Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | runlaszlorun's commentslogin

Awesome, thx for posting. I now have my new next book to read. Been wanting to read more of the original cybernetics stuff.

Would you also recommend "The Human Use of Human Beings"?


Yes, it starts slow with a lot of history of Cybernetics stuff through Leibniz and stuff (kind of prescient given chain rule -> back propagation, and control theory's relevance to optimizers). It is about twice as long as God & Golem and covers a lot of the same plus more examination of automation and human augmentation. I think either it or Cybernetics also goes into mass communication with some relevance to how social media played out.

God & Golem is the most succinct and up to date though, probably a 2hr read.

The book Cybernetics is a lot of math and ergodic theory stuff that went beyond me, but is the longest and you still get a lot out of it skimming over that stuff if you don't have the background for it. The last revision of it in the 50s added some of the same blackbox function copying/imitation learning/distillation stuff, reinforcement learning with reward hacking concerns, and superintelligence as genie/monkey's paw.

I would read the three in reverse order of publication.

He also foresaw another big area of potential existential danger, Wiener filter for guidance and control of missiles (later superceded with Kalman filter bringing the nuclear hard targets era with 15min retaliation windows) and refused to work on it or share prior work, and he also had bioweapons delivery concerns before the bioweapons treaties, publishing this open letter in The Atlantic in 1947:

https://archive.ph/D7BPt


I'm in. What's next?


Invest in local and open source LLMs. They are not as advanced as proprietary ones, but we can all use them and define them as the standard. We don't need closed models


Use your brain to solve problems not a computer.


Local LLMs.

Krasis is one such tool that allows large models using blended GPU/RAM.

ik_llama for better performance than llama.

ComfyAI for local image generation.

Nanocrab seems better for orchestration. Still need a good system capability firewall.


Who’s buying the memory for this effort?


Think how cheap its gonna be when everyone abandons the cloud providers and they start selling the 50B of hardware they over-invested in


I got 96GB of DDR5 ram 2y ago for $300.

Which now, 32GB goes for $300. Fucking insane. But prices will eventually come down as the enterprise and corpo scalpers realize AI is a losing deal for human replacement. Nvidia has already said as much.

https://fortune.com/2026/04/28/nvidia-executive-cost-of-ai-i...



This is hilarious but... and I can't believe Im actually giving critique here... but a modern day, LinkedIn version would be couched in words like "exceedingly complex", "multi-domain", "system of systems", etc.

But the whole thing is brilliant. And #GrowthMindset at the end is absolute gold.


I'll confess to only have skimmed TFA but I love this idea.


I'm def adding "slippery semantic slopes" to my vocab.


You pretty much nailed it. I can't even get outraged at any given instance now that the trendline is so staggeringly clear.

I can't see anyway this ends well for the US. I say this as both an American and a military veteran.


Never in history has an authoritarian ceded power without massive violence.


The dissolution of the USSR was not massively violent.

Frederick VII of Denmark, an absolute monarch, introduced parliamentarism without any violence or even broad public pressure.

And thats just what I can remember without digging.


Um. No, that's not how it works...


Oh my gosh. I was hoping that book had died a terrible death...


Best comment of the day. In three words no less...


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: