Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | stupiduser's commentslogin

Anecdotally, it wasn't true of Einstein.


"Free markets" are a disaster; without protectionist measures the United States would still be pursuing its comparative advantage against Great Britian--we'd be selling them beaver skins and acorns in exchange for their manufactured goods. All of the protectionist Asian countries have done gangbusters in the last half-decade or so; meanwhile all of the countries that have had "free markets" forced on them (which certainly does NOT include the United States) have in comparison done terrible (think Africa, Latin America).


It cuts both ways. Take a heavily state-controlled market like the entire US system during and after WWII and claim the gains are due to the free market.


It's true that we should be wary of the post hoc, ergo propter hoc fallacy. In this case, I think the right lesson is that markets are so robust that they can tolerate a lot of abuse before buckling. For example, to bolster agricultural prices during the New Deal, the federal government paid farmers not only to stop growing crops, but to plow perfectly good crops under. Frédéric Bastiat himself (of broken window and candlemaker petition fame) couldn't come up with a better reductio ad absurdum, and yet it was implemented as real policy in a time of mass hunger. Nevertheless, America, and the world, survived and prospered. Recall also that even the Soviet Union, with an economic system about as bad as you can imagine, still lasted ~70 years.


Sorry, your post is just completely wrong because this is not a market situation. The government regulates banks through the FDIC, and implicitly underwrites the insurance that is granted to savings accounts. Therefore people have absolutely no incentive to pick "safe" savings accounts, where there savings are loaned out to "sure bets". Instead, if the bank has been covered by the FDIC, the only thing that matters to a consumer is the interest rate--he/she doesn't have to consider risk.


This boat is a great advertisement for progressive taxation; under more extreme progressive taxation Perkins would still have the biggest boat (which is all he really cares about), it just wouldn't have be nearly so big or wasteful =P.


The only federal taxes that about half Americans pay are for their retirement, and even that is subsidized by the other half.

Of the "not retirement" taxes, the vast majority is already paid by the "rich", with a huge fraction coming from the top 5% alone.

How much more progressive should the system be?

And, in Biden's words, shouldn't the rest of America be patriotic, ie pay taxes?


When the communists took power in China, mobs would go from house to house in what was euphemistically called "people's courts" The mob would bring out the capitalist, demonstrate all of the rewards of their work. Usually they would be whipped into a frenzy, the idea being that there was no way anybody needed any of that wealth.

Either you understand how deeply immoral that is or you don't.


I'd say it's a great advertisment for how much wealth that can be created in a relatively free economy. You don't see many mega yacht buyers from Cuba or North Korea.

And I think your thought of having the state stealing even more money from people is despicable.


Sort of like how Joel Spolsky makes more money via the job board on his blog than via sales of Fog Bugz. Hmm, doesn't some other blog have a job board as well?


Youtube doesn't do live video whatsoever. And yes, Justin was the guy with the camera strapped to his head 24/7. If a site doesn't make its history clear, you can usually check out wikipedia.


Plastic is heavier than water; are you suggesting that plastic bottles degrade into smaller plastic bottles?


That would be so cute!!!


>Every email I send through Gmail is Google's? No, but Google has a non-exclusive license to use it however they want.


Within the context of running and promoting the Services.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: