Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | michaelje's commentslogin

I built something similar at the start of the year, using tailscale for auth (multi user on my tailnet/home network) and for access wherever I was, whether at home or on the road (all compute/storage was on my Mac mini.) Worked a treat.


Once upon a time, physically shipping faulty software had real costs borne by the organization - production, redistribution and transportation of a physical disc.

Today there’s no disc, no recall - that cost to shipping broken software is gone. We the users pay the price.


You act like there's no benefit to the user either, plenty of software gets better because of updates shipped after the fact.


I would prefer to know what the product will do when I purchase it, and it should continue to do the same things in the same way for its entire lifespan. I would also prefer that vendors be unable to retroactively add ads, tracking, or other user hostile "features".

Also, as an embedded engineer, I know things get tested better the more "final" they are. Faster release cadences always have poor testing as one of the tradeoffs.


> You act like there's no benefit to the user either, plenty of software gets better because of updates shipped after the fact.

There is a "release early, release often" line of thinking.

But I also think there is a risk of "fixing it in post(-production)" thinking: that lack of preparation and care can be patched over after-the-fact.


The averaged-over-usage-lifetime software quality for things like cars or video games is worse today than it was before OTA updates

Arguably the peak quality after a few months/years of fixes is better, but that doesn't really matter because usage is front-loaded


I remember my parents needing to buy very expensive map DVD disks in order to update the car’s navigation system to update their car’s navigation computer.

The disks were very expensive and if you didn’t update them it wouldn’t know about new roads (slower trip, missed turns, etc).


That's why we have Android Auto: move the updates to a thing that already has frequent Internet connection, and if the update goes wrong it's clearly the fault of this other company, plus the car itself still works fine.

Jeep already had an OTA the broke the ability for the car to be driven.


Did those updates ever break the navigation software?


I've had map update packages brick head units before, yes. Largely because they also shipped some software updates in that map update package.


> plenty of software gets better because of updates

This was true for old Microsoft Windows releases. This is not true anymore. Everything is a rolling release. Angry users ? F*k them. They will get an update.


You act like all the updates benefit the user.


Fair


s/better/less bad/


The CBC recently reported on videos pretending to be from Canadians promoting similar anti-Canada messaging. They used AI generated copies of real Canadians and hired voice actors. They use this divisive content to drive views and ad revenue: https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/alberta-separatist-youtube-ch...


Yes, this is story immediately came to mind to me. It also shows that the idea of poor people in the global south doing this for money isn't quite the entire story either. Most of the people exposed seem to be young Dutch people trying to make a quick buck attacking Canada.


The overreach on access and then storage will be a meaningful issue we will have to reckon with more and more. Companies are acquired, companies die. What happens to your data in 5, 15, 50 years? It doesn’t just disappear.

From a few months back: https://mjeggleton.com/blog/your-data-never-dies


Open models keep closing the eval gap for many tasks, and local inference continues to be increasingly viable. What's missing isn't technical capability, but productized convenience that makes the API path feel like the only realistic option.

Frontier labs are incentivized to keep it that way, and they're investing billions to make AI = API the default. But that's a business model, not a technical inevitability.


im hoping and praying that local inference finds it's way to some sort of baseline that we're all depending on claude for here. that would help shape hardware designs on personal devices probably something in the direction of what apple has been doing.

ive had to like tune out of the LLM scene because it's just a huge mess. It feels impossible to actually get benchmarks, it's insanely hard to get a grasp on what everyone is talking about, bots galore championing whatever model, it's just way too much craze and hype and misinformation. what I do know is we can't keep draining lakes with datacenters here and letting companies that are willing to heel turn on a whim basically control the output of all companies. that's not going to work, we collectively have to find a way to make local inference the path forward.

everyone's foot is on the gas. all orgs, all execs, all peoples working jobs. there's no putting this stuff down, and it's exhausting but we have to be using claude like _right now_. pretty much every company is already completely locked in to openai/gemini/claude and for some unfortunate ones copilot. this was a utility vendor lock in capture that happened faster than anything ive ever seen in my life & I already am desperate for a way to get my org out of this.


I'm frustrated that there's not "solid" instructional tooling. I either see people just saying "keep trying different prompts and switching models until you get lucky" or building huge cantilevered toolchains that seems incredibly brittle, and even then, how well do they really work?

I get choice paralysis when you show me a prompt box-- I don't know what I can reasonably ask for and how to best phrase it, so I just panic. It doesn't help when we see articles saying people are getting better outcomes by adding things like "and no bugs plz owo"

I'm sure this is by design-- anything with clear boundaries and best practices would discourage gacha style experimentation. Can you trust anyone who sells you a metered service to give you good guidance on how to use it efficiently?


yea that is probably the worst part of these techs becoming mainstream services and local-LLM'ing taking off in general: working with them at many points in any architecture no longer feels... deterministic i guess. way too fucking much "heres what i use" but no real best practices yet, just a lot of vague gray area and everyones still in discovery-mode on how to best find some level of determinism or workflow and ways we are benchmarking is seriously a moving target. everyone has their own branded take on what the technology is and their own branded approach on how to use it, and it's probably the murkiest and foggiest time to be in technology fields that i've ever seen :\ seems like weekly/monthly something is outdated, not just the models but the tooling people are parroting as the current best tooling to use. incredibly frustrating. there's simply too much ground to cover for any one person to have any absolute takes on any of it, and because a handful of entities are currently leading the charge draining lakes and trying to compete for every person and every businesses money, there's zero organized frameworks at the top to make some sense of this. they all are banking on their secret sauce, and i _really_ want us all to get away from this. local inference has to succeed imo but goddamn there needs to be some collective working together to rally behind some common strats/frameworks here. im sure there's already countless committees that have been established to try and get in front of this but even that's messy.

i don't know how else to phrase it: this feels like such an unstable landscape, "beta" software/services are running rampant in every industry/company/org/etc and there's absolutely no single resource we can turn to to help stay ahead of & plan for the rapidly-evolving landscape. every, and i mean every company, is incredibly irresponsible for using this stuff. including my own. once again though, cat's already out of the bag. now we fight for our lives trying to contain it and ensure things are well understood and implemented properly...which seems to be the steepest uphill battle of my life


Absolutely. Pricing exposure is the quiet story under all the waves of AI hype. Build for convenience → subsidise for dependence → meter for margin is a well-worn playbook, and AI-dependent companies are about to find out what phase three feels like.

Hyperscalers are spending a fortune so we think AI = API, but renting intelligence is a business model, not a technical inevitability.

Shameless link to my post on this: https://mjeggleton.com/blog/AIs-mainframe-moment


https://sorso.app/

A fresh PWA to log / improve your coffee brewing process. We use it to see what we are all drinking, find new coffees, explore new cafes, and understand what we like / don’t like.

It’s primarily used by our group of friends, so if you see a rough edge somewhere please reach out!


Every other country appears to have the “bread” at a reasonable price. Ironically, it’s the US which has the same bread for 100x the cost.


Did you know Russian citizens spend half their take home pay on food? Wanna keep running with that point of yours?


I thought we were talking about developed nations participating in the global economy.


There are other markets than Russia and the US what about all of Europe.



Not sure medicine is the best example given the same profit seeking culture is driving decisions where care takes a back seat


>> critics argue that it reduces the supply of rental apartments and creates housing shortages

I don’t follow the logic. It doesn’t destroy the property or take it out of supply, it just means someone might not purchase it specifically to rent it out. Which in turn means less demand buying houses overall, which means more opportunities for people to buy (if they want?)


In Toronto, as it has been explained to me by some banker types, in 2006 they introduced some pretty strong rent control, and developers just switched from building rentals to building condos, now Toronto has no rental units and a zillion condos that not many people can afford to buy or rent.^ Friend of mine lives in a condo and over half the units in his floor are now managed airbnbs.

^ Couple this situation with no restrictions (in fact encouragement) on foreign buyers for many many years, and you have condos sitting empty, condos rented out for amounts nobody can afford, and condos turning into airbnbs for rich tourists. From what I gather, both Toronto and Vancouver are a real mess because of this.


> friend of mine lives in a condo and over half the units in his floor are now managed airbnbs

This should change with the new Anti-AirBNB(Short term rental) rules at municipal, provincial, and federal (CRA) levels.


…and it ends up being a cascade of new regulations to try and address the unforeseen consequences of the previous regulation. Eventually you end up like San Francisco where no new housing ever gets built ever again and prices are sky-high because of it.


But go too far in the other direction of not regulating enough, you also end up in the exact same spot.


Do we? How does that work?


Yes. Most places have had unregulated property market like forever and are similary broken by speculation, collusion, price fixing and just exploitation of tenants.

The regulations actually attempts to answer this. They might not work well but atleast somebody is trying to do something.

The notion that if you got rid of the regulation and suddently situation would fix itself is suspiciously naive.


Doesn't that make it worse for people who want to rent AirBNBs?

I think the solution is to overbuild like crazy. Particularly in Canada where there is infinite land. People will be less interested in speculating as there is no supply limit. Cheap real estate is a net good for humanity.


So now fewer condos and apartments are produced.

Brilliant.


It doesn't destroy the property or take it out of supply.

But it also strongly disincentivizes potential investors in building new rental properties. Which makes perfect sense,if you inherited 5million euro would you spend it building rent controlled apartments or put into stocks&bonds?


Or in a US scenario, would you rather build rentals in Texas or California?


California. It’s the world’s fifth largest economy. I will take some regulatory risk over volatility in Texas. California vacancy rates speak for themselves, there is voracious demand for housing there vs Texas. Texas also has the nation’s 7th highest property tax rate.

https://austin.culturemap.com/news/real-estate/texas-propert...


> It’s the world’s fifth largest economy

You're comparing $3.9T to $2.4T, but that's still not the metric you look at. It's whether you're a landlord in a town of 5,000, a mid-sized city, or a 2M metro, and what the local economy looks like.

> California vacancy rates speak for themselves

This goes two ways. On one hand, it's an opportunity. On the other, it's an opportunity a lot of people clearly don't want to take.

> Texas also has the nation’s 7th highest property tax rate

As long as it's consistent and the regulators allow it, you just pass it on to tenants. CA's Prop 13, while making overall property taxes lower, puts you at a weird disadvantage compared to incumbent landlords.


[flagged]


In my experience, it is crucial to avoid human nature, and instead, simply evaluate the math. It either works or it doesn’t, no emotion. Emotion destroys risk adjusted returns, and is harmful to preserving capital.


If you don't evaluate emotions too, you are missing most of human reality in your equations, like it or not. Stuff will not go as expected.


This analysis only works if you assume the supply is fixed.

If you increase the returns to building ownership then people will build more buildings. Which lowers prices.

Capping supply by decreasing the returns leads to less supply, other things equal.


Won't lower prices reduce returns to building ownership?


Yes, that is supply and demand. Supply will expand until it is no longer profitable to expand supply.


But for supply to expand, prices must go up, right? They can't go down.

That is what I'm trying to understand, since a lot of people here imply that "increase in supply will lower prices".


It is called The Law of Supply and Demand. I'm sure there are zounds of articles or videos on it.

In the model, the price of a unit will change as you adjust either supply or demand. If there is lots of demand and little supply, the price is high. If there is lots of supply, the demand cannot force the price higher. Assuming the seller wants to sell, they have to compete with other sellers. The more units for sell, the less negotiating power they have because someone more desperate can sell cheaper.


I understand supply and demand... but it's a really basic theory.

My point is: prices will have to increases for supply to increase as well. Saying that increasing supply will keep prices low makes no sense if right now prices are too low for private interests to build more housing.

Supply won't keep prices "low" and certainly not lower than they are now. How would that work? How would they make profit?


1. Few new rentals are built, because it's not profitable

2. Existing rentals are converted to condominiums, because that is more profitable

If you can afford to buy a condominium, great. If not, there is always the public housing company. I hope you're not in a hurry though because the typical waiting time to get a rental in Stockholm is 7-11 years.

https://bostad.stockholm.se/english/


I refer you to https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39655144

> there's a queue for rentals, so you register that you want to rent in Stockholm, and then you get put on a list, and then wait two years for it to be your turn

Price capping any good -- housing, fuel, food -- by definition produces a shortage.

A shortage is when there is more demand than supply at the market price.

And artificially lowering the market price increases the amount demanded and reduces the amount supplied.


I believe that the queue hasn't been as short as "two years" in a couple of decades.


It only creates a shortage in a world where you have the x-shaped supply and demand curve from econ 101, which doesn’t apply here because the shortage already exists because of zoning/planning laws limiting the construction of new housing. If there wasn’t an existing shortage then no-one would be calling for rent controls. Rent controls just change who the winners and losers are as a result of a given shortage, in Stockholm’s case, existing residents are the winners and new residents are the losers. Existing residents who benefit get to vote to maintain the status quo in municipal elections whereas the people that can’t move there because of rent controls don’t, hence the system is self-sustaining.


> If there wasn’t an existing shortage then no-one would be calling for rent controls

False, rent controls isn't about shortage it is about land lords raising rents for people who already live there and since it is so much work to move people will stay and pay overpriced rent.

Then that rent control easily leads to the shortage and extremely high prices for new entrants, but that was never the original goal.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: