Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | ryan_n's commentslogin

The other big difference between the two is that after the last election, Musk (with Trumps help) essentially put himself in a position where he basically controlled the federal government for 6 months and did whatever he wanted with no consequences. It's a lot easier to commit crimes when you fire all the people who are trying to stop you..

The questions weren't poorly informed just because you agree with what Jensen was saying. He seems pretty obviously to have made drastically poor judgement decisions that potentially affect national security of the US. I don't know if I would consider that to be a huge loss to the US.

The poorly informed part is the assumption that if Nvidia doesn't sell chips China AI dev will stop.

It clearly didn't - don't you remember the Deepseek launch where it came as a rude shock that the much vaunted concept of a compute capacity moat was blown away?

He kept repeating that while he made the best chips, computer science was more important.


>affect national security of the US

Like what? Do you think Jensen knows about some state secrets?

To me it looks like the whole thing was merely about circumventing export controls on graphic cards to sell them for $$$?


Yea my understanding is that is also what it was about. I don't know if he knows state secrets or not. The affect on national security is more that if he's selling billions of dollars of GPU's to foreign adversary's he's helping foreign adversary's gain power over the US. The video in question talks about how selling GPU's is like selling enriched uranium, thus the national security concern. Whether that's a good analogy or not, I don't really know. But the people at these AI companies (ANT/OpenAI) do seem to talk a lot about how there's a non-zero chance AI will end the world so..

Even the not-frontier models are not hallucinating 1 out of every 10 times. Insane claim with zero data to back it up.

It was a hallucination.

> I really don't understand why people can't see the future, in ten years the speed at which AI will create apps will be astonishing.

Why do you assume people don't understand this? I think most people, especially those on HN are painfully aware of this.


> Gov't handouts and moats are provided to lots of companies. All over the world. > But somehow, those handouts and moats have produced exactly zero credible competitors for SpaceX and Starlink.

Almost no companies in the world get the same level of gov subsidies that starlink/spacex gets. If you exclude other big gov contractors (no reason why you should do that, just to illustrate the point I guess) the number is basically 0. Also, there are several other companies that are direct competitors with Starlink but they haven't been as successful. I don't know if that's due to a funding issue or something else, but I doubt it's due to lack of technical ability. Not sure the Magnus comparison is too relevant here..


Where are these SpaceX subsidies?

I keep hearing about them but can't find the cash anywhere.


A short history of doing bad things is still a history of doing bad things..


> Attribution is important

Amazing how quickly people forget how these AI companies gained their fortune. The whole existence of modern LLM's is due to taking (stealing) other peoples work without attribution.

> what matters is the journey of human knowledge

This is probably a lot easier to accept when you haven't dedicated your entire life to a specific field of research, and then are made significantly less relevant by a machine.


Serious question: why would he be "heavily" quoted in physics books? I didn't think he was a physicist, is he?


It's not limited to textbooks or academic publications, or based on any context whatsoever, but an ngram search actually suggests there's a much larger musk stain on recent published literature than I'd ever thought possible:

https://books.google.com/ngrams/graph?content=Elon+Musk%2CAl...

Make of that what you will.


I don't understand how to filter this to physics books


I wasn't trying to imply that, simply noting that there was a surprising amount of literary chatter about Musk, at high levels compared to commonly cited physicists. It's not the most useful comparison.

It could easily be people writing fanfic about him (ugh) or criticising the pants off him, and may not be related at all. But I'd guess a lot of this was field-adjacent to at least his business interests.


We need to get to the bottom of why people believe stuff like that, and fix it.


It's money.

If you have a lot of money and you've managed to stay out of prison, people are generally ready to believe good things about you and want to be in your good graces. If you pay people to continually say good things about you and manage your media appearances for you, there will generally be a lot of impact to that. You're just telling people what they're primed to believe. A lot of people will fluff up your image for free just because they're hoping for patronage.

Musk has a BA in physics that was awarded a couple years after he says he says he completed his studies. Unlike CPSC, leaving a physics program early robs you of some pretty crucial stuff. You generally don't see a lot of rockstar physicists leaving university early to join startups. Despite Musk posing as a rocket scientist, engineering guru, etc., there's no evidence he's one of the scientific or engineering minds behind Tesla or SpaceX's work. He's just a money guy.

The general rule for money guys is that the closer you are to the money, the more of it you can get. This is why CEO's are paid outrageous sums. Musk is the closest guy to the money at his companies, and his one true gift seems to be "getting close" to politicians in order to get the public's money, which Tesla and SpaceX have received gob-smacking amounts of.

If you want a laugh, go look up the episode of Dan Carlin's Hardcore History addendum where he brought Musk on. Carlin typically interviews authors of history books, so why Musk? Why indeed! During this episode, it comes out that Musk used to have models of WWII planes but clearly knows absolutely nothing about history. Despite this, he makes every effort to sound like he does. This is the sort of exposure $$$ gets you but, sometimes, you miss the mark.


Reality distortion field. Same reason Jobs is held up as an amazing visionary.


That assumption has certainly been vindicated, considering what happened to Apple after he was gone.


A 5 trillion dollar company?


That produces the blandest corporate safe slop.


Who’s to say that it’s not a calculated decision to not follow in Jobs’ footsteps, and not some sort of “skill issue”?


Long before a company reaches 5 trln, everything at that level is a calculated decision.

Also, what is a brand if not a intentional ‘reality distortion’?


You're fighting a losing war against human laziness and gullibility.


I guess some people still like to troll? Or are so dumb they’ve obviously never even cracked a physic text? I’m hoping it’s just old fashioned trolling.



In the "Read On" section at the bottom it says "Author's notes: The one page written by a human." Seems they're pretty open about everything being written with Claude.


> They study this. [Gen Z is 10x more accepting of violence to suppress speech they object to compared to Boomers.](https://expression.fire.org/p/gen-z-is-10-times-more-accepti...)

Seems like this is a direct result of being more exposed to the internet. I'm not sure it's their fault when they are raised with ipads in their lap and multi-billion dollar corporations are shoving propaganda (both sides) down everyone's throat 24/7. I wonder if boomers and gen x would feel the same if they grew up the same way.

> It seems history really does repeat. People are going to need to experience some authoritarianism to remember why we care so much about free speech.

Not sure making people experience authoritarianism is the best way to make people remember why free speech is important. That seems more extreme than anything I've read on Reddit lately. Surely there are better solutions.


Not just Internet, but the most abhorrent version of it, aka algorithmic rage-bait machine the Web 2.0 had become.

I can see why people don't value free speech anymore, when the speech had become mostly astroturfing curated by algorithms.

Censorship is the wrong direction, but I see where it coming from emotionally, mass Internet today is an abomination. It wasn't like that when I discovered it.


To be clear I’m not suggesting that that is my preferred outcome. I’m worried that that is what this new generation will vote for. Then when they get it, they’ll realise what they lost, and they’ll have to fight to get it back again.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: