Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | pdhborges's commentslogin

Last time I touched that book was 14 years ago. Yeah not only it is missing a bunch of recent algorithms and quantization methods like HNSW but also as a reference it devotes many many pages to the zoo of tree based methods that frankly did not feel very iluminating at the time an was mostly completely useless since then.

this is great feedback. higher dimensional spaces are something i'm not very strong in. i'll likely pull this volume from the list until/unless i get a more modern view of it, thanks!

The book is quite basic. Don't expect to get much out of it if you have a STEM degree.

It is still good as a book on philosophy of mathematics. Not the best, perhaps, but a solid introduction.

Like, the epistemology and metaphysics of mathematics? That kind of philosophy? Realism, idealism and all that jazz?

Nothing so esoteric — it’s written for the popular audience. But there’s a lot of “what is mathematics?” or “how do we do mathematics?” Some random highlights:

> A big part of mathematical training is becoming acquainted with different concepts and recognizing how they’re cousins to each other.

> I encourage everyone to fool around with numbers—some enthusiasts discover important patterns that way, and some famous mathematicians, like the late John Conway, made a career of it.

> When we give word problems in school, we tend to cherry-pick perfect models that have one correct answer. Rather than teach a preordained procedure, we could encourage exploration by asking students to fix more realistic models where things are slightly noisy or slightly incorrect.


I'm hoping my kids will get a lot out of it as they grow up :)

> The book is quite basic.

Perplexing how it's on the front page then given the background of the median HN user (presumably technical with some STEM background in general, some pure VC bros peppered in etc).

The Tao love conquers all, as it were.


I enjoy reading less technical books even on technical topics I know about. They serve a different purpose.

Eh, I just like reading new books on mathematics, even if they're covering well trod ground. I think a lot of people in math are like this. I'm not endlessly grinding through introductory textbooks, but there is something nice about seeing someone brilliant give their take on something fundamental. And the cultural differences you get in reading different texts from different periods or from different authors is really stimulating, for me at least.

1) Not everyone, and 2) some of us regularly find ourselves recommending books to others, or for kids.

Basic knowledge resources are very common in HN in front page. And such resource from someone known to write very well will be helpful for newbies even from lesser known personalities. Shared here all the time so why pretend its not common.

[flagged]


HN guidelines:

> Be kind. Don't be snarky.


I'm not talking to another member or referring to a particular comment, I'm making a brief comment by analogy regarding a pair of public figures who profit from their notoriety.

Moreover I was accurate, unless your idea of kindness is to imply that comparison to a success physicist is "unkind".


im not pro-ai-bro but i gotta say some of the maths involved is pretty cool

That math isn't being discussed here, it's barely even discussed in the book! Frankly how often do you open an HN thread on the front page and see any significant technical discussion of anything other than coding? I find the times I see someone writing out equations and discussing fundamentals so rare and welcome as to be memorable.

Most conversation here is profoundly non-technical and never touches anything like "the math".


In Portugal it is part of the standard curriculum although in my time they were poorly motivativated and besides solving some classes of quadratic equations no other applications were mentioned.


What inference provider are you using?


opencode go


If it doesn't matter I will just pick the cheapest to run (the static ones).


We also use technology to care for the people in medicine and it requires pretty advanced science and engineering. Doesn't that shred your argument?


Nope. The medical advances created the inverted pyramid of demographics in the western world, filled by old people.


OP was talking about this: https://www.math.uwaterloo.ca/~hwolkowi/matrixcookbook.pdf

Look into some examples of the section 2.4 "Derivatives of Matrices, Vectors and Scalar Forms"


Do you believe I can't get a list of 20 effective pro-consumer regulations drafted by the EU out of Gemini?


I don't think you're taking my "there's two sides to regulation" comment in good faith.

I gave a pretty clear example of pro-consumer regulation myself.

Saying that the EU is overregulating cannot possibly be that controversial, given that even the European politicians are beginning to admit it.. Draghi, Von der Leyen (even though she passes blame), Merz, Macron.


I took it in good faith I just think that:

- the overregulation narrative conflates two different problems

- and that you minimized too much the consumer benefits of EU legislation

I think the overregulation problem olis less that we have 200 EU regulations and we need to hack and slash 100 of them and more that we have 100 national regulations 25 are exact transcriptions of EU directives, 25 are transcriptions with tweaks and the other 50 are national scoped regulations and what we need to do is to make them uniform so that companies don't have to deal with 27x75 problems.

I'm a bit burned by politicians using the overregulation narrative and then not specifying a single example of a meaningfull rule that they would get rid of. Usually what is left in the air is that worker rights and consumer rights should be cut.


Maybe you should get that list from the European AI products that came from those awesome EU regulations.


You can use your AC as a fan when it is not too bad.


If you think that then you've never used a ceiling fan before - they are substantially more powerful than the air blowing out of your AC.


This was an half usefull joke. I can still make it with the exterior unit off for an extra 1 or 2 degrees with just the interior unit blowing during the day and the use the AC to cool during the night when it is more efficient.

In any case where I live fans are not a meaningfull stopgap measure.


> A very personal view but many developers/engineers fail to see the overall picture. And yes, I was there and I went through all of the mistakes.

What is failling to see the overall picture? I hate this overall picture mysticism. I bet that if people where given the same role and information as the CEO they would be able to see the overall picture.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: