Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | more pythonRon's commentslogin

The Linux desktop does need work, but it's not 100% up to speed yet, either. The ultimate UX can be found when the user has 100% control over the experience and we aren't there yet. Wayland won't allow window size/position to be remembered between sessions and too many UX designers think the desktop is just a big phone. Yes, we need work on UX and the first step should be to get Wayland to allow the user the same flexibility we enjoyed with X11. Using Linux with multiple screens means reverting to X11 just to keep from going nuts.


> Wayland won't allow window size/position to be remembered between sessions

It's not on the program itself to restore its position, but on the compositor, who has every right and control to do just that. AFAIK it does work in plasma Wayland.


That sounds great, but I don't fully agree... IMO a compositor should be able to provide a data structure (unchangeable, mostly or fully opaque) that the app can save/restore across sessions.


I don't get how that would work.


You'd ask for your window positioning data on close and restore it on open.


But then what's the point, what do you do with it that the compositor can't?

Then instead have stable window IDs so the compositor can do its job properly - there is absolutely no need to self-position and outside of certain privileged apps I absolutely don't want random programs to move their windows around.


Stable window IDs? Are you gonna use the document path and the panel number or something?


I wasn't aware of this proposal, but I pretty much nailed it and though of the same thing: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=49836487


That's the problem. The compositor can't reliably distinguish windows, and it definitely doesn't know when the data should be deleted in case the same window never opens again.


The session restore protocol requires the client to tag its windows with a string. See https://wayland.app/protocols/wayland-protocols/18#xdg_sessi... for details.


Most people are not remotely concerned about having "100% control over the experience". They want something reliable and understandable.

Only a relatively small subset of tech enthusiasts want to tweak everything, and there are PLENTY of options for those people.


Oh, here we go, another entity to blame for failings of judgement.


I feel very lucky in that I bought a handful of SSDs mere months before the prices went insane. RAM, not so much, especially for my new laptop which demands DDR5. It may be a while before I can expand that past the 16GB that came with it.


I dabbled with Flet for a couple of weeks and all I can say is: I wish it were further along in development. Either that, or had more documentation and examples available. I love that it targets all platforms and that it's so easily distributable, but where I ran into problems was with layouts in general and aligning controls with one another specifically. I was ready to drop all other GUI toolkits before I ran into that snag. Perhaps in another year or two I'll take another look.


The layout documentation is a real weak point in Flet. I believe it's essentially as powerful as Flutter, which is also really hard to figure out but at least there's a million blog posts about it and AI understands it. Flet repackages that power (mainly in its Container widget) in a way that's probably more sensible, but if they'd religiously stuck to Flutter's API (or just had really good documentation) then at least you'd be able to figure it out.


This was just business as usual 50 to 100 years ago. People started at the bottom and worked their way up. There were no I've-got-a-degree shortcuts because degrees weren't about training for a job, they were about finding out about the world around us. It's interesting that things are starting to circle around, but I doubt any corporation will drop the degree requirements... unless AI CEO's start rejecting all human applications.


As a high school dropout, with a GED, I can relate. Pretty much all of my education has been OJT and seminars/classes.

It's earned me lots of sneers, over the years, but the people that mattered, didn't care. I spent most of my career at one of the world's best optical equipment companies, working as a peer with some of the top people in the world. It was quite humbling, and extremely gratifying.


I'm trying to find my focus again. After using AI agents for about a year, I've lost my ability to concentrate on anything for more than a few minutes.


It's good to see the jobs of CEO's finally being threatened. Let's go after those who sit on corporate boards next, please.


I was interested in reading the article but, like so many I find online these days, the white text on black makes my eyes throb to the point of giving me a headache if I don't stop after a few seconds. so I have to give it a miss. I've read that white text on a black background is easier on the eyes, but it's obviously not universal.


It’s not perfect but I’ve just tested and reader mode does work for this website.


What would get me to stay with Linux (I've been going back and forth for the last few years) would be a fully-featured File Explorer work-alike complete with previews of every file type and a full-on context menu copy. One other thing... the ability to right-click any program icon and pin it to the taskbar. They're little things, but whenever I find myself on Windows 11, those are the things I find I missed most... well, other than being able to run File Locator Pro, NotePad++, and Bulk Rename natively.

Oh, and getting some part of the OS/window manager to remember window placement/size. Wayland/GTK don't and this is NOT an innovation, it's trying to turn the desktop into a phone.


> a fully-featured File Explorer work-alike complete with previews of every file type and a full-on context menu copy

Corel LinuxOS did this at the turn of the century. Xandros took it even further.

Sadly, although a company is still around and owns the names, they do not use any of the original code.

Xandros's version of KDE 2 was the best Linux desktop of its era and it wasn't even close. By a decade later, Ubuntu Unity took that role, but a lot of people don't know how to drive Windows by keyboard, and aren't willing to learn new things, so they hated it -- especially here on HN, which called for it to be cancelled, and Canonical listened.


KDE has that?


Perhaps this AI CEO will bring an end of all this over-paying of top management. Running a corporation isn't rocket science; it's just a matter of putting profit above everything else. Any idiot can do that.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: