Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | shit_game's commentslogin

>Why get an expensive Pi when I have an old phone?

>I’ve unlocked and rooted the Redmi

Herein lies the issue. I don't know fuck all about phones. I don't want to. They are engineered to keep me out, and that is a pain in the ass I don't want to deal with when doing hardware work. I want to own something that works the second I get it and doesn't fight me the entire way. Sure, I could let an LLM guide me through it or even do it for me, but why bother when the whole point of the hardware is for me to fuck off and use it as a subscriber to the OEM and carrier? This is tedium, removed by further spending. Not to mention documentation - what bullshit is the OEM hiding in their board or firmware thats going to ruin my day? I'm sure that some of these devices are great for reuse as a self contained server with media and modem, but is my old phone going to do this?

I'm not gonna spend $50 on ewaste to try to do something unless I want to use that ewaste (old keyboards, old toys? :3). Old phones are a non-sequitur because, again, they're engineered to keep me out.


>>Herein lies the issue. I don't know fuck all about phones. I don't want to. They are engineered to keep me out, and that is a pain in the ass I don't want to deal with when doing hardware work.

I mean, you do know we're on a forum called hacker news, right?

In most cases it's not some magic voodoo process that you need an LLM for, it's the first result on Google and one command to run or in some cases you just hold two buttons together when booting up and click the unlock button.

Like, I completely understand your perspective and desire to have things which "just work"(I'm in the same boat a lot of the time lately) but like, let's be realistic - rooting an old phone and running some software on it is really not a big deal, I'd hope especially for people on here.


True for modern mid-high range models of mainstream brands. But some devices are just that hacker unfriendly.

> One of my favorite genres of psychology experiment is called something like: “the study is probably bullshit but the effect is probably real”. At the top of that heap is The Illusion of Control, a classic from 1975 and a favorite of Psych 101 classes everywhere. Usually, this study gets summarized as “people value their lottery tickets more when you let them pick the numbers vs. when you pick the numbers for them.” It’s as if people think that the mere act of picking imbues their ticket with a bit of juju, which makes them less willing to part with it.

> That would be a beautiful study, but it wasn’t the study that was actually conducted. The “lottery tickets” in question were in fact football cards, each one with a picture of a player, their team, etc. Some participants were given the opportunity to choose their football card and some had a card handed to them. Later, just before the drawing, all of the participants were asked how much it would take to buy their card back. On average, the pickers asked for $8.67, while the not-pickers said $1.86.4

> I’m sure you can see the obvious and less exciting explanation for these results: when people were given the chance, they picked their favorite players. The people who didn’t get to pick ended up with a card they liked less. This “illusion of control” effect is merely a “reality of people having preferences and acting on them” effect.5

Alternatively, people who are knowledgeable of a subject will have selfishly biased opinions about it, which they value more than unknowledgeable people will value an arbitrary stance on the subject. From experience, this seems to affect things beyond situations of chance like lotteries, and infests collaborations like businesses in ways such as Not Invented Here Syndrome or generally poor management choices that fail to consider situational factors (e.g. overarching decrees that are ineffective in certain situations/locations/applications).


A lot of lottery players will say use a birthday or something. Kind of interesting to think about this as deciding on pure random search or setting a seed and sampling that seed over the space. The behavior becomes much less about juju and maybe more an actual functional one with some biological utility, this ability to sample a defined input across a function set. The lottery aspect is almost blinding the point of why it might be useful to think like that.

About (dear lord) 30 years ago when the national lottery came to the shores of Britain, my family had the neighbours over and there was some faux hand holding "seance/trance" make-pretend, with us spitting out numbers for the very first lottery ticket. We won a tenner!

Silliness of the highest order. I still have those numbers written down. They've got the same chance as any other set - but this set are _mine_. I might just be the only person alive who was there, now I reflect upon it. Huh


> A lot of lottery players will say use a birthday or something.

Ironically, this makes the ticket less valuable.

You can't do anything to change the probability of winning, but you can change the probability of winning at the same time as other players (which affects the size of the winnings). By picking birthdays (i.e. forcing the numbers to be in the first 30 or so), your prize, if you do win, is likely to be smaller than a really random selection.


>Alternatively, people who are knowledgeable of a subject will have selfishly biased opinions about it, which they value more than unknowledgeable people will value an arbitrary stance on the subject. From experience, this seems to affect things beyond situations of chance like lotteries, and infests collaborations like businesses in ways such as Not Invented Here Syndrome or generally poor management choices that fail to consider situational factors (e.g. overarching decrees that are ineffective in certain situations/locations/applications).

And the ignorant are always the loudest.

