Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | snowbeing's commentslogin

i would argue that obsidian has a better UI than apple notes, but it unfortunately isn't open source.

I feel like the massive difficulty in self-hosting a sync server is intentional sabotage to make you pay for their cloud service.

I can understand the economic reasons why but I don’t love it.


If that were true Obsidian wouldn't let you sync for free with iCloud, or provide guides to alternatives on the official Help site [1], or have a syncing category on the Community site with hundreds of plugins to choose from for every alternative service you can think of [2]. The truth is that Obsidian is a really small team, and there many many different services and ways to sync, so we prefer to focus our energy on making the core app.

[1]: https://obsidian.md/help/sync-notes

[2]: https://community.obsidian.md/search?type=plugin&categories=...


Isn't being able to sync your own plain files the most simple thing to do, how is this intentional sabotage?

See for yourself. It’s nowhere near as easy as it sounds.

First follow these steps:

https://github.com/vrtmrz/obsidian-livesync#1-choose-a-synch...

Then set up your first device:

https://github.com/vrtmrz/obsidian-livesync/blob/main/docs/q...

Non-intentional sabotage would be Obsidian providing the server and supporting it as a first-class option where you just paste in your server URL into the app without the need for a convoluted third-party plugin.


You are just syncing files like you would sync any other file, you don't need such a complex setup, that's overkill for most.

Use whatever you already use, Google Drive, SyncThing fork, whatever.

A quick comparison of much simpler approaches: https://bryanhogan.com/blog/how-to-sync-obsidian


I've never tried to set it up, but how difficult can it be? Won't an LLM just set it up for you?

I don’t think that expecting end users to finish the software themselves with an LLM is a very good user experience.

Check my other comment in this thread, see the setup steps for yourself. I think they’re way harder than they should be for something as simple as a notes app, and it shouldn’t require a third-party plugin in the first place. They should just provide a server docker container and then the app should let you connect to an arbitrary URL without this very long and technical process.

Yes you can just use a cloud folder for storage (iCloud only on iOS) but that’s not the full feature set including live sync.


On an iOS device the options are limited. On Android it's fairly easy. This made me stay with Android when my phone died.

Oh, I thought you meant the server itself, not the clients.

Obsidian is purely file based, a you can use anything that syncs files (w.g. Google Drive) , but you need a shared filesystem across multiple apps for that.

This is not 100% true as features like live sync require couchdb.

Try Git, Try Quartz to host your notes.

they both work on Helium, which is Chromium-based!


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: