acting as the bank/insurer of the loan). If one of those companies can't pay, NVidia is left taking all the losses for the circular arrangement with that company.
Did Anthropic's new release this week include an AI rollout plan (i.e. not approved by humans) to take down Office and Outlook for a lot of enterprises? I half-snarkily ask since we have seen "rogue AI" headlines before.
A fictional story about AI could be that it rolled out its new document, spreadsheet, slides, etc. apps, knows the IPO is coming up and decided to make a lot of opportunities for people to sign up for their new release by DDosing their competitor.
Its economics, I'm not going to pay $100k for a robot to empty my dishwasher. I won't even pay $1k to purchase a robot vacuum.
There's no ROI for it at this point in time for consumers. Robots have been automating various things in factories for decades, its not new. Making the robots look like humans and act like humans doesn't really provide value does it?
For example how is a $100-200k robot cashier better than self-checkout or having a teenager get paid $12/hour?
I get that economics plays a huge role, but as with almost every technology, it starts off super expensive and is only used by big corporations (factories, in this case). Then it gets cheaper, and disruptive technologies appear that knock down the incumbents. A surge in demand follows, especially when the technology is actually useful and makes life easier. The history of PCs is a good example.
The biggest moat with applications like MS Office is compatibility. Sharing a slide deck or spreadsheet with others is a simple decision, you know they have it or have software that can read/write it.
I don't get the need to have Anthropic build their custom versions of MS Office apps, I can tell Claude to generate a word doc from a wiki page and it does a pretty damn good job. Anthropic's statistical median level of software that they had Claude create isn't going to replace Office apps to the point where companies cancel/stop renewing their MS Office subscriptions/licenses.
The other element is trust. Do end users trust their data in Anthropic's systems? A lot of people get creeped out when they search for content from one device in their household and then nearly instantaneously they start seeing ads from other devices on the same topic. How creepy will AI get if it starts consuming all your docs, spreadsheets, personal finance info, emails, etc.?
I beg to differ I already am stopping using MS office recently but that's mainly because I really dislike how they lock up the apps if your late on your annual payment. It's a grating value capture model. I'm sure I will have to get back to it at some point but in the meantime google is providing great optionality and I don't have a concern that the software stack has glaring security concerns.
On the trust thing - I don't trust anthropic and I don't think MS has been a great steward over the years either.
The moat of backwards compatibility and plugins is why MS Office has survived decades of competitors without any appreciable loss of market share.
It's hard to see Anthropic replacing it, and even if so - why bother, the revenue is miniscule. They need 100 MS Offices for the compute contracts to pencil out.
Without LLMs, reverse engineering isn't illegal is it? Companies probably have departments of people that reverse engineer other companies products, software and hardware, to look for patent infringement, how a competitor is doing things, etc. Using that reverse engineered code or physical designs in your product and producing it I think is the illegal part.
Some of the reverse engineering being done by LLMs is using older OSS. I remember hearing about some 2012 era reverse engineering app that looks at the assembly language and reconstructs software. The LLM isn't reverse engineering itself in those scenarios, its calling local software, interpreting results, probably glueing software together with what the human is prompting it to do.
reply