The fresh minted safety guy with his shiny new clipboard and vest is a fool running around the plant spewing rabid idiocy straight out of the internet comment section about how everything is non-optimal.

His boss who's been doing things for a decade is more measured, knows you can't tell a guy how to use a screwdriver if you also want to tell him how to use a ladder.


This is a ridiculous take. The reason that "people" are floating the idea of placing datacenter in space - despite the MASSIVE downsides present (cooling, maintenence, latency, availability, cost, etc.) is because you can't firebomb a datacenter thats in space as easily as you can one thats in your suburb. The regulatory friction behind a datacenter buildout is a low concern, and something that is "affordable" for hyperscalers and billionaires. Buying someones farm and building a private powerplant is small potatoes. But being terrestrial, angry people can show up and destroy it if they feel so inclined. It's much, much harder for angry plebs to launch something into orbit and then hit a moving target.

Just notice that your random $enemy_country can indeed destroy a datacenter in space much more easily than they can destroy one in suburb of one of your cities.

That tells a lot about who decision makers are optimizing against.


This is legitimately the stupidest comment I've seen on HN all year. One of these people have devoted billions of dollars to eradicating disease, providing education, developing living conditions and essential infrastructure, and improving quality of life and life expectancy for the worlds poorest, globally, for decades. The other has cozied up to corrupt kleptocrats and every other manner of scum to benefit himself while enriching himself at the expense of everyone else, particularly in his recent quest to become the worlds first trillionaire.

The temptation to succumb to Godwin's Law is so, so, so strong. How shitty and horrible of a person does one have to be for someone on HN to admit that they are a shitty and bad person? At some point the Big Bang sterotype of "nerd" who jerks off to the idea of a rich guy who "computers" and "businesses" and "engineers" outgrows tiresome and becomes despicable once said rich guy facilitates/encourages/actualizes concentration camps. Grow up.


The black pill for me is that these people's votes count equally


The introduction gives me strong PoCorGTFO vibes. I miss writing with personality, regardless of how I care for it.

I love the jank present. It validates me.


>I simply stopped worrying and began to love the bomb

This may apply to the consequences of ones data being subject to so many breaches and leaks and thefts, but it should not be the attitude one adopts towards the idea of ones data being taken and used by so many parties. At some level, my data is my personhood - it is my evidence of myself, and my record of myself, and my proof of myself. It encodes who I talk to, what I'm interested in, where I go, and what I do. My health, my finances, my habits, vices, schedule, family, friends, coworkers, beliefs. People more clever than myself use this data to advertise to me; people more powerful use this data to surveil me. When will people more malevolent use this data to persecute me?

I should not have to love the bomb because the bomb will kill me.


Yes, that's the direct subtext of that phrase.


Some of us are more practical than ideological, but we tend not to put as much energy into communicating our views as the ideological types. The result online is an often distorted sense of the universality and importance of ideology. You feel That your data is part of your personhood? I feel that it’s more like tracks in the woods and scat.


Loss of privacy has no upsides. The bomb, on the other hand, saved many millions of lives over the last 80 years, so it works as a metaphor everyone shares, but the metaphor itself was always much more arguable with nukes. It's possible to actually rationally love the bomb, but what are the upsides for everything about me being exfiltrated at will?


I don't disagree about privacy being valuable, but I don't think you quite understood my writing. "The Bomb" in this conversation is not the literal atom bomb. Perhaps the Dr. Strangelove metaphor confuses this for some, but "The Bomb" in this context is "all my shit got ganked by hackers and now my indentity is forever stolen by anyone who pays a dollar". I don't believe that this shares any semblance of metaphor with the nuclear threat - the threat is individual, survivable, and its consequences yet-unknown because of these two factors. It's arugably pretty rational for someone to be favorable of a nuclear device in its capability of facilitating MAD (and arguably uneasy peace) at a national scale - I don't believe anyone could ever reasonably argue that global perpetual inescapable indefensible identity theft (with the added bonus of potential for persecution) is worth reading license plates or sniffing bluetooth or capturing residential internet traffic in order to "catch terrorists" or "save children" (neither of which has ever actually been done with these methods).


The upside is that you can know everything of almost any person as well. Whether that upside is beneficial for you is a different matter.


We have almost universal capture of ID and biometric information (like it's on your driver's license or passport), you have to present it in many places in the US, airplane checkin, car rental, hotel. It sure helps the government track you better, because at various points they do crap like capture your bluetooth watch or headphone id and associate it with you. You car has similar things.

Then when an evil force gets in power, like in the US, they can use it along with other ubiquitous info like the US' dystopian FLOCK and other cameras. Then an evil government can and pretty easily arrest people, find them.

I don't know about every person, only the government does. Abusers of power in the government or law enforcement know. Eventually wherever you live, an evil entity will get access to the data, an Idiocracy type government will come into power.

And as this thread talks about, nefarious hackers will be drawn to steal all data from these convenient government repositories. Now they can have much more accurate looking fake id, steal your identity even more deeply, and I would guess will look for blackmail opportunities.


It tracks terrorists' efforts to acquire the bomb.


Oh, but of course there is. He you ever seen arguments from the other side? It is to catch criminals of various sorts (money laundering, trafficking, smuggling goods and people, terrorism etc), to keep children safe etc etc.

Also,it can help you uncover and put behind bars your dangerous political enemies. That the tables may turn and the shoe may be on the other foot soon, that's too abstract of a thought to occur to most of them.


well isn’t the point of the movie that if you have a doomsday-(dead man switch)-device you should let everyone know?

I don’t get that comparison with data being available everywhere


No, todays Jagex is just as oblivious and short-sighted as ever. They don't only make OSRS. It took Jagex over a decade to remove Treasure hunter (microtransaction gambling) from the game despite its addition (and continued operation at the obvious requirement of whatever of several, 7-ish? PE firms owned the studio). It was added for the obvious goal of increasing revenue on top of subscription cost, but grew into a game feature that overcame traditional levelling and moneymaking in exchange for real world payments. There was a period of about 5 years where the meta for training any skill was to kill engdame bosses and then gamble with the gold you made, using the xp rewarded from treasure hunter to level up. It was simply a more efficient use of time to train any of the 26 skills by not training any of the skills and instead gambling. It was so bad that they added an option for this interface to gamble multiple times upon a single user input and automatically redeem the rewards.

OSRS as a product is unique in the MMO space because it really is a product of passion. RS3, the former Jagex cash cow, was a product of a private equity. Now, after over a decade of profit extraction, everyone I knew who played it has long since quit because the updates became sparse, the artstyle because sanitized and generic, and the game mechanics became predatory. I don't blieve that any specifics have ever been made public, but the general understanding is that OSRS is largely unmolested because the playerbase were provably people who violently reject microtransactions, and the private equity owners would have killed their best possible investment by modelling it after RS3.

Jagex the company, for all its success, is a bad game studio. Look into all their shuttered and unreleased games, and their declining playerbases. Christ, their Transformers Universe game went live for a public beta and was shuttered after 2 weeks with full refunds, at the development expense of Stellar Dawn. OSRS is an anomaly that Jagex is lucky to have, and not something they are capable of recreating.


That was a year+ ago, which notably is when they decided to clean the game up. I don't see the point of using the past as an example when they very explicitly (like it was the very first set of criticisms aired in their keynote yesterday) are trying to move away from that.

What you're describing at the end is an attempt for a company to diversify and cutting their losses early to stem bleeding from projects which wouldn't have met the expected ROI. Gaming is a difficult industry and the majority of games do not get big. It's not surprising that the majority of their efforts to branch out failed.

None of your criticisms of the main game apply during the past year of updates. That + their attempt to create "sanitized" servers this year looks like another attempt to diversify - away from the microtransaction-based revenue source into a stable subscription source, assuming they get the playercounts.


It's insulting because RS/RS3 was designed from the perspective that everything leads to everything else. Prior to the sixth age, and I'm not calling that a mistake, and especially MTX, skills had a certain curve and quest lines made sense

What the MTX team apparently did is pocket all of it while not using the money to improve the game

Whether or not they're doing a good job now, their behavior across many years was/is despicable


A significant factor in vapes not overtaking cigarettes is the tobacco lobby; they pay to play in legislature to ban vapes and associated paraphernalia in many US states, as well as create their own vape products to play both sides of the market. It's difficult to use vapes to quit smoking cigarettes when vape juice and single use vapes get banned, yet cigarettes remain legal.


"I am not <this thing>, but if I were, I'd have <this opionion> about it." isn't a terribly convincing argument. Opinions (good ones, at least) are shaped by experience - what experience is there to shape your opinion on AI affecting art when you aren't an artist?


People could return to burning down enterprises that they find unsavory or detrimental to society, such as they did during the industrial revolution, but this is problematic in that it's violent and not something the modern person often considers as viable. A part of why people consider this unviable now is in-part due to the consequences of these surveilance technologies. It's difficult to accomplish a revolution when everyone is being spied on all the time.


“Citizens will be on their best behavior because we are constantly recording and reporting everything that’s going on”

- Larry Ellison (Oracle Corporation)


The shortest path answer is a bit too caveman-esque to survive its application to reality.

That said, I think there is a lot of appeal to go hunting for firms, since it really feels like corporations and their owners are engaging in predatory behavior as opposed to customer centric behavior.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: