Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | plc's commentslogin

yeah sadly being in this industry for too long I more and more just want to get a log cabin with no internet access...i can't stand the constant ring devices around me, hoping that hackers aren't watching me while I sleep and knowing the firmware is hopelessly outdated and that Opus 5 or whatever has already found 300 vulns (they already hacked 85% of classified DOD systems in all of FIVE HOURS) Geez, taxpayer money well spent to harden our secrets...


For me it's that and the nonsense of later audio codec versions doing things other than encoding audio. Nonsense like that keeps accumulating.


it's just a HN for this particular vertical of AI privacy and security...thanks for the patience, it's our first run at this. no marketing is intended, it's just a (hopefully useful) website to try out some techniques.


But does it do anything? The only thing I could do was share a link the content was light and nothing else seemed interactive. I’m not sure why this would be for HN since it doesn’t appear to have any real content or information.


yeah exactly, this is totally ungoverned territory and has to be discussed a lot, a lot more...


i get the vibe coding angst but I do think this is different, I mean there are 14 agents scouring real time sources 24/7 to put together condensed, readable content for the average user to make them more alarmed (as they should be) about AI privacy. That's the only goal, just education, if it works. If not, we'll shut it down.


I think you'll find most people on hacker news don't want to read re-packaged content, they want to read primary sources or original reporting.


yeah apologies, it's not meant to be repackaging but a 24/7 news analysis to compact relatively recent cyber related incidents to an HN style update, automate by our AI. This is the first run on this, so I appreciate the patience.


Disclosure: I'm the founder of AuraVision, which publishes The Signal (the linked site). Posting because the underlying Northeastern/Consumer Reports study is a significant privacy issue worth a technical discussion here. The site has a product point of view, but the reporting and primary sources stand on their own — happy to link the raw sources or dig into specifics in the thread.


The problem with vibecoded sites like this is nobody will take you or your idea seriously. It’s like a big rubber stamp that says “this is slop”. Hire an actual designer and make an actual website, you could still do this with AI to build it, but it will look 1000x more credible.


i mean, I really want to give parity credit to AI when it's due. We have lots of designers, and honestly, the work is not at parity at what we're seeing internally. People can disagree but that is just my personal experience. Thanks for the feedback though, I do appreciate it. If we have to make it more credible with different colors or fonts I don't really see that as an issue but we'll take a look.


LLMs do match the level of sophistication of the user and the quality of questions they ask. So questions about, how do you improve the level of question? You see the answer in Terry's exchange, both AI and humans are doing an exchange that is thought provoking on both sides for what interesting questions to ask. That is the most startling thing about this -- they are exploring the solution space with the same naivete, to some degree.

Physics, they describe general relativity as a two way street. Space tells mass how to move, and mass tells space how to bend.

Here, Terence tells AI what question to explore, AI tells him what questions to ask next.

The exchange that ensues is just magic to watch.


uh -- who does naked options at ledgerx?

and yes, the data says 3600 for the call, which is the definition of a premium. nothing missing, guys. seriously. do more thinking before you post.

seriously no joke, I am the CEO there, former trader at Goldman so I sort of know what I am talking about with this type of stuff. You guys do not. It's hilarious to watch this conversation.


It's not in your interest to be dismissive and insulting with others here, and it breaks the guidelines by being uncivil and unsubstantive. Could you please stop?

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html


go ahead and close my account. you guys have tolerated a lot worse in the past with others. i'm just being substantive, because you know, i sort of know what i'm talking about.


in general, you are telling me to stop but I am telling you guys to stop. you do so much damage to companies with completely uninformed comments than you can possibly realize. if you don't know what you're talking about, don't talk. and yes, there are "facts" that companies cannot discuss in an open format. that's the nature of a regulated business. we do not do cat photo sharing. we hold money and assets for people. think on that.


Two things - One, it's not the comments on hn which is hurting you rather an adverse reaction to a story which is obviously raising a false flag in many people's mind. So, if this is story was a PR move, it was a bad one.

Second, you can't have it both ways. Get mad at people for saying wrong thing, as per you and then refuse to share information citing regulation. While people might forget the story they will remember the CEO who wanted to convince people but citing no evidence.

Lastly, you keep replying in a hostile manner to everyone. It is not helping your case.


it's absolutely my bad -- when you have been doing this for 4 years, and a team works incredibly hard to do a trade that makes a lot of sense, seeing comments like i've seen here on this thread just straight up hurts. and again, i simply cannot share certain pieces of information. i would literally go to jail, so it's frustrating to see the stuff that is posted about us (and I'm a YC alum on top of that)


You're the CEO of this company? Well congrats on the WSJ article.

Can I ask who books writing a large trade like this? Basically are you making this market and $1 million dollar trade like this would need to contact you guys to write it OTC? Or is the crypto options market supply that big and liquid already that a buyer can just come along and buy $1 million worth of Dec 18 Bitcoin call options that will clear?


not OTC -- it's centrally cleared by us.


Does anyone here even have any experience in NYC, or on Wall Street?

Wall street knows what business it's in...lots of them. It does bond research, equity research, investment management, sales and trading, and yes, investment banking (to raise capital to all these poor companies that can't find anyone to pay millions of dollars in fees to do)

Do people really think that there are no investment bankers who raise capital anymore? That because of HFT, a job that pays 1mm a year when you're 30 has no more interest to anybody? That there are so many humanities majors graduating from princeton and harvard that normally do client relationship investment banking but because of HFT, they are going to write algorithms and optimize OS code for latency instead?

Have people seen how many layoffs are happening in investment banking division on wall street? (where they raise the capital for companies) It is NOT A ZERO SUM GAME. HFT doing well is NOT AT THE EXPENSE OF CAPITAL RAISING.

What kind of point is this? Is it even informed by any facts?


No, most of the people here have no experience in high-end trading. And no, it's not informed by facts. It's very frustrating, but if it's any consolation, it's the same kind of struggle against ignorance that occurs on threads about cryptography (a nerd subject) or language design (another nerd subject).

Personally, I'm not irritated at the nerds (after all, I'm one of them) so much as I am at places like Zero Hedge and Rolling Stone which prey on the ignorance of nerds to drive up pageviews.


Agreed, those blogs/publications are horrendous. Just factual stuff that is wrong all over the place. I wouldn't mind if people had concerns, as long as they realize it's a very complicated subject, so maybe they should ask questions, instead of making stupid assertions that are clearly false and try to sound like experts in a subject they've thought about for 10 minutes.


Zero Hedge was an excellent site in its early days before it became popular. Most of the good contributors have left the site, understandably.

And Matt Taibbi was responsible for the legendary characterization of Goldman Sachs as a "great vampire squid wrapped around the face of humanity."


I'm having a very hard time responding to the idea that extraordinarily bad technical reporting on the trading markets is redeemed by colorful writing. Is he a journalist or a poet?

I get it: people like reading this stuff. That's why they write it that way. But I'm saying, like reading it or don't like reading it, a lot of the underlying facts being reported are laughable.


It is not a zero sum game between you and HFT. It IS a zero sum game between an HFT firm and another HFT firm, or an HFT firm versus people specialist traders. You think that burly guy from queens who used to be a janitor and now works on the floor of the NYSE will give you a good price? HFT cuts the line in the sense that it competes with him to give you a better price. HFT firms are fast to compete for your business vs other HFT firms. HFT and the average retail investor is not a zero sum game. It is mostly zero sum between HFT and the old system of specialist traders. It turns out the biggest critics of HFT are the old specialists who have lost their jobs and people who do not know what they are talking about.

So say you trade against an HFT algorithm. If you are talking about the narrow context of the trade, it is zero sum. But that is not how the world works. Bill Gates can sell a share of Microsoft to a market maker trader/HFT. Say he does this for $26.00. Tomorrow, it goes to $30.00. In the context of the trade, Bill Gates "loses" $4 to the HFT algorithm. But that is not the whole story. He took that $26 and did something with it. Maybe he helped fund a startup which has created value and doubled his money. So now the HFT trader is up $4, and Bill Gates is up $26. Zero sum, huh? Or maybe he invested it in a Malaria vaccination program that has no easy dollar valuation but is clearly positive to the world. This is why in the context of the system, everyone can win, and it can be a positive sum game.

If you invested your savings 18 years ago for your kid to go to college, at some point you will sell that stock to raise cash and pay for college. You are investing in your child's education, so that he can have a good life, invent things, cure cancer, solve P vs NP, improve Shor's algorithm, and more. That seems like a good return, even if 4 years later the HFT algorithm you sold your stock to made money because the stock went up.


When the world changes, prices change as well. As an HFT firm, you are always sending prices that are competitive for customers. HFT being fast is the effort to improve prices as quickly as possible, or admittedly, pull prices if they are no longer fair. Often, this is a typical scenario for an HFT firm…news comes out on a stock that is positive. The old bid for the stock was 20.00. That means if you are sending an order to sell your shares in the stock, to say, raise money to send your kids to a good college, you will hit the bid at 20.00. If HFT is not fast, you will get $20 for your share, even though the news hit 2 seconds ago. HFT algorithms compete for your business in the sense that they try to be fastest to improve that bid price to 20.05. If they are not fast, you get $20. If they are fast, then you get $20.05. What is the problem here?


The bottom line of all this misunderstanding is, I believe, a distrust of where all this money is coming from that they make. It's simple--it's from them cannibalizing the old human, specialist trader business (do you know how many billions they made from retail before HFT?). It's no different from a startup upending an old industry veteran by undercutting their prices by 90% and taking away all their business.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: