Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | teagee's commentslogin

None of what Wikimedia accuses OpenAI of seems technically novel, aside from having AI do the bidding. I can't imagine a company doing these things in the past and maintaining any sort of reputation. Is it really a matter of adding new regulation, or just treating them the way any other company would be treated?


Well, in the past, there was probably only a very small number of cases where some party hacked an institution and then worked with them to remedy the situation to the best of their abilities.

Which is not to say that any of this is okay and should just be excused, but failing to recognize this fairly significant difference is probably not a great start to any discussion about the issue.


If you break into my house and then work with me to the best of your ability to pay me back or repair the window, does that change the potential of your being charged with a crime?

It could change the sentencing maybe, I'm not sure.


> If you break into my house and then work with me to the best of your ability to pay me back or repair the window, does that change the potential of your being charged with a crime?

Yes, it does, because the damaged party is less likely to press charges. And when it came to sentencing, like you said, how the damaging party handled themselves would also be considered (in most western jurisdictions).


> less likely to press charges

It is an American Entertainment Industry misconception that victims (or anyone else) have the ability to tell the police or the prosecutors how and when to do their jobs.

Hypothetically, a private homeowner could choose not to report a break-in as a crime, since it wasn't violent, and it wasn't commercial property, and if the crooks are not gangstas or some other group-backed actor, then they could quietly put the crime to rest. This would also be a question of the insurance company's policy.

But if there were a crime that did damage, usually there is a question that comes up in the police report like, "as a victim, are you prepared to cooperate in the investigation?" and if you do not tick "yes" then you can probably count on nothing else being done whatsoever.

https://www.maricopa.gov/911/Remain-Silent

https://www.ajblawfirm.com/articles/understanding-pressing-c...


[flagged]


Now switch it to "your dog broke in and destroyed stuff", ya it's still damages but that have to be paid for, but crime gets much harder to prove.


Would be good for the supreme court to rule on a "blame the rogue agent" case.

Then we would find out if the argument doesn't hold (in which case there should be liability and dire consequences for the labs), or the argument holds (in which case YOLO, AI labs can blame the AI and we can all do it too).

At least that would make things consistent.


> Would be good for the supreme court to rule on a "blame the rogue agent" case

Have any of the private hacking victims sued? Maybe OpenAI is furiously settling in the shadows?


Well I think OpenAI’s reputation is also shot but it’s irrelevant to their valuation.


Is there any precedent from other industries where a company tries to frame their own product’s shortcomings appear to be society’s problem?

Would nytimes cover a self driving car company disclose concerning ‘behavior’ of their cars the same way?

For anyone who has had to remind a coding agent to not leave comments over and over again, not following instructions seems more feature than bug


Automobile manufacturers invented Jaywalking, right off the top of my head, but I'm sure there are more examples. Arguably the self-driving evangelists like to do that by using "but human drivers" as a way to argue for a technology that isn't ready yet.

When you consider how much money is at stake for a relative handful of people I'm not surprised at their desperation or deception.


They are just pushing for favorable legal environment before the Anthropic IPO.


This is an entirely pointless exercise without transparency into how these "unreleased" models are trained, what their RL goals and biases are and related RL data, what their system prompts are, what their environments are and its restrictions, etc. What good is it for the industry to say:

"Our unreleased model attempted to create a bioweapon", but "trust me bro, we didn't tell it to do that. We didn't train the model on a dataset that specializes in creating and glorifying bioweapons. We'd never stand to gain from misleading people about model capabilities in any way shape or form." - Anthropic are renowned for doing exactly this, for starters.

So this ends up resulting in more safety theater. You can't have anything fruitful come of this without transparency. Stop trying to protect your moat if you truly care about safety and actionable outcomes, and provide real transparency, otherwise this is as good as saying nothing at all.

I'm not even saying they're intentionally trying to do this by the way, but this is not sufficient if the goal is balanced incentives and accountability.


It's not only that but another aim is for them to ban the competition, US and domestic, including open source models.

Basically, the billionaire elites and their employees are panicking because they fear their funds are at risk when the bubble bursts.


I'll believe it when they confirm a date.


Perhaps they want to have their cake and eat it. Now that they are too big to be cancelled, they can both say "wooah so dangerous, don’t keep us accountable!”. And, well, keep doing what they’re doing…


Teething problems with early cars and planes crashing were kind of inherent to the industries developing more than failings of individual companies, maybe.


This is such an odd point of view. If I were in the business of nuclear energy, I would: 1. Want there to be quality rules that keep me free from lawsuits were things outside my control to go wrong 2. Want others to follow the rules too so the whole industry doesn't get shut down when an incident on the other side of the planet kills 1000s


Banking. The energy sector. Mining. Chemical industries.


Wouldn’t the equivalent in chemical be like Exxon having a blog post of their most damaging oil spills?


Yup, this is and a blog post outlining how dangerous climate change is and how they need to be regulated immediately to stop global extinction.


I think there is a major difference in that climate change is real, while AI companies are constantly hampering on about a threat which is basically just science fiction. It would be like if Exxon was constantly warning about oil drilling opening up a portal which would unleash monsters with 10% chance of killing all humans.

AI companies are still very silent about the actual risks of their products. That this is addictive, that it causes atrophy, that its usage among children is bad for their education, that in worst cases it psychosis, and is often used to harm others and for criminal activities.

This reminds me of the behavior of cigarette companies. Except instead of only staying silent on the risks of their products (and funding pseudo-scientific studies to muddy the waters) they invent risks which do not exist. And then use these stories as evidence for these made up risks. In the non-AI world this is called consumer hostile behavior, but in AI the fact that their products are faulty, and unsafe, is called misalignment.


Our fracking activity is causing the tap water to catch on fire, causing small earthquakes, and killing all the wildlife, so you (government) better stop us. But we can't stop because if we do, China might open up the hell portal first!


I think I heard that we’ll be fracking with nuclear materials soon so we can harvest the tritium water as a byproduct. Does anyone know if that’s just a wild, stupid theory that will never work, or an actual idea being explored? Sounds horrifying.


Issue is that other corps play by the same rules. If those corps are willing to stoop to immoral means and not get punished for it (they don't), the upstanding players are going to get outcompeted


“This is big oil pushing the climate hoax to spur regulation and prevent the impede upstarts from installing an oil rig on their own land!”


Recycling plastics is a huge lie that’s caused society to perform rituals that absolve them of the horrible impact they’re inflicting on the planet.

I don’t think this kind of gaslighting is unique or new, but the AI company’s specific melange of fear-mongering, disingenuous helplessness, ethics-washing, with a handy wildcard of regulatory capture is perhaps uniquely optimized and (so far) effective.


Big Agriculture (eg subsidies, dereg). Car manufacturers. Healthcare insurance (or insurance of any stripe when it comes to natural disasters and over-insuring and then needing bail outs).

It's almost like avoiding accountability for the sake of the share value is a systemic problem encouraged by the way we have currently arranged ourselves


Sorry, are you saying car companies begged to be regulated for safety , or they just followed guidelines and improved the safety of their cars without writing articles about how dangerous cars are and they should be taken off the road ?


I could see how the push for larger more profitable suvs and trucks in the name of safety is similar— the only reason they’re safer is because small cars get crushed by big cars



ah, I fail to see the parallels ?


maybe more explicitly this one: https://www.vox.com/2015/1/15/7551873/jaywalking-history

“In the 1920s, auto groups redefined who owned the city street. It was [originally the] drivers’ job to avoid you, not your job to avoid them,” says Peter Norton, a historian at the University of Virginia and author of Fighting Traffic: The Dawn of the Motor Age in the American City. “But under the new model, streets became a place for cars — and as a pedestrian, it’s your fault if you get hit.”

ie under the banner of "pedestrian safety" that was illustrated by numerous examples of grisly accidents, automobile manufacturing lobbyists pushed jay-walking laws and essentially took all city streets away from pedestrian use, entrenching reliance on cars for transportation and urban design to match

the idea here was to portray cars as inevitable, necessary things that were going to kill people anyway (just like how AI is inevitably going to lead to mass security breaches) and really it's the pedestrian's (or the maintainer's) job to avoid being harmed


It's still a different situation. In the example provided it seems like the car companies lobbied to make it a law that the "pedestrians" were at fault if they were hit for "jaywalking", thus absolving responsibility for pedestrian safety.

The equivalent to the "AI companies" pitch would've been the car companies lobbying to make cars much safer therefore raising the bar for competitors to join the market. Like if Henry Ford was the only person to own the patent for air bags and then lobbied hard to regulate that every car shipped with one.


I think this is too generous of an interpretation of OpenAI's and Anthropic's position. the 'slow down' mandate is not a real regulatory standard - policies are generally crafted based on good vs bad outcomes, not speed-of-development. the drive for this kind of specific, toothless regulation is done at the behest of large corporations looking at open-weight models eating their cake and realizing that any small player could now do so too if they had the compute backing them (places like Canopy Wave, for eg)

that it also serves as marketing material for just how capable their models are is just a cherry on top, I suppose


The equivalent in health insurance would be a blogpost listing out egregious denied claims. Sure they avoid accountability but these releases by OpenAI aren’t that


no, the equivalent would be marketing material claiming that their specialists help uncover denials that were being blocked but helpfully and so proactively these good insurance companies are hiring more middle managers to oversee that such a bad thing never happens again

the point of these 'disclosures' is AGI branding - wow we have such a dangerous new product, it (consciously, autonomously) escaped confinement!

their whole business is selling capability. and what better advertising than to say that your model is just a little too capable sometimes


"What has science done?!"


Privatize profits, socialize losses. Late-stage capitalism.


The chart in the tweet represents year-on-year growth. Based on these figures alone the actual number of people employed in tech is still really high, and the numbers can't just go up forever.

Also this only captures 6 industries, which is a narrow view of what would define "tech" these days.

Not to say that the job market isn't tough but this graph is a very narrow view


> The chart in the tweet represents year-on-year growth.

Can’t believe how many people are commenting without looking at what the chart means. We’ve lost 50k jobs last two years after decades of adding 100k+ every year including the pandemic highs of 300k+ per year. Total employment remains way above 2000s, 2008 and 2020 unlike the title suggests.


Tech has also changed to become an all encompassing thing. In 2000, loads of people didn't have computers or cell phones. Maybe they owned a CD player and watched TV. Tech was avoidable then. But now everyone has a phone in their pocket, a computer, does all their banking through apps instead of visiting the bank, orders food online, orders taxis through apps, and so on. Everything is lumped under tech now and unavoidably so.


Yeah but, there are like 100K CS/IT graduates in the US every year. Tech jobs increasing 100K per year was just maintenance.

Lotta people in tech are going to struggle to find a job. That's the point.


Yes, but how many people have tried to enter the field since then? Is the economy that supports current number of tech workers really better than one that supports 10x?


Thanks for pointing this out - title is extremely misleading. Total tech jobs is not lower than 2008 just because YoY is down.


No, the title is not misleading at all - your comment is misleading. Total tech jobs being up doesn't tell us anything, since there are also way more tech workers now than back then.

Over 100K people graduate in CS/IT per year, and that doesn't even count people who come in to the industry from overseas or from other degree paths.


"Tech employment now significantly worse than the 2008 or 2020" says the unemployment rate is higher today than in 2008 and 2020, but that is NOT what the chart shows.


General media, news, etc. gets this wrong all the time, see any commentary on inflation, GDP growth, rate of change in house prices, etc.


As an aside, I remember some time ago that Tesla stock went down because the growth of the Model 3 sales went down... After years of being one of the best selling cars on the planet.

If number don't go up fast I guess people get scared.


It could have been that so much future growth was priced in that a reduction in the growth rate could have justified a reduction in the share price


I didn't think of that! That's certainly possible.


The issue is the company's valuation has priced in ridiculous growth in the future. The trajectory matters here. Not saying you should short the stock


Absolute numbers are still higher than they were 5 years ago but the number of jobs going down means that the same (or about the same) number of people are starting to compete for a smaller number of jobs. Many people have chosen to study software development in recent years so nowadays the workforce is much larger than it was 5-10 years ago.

This imbalance of supply and demand shifts power toward employers and it's hard not to feel the pressure even if you're not looking for a job right now.


The chart shows devs still growing, and "Computer System Design SERVICES" getting hammered (most of the total loss).

I'm not even sure this chart tells the story of the title.


Is this WITCH companies?


Yes, but...

The health of the market is not a function of the total number of jobs alone, it's a function of the number of jobs and the number of people to fill them.

The number of total jobs going up year after year meant that there were increasing numbers of candidates, new people entering the field. If the job growth stops, then there still we be candidates coming in. There will also be the new hires from the last decade moving into increasingly senior roles, and there won't be space for them (unless you devalue the meaning of "senior" even more).

So the year over year change matters a lot. If it plateaus, or even declines slightly, it's more than enough to make a terrible market.


YoY change in jobs is still probably not the best way to visualize overall market health. As you say, you also have to take into account the number of people of fill the jobs. To me it seems like the least misleading statistics would be a graph showing unemployment and underemployment % over time. I'd probably also toss in graphs of length of unemployment period as well as various median wage percentiles (quintiles or deciles maybe) over time.


It shows growth or decline but it absolutely does not show what the title implies.


The chart shows the derivative of the thing people care about which is total cumulative change. The area under the curve shows cumulative change.


And they said we'd never have to use calculus in real life!


The post-COVID spike was also absolutely insane and much bigger than dotcom boom.


And I already thought we hired more devs than needed pre-covid. It was pretty well surmised that big tech was hiring to starve other companies of talent, and thus employees were underutilised.


Thank you. And those raw numbers in the chart that go back to 2001 are not normalized percentages; what’s happening right now is NOTHING like 2001.

But, it just doesn’t hit the same way on X to say “We are back to late 2023-levels of tech employment” or “The losses in tech jobs over the last 18 months give back two months of hiring in 2022”.


Asked Gemini quickly for 2000 and 2025 numbers.

Tech employees: 5.5m vs 9.9.

Software developers: 0.68m vs 3.2m.

Different ball game.


Check out the HTMX example in the blog, this helped me better understand how it could be used

https://adamj.eu/tech/2025/12/03/django-whats-new-6.0/#rende...


I'm an avid HTMX user but never did I ever think "I'm using so many includes, I wish I didn't have to use include so much."

What I would like is a way to cut down the sprawl of urls and views.


I do a check for `request.htmx` in my views and conditionally return a template partial as needed. This reduced my need for one-off view functions that were only returning partials for htmx. Works pretty well from my experience.


Any code or blog written by Adam is worth spending some time on.

It will be interesting to see how the tasks framework develops and expands. I am sad to see the great Django-Q2 lumped in with the awful Celery though.


Celery is the worst background task framework, except for all the others.

There are bugs and issues, but because so many people are using it, you’re rarely the first to stumble upon a problem. We processed double-digit millions of messages daily with Celery + RabbitMQ without major obstacles. Regardless of what people say, it should be your first go-to.


Celery has way too much magic crammed into it, it is very annoying to debug, and produces interesting bugs. Celery is/was also a "pickle-first" API and this almost always turns out to be the wrong choice. As a rule of thumb, persisting pickles is a really bad idea. Trying to hide IPC / make-believe that it's not there tends to be a bad idea. Trying to hide interfaces between components tends to be a bad idea. Celery combines all of these bad ideas into one blob. The last time I looked the code was also a huge mess, even for old-guard-pythonic-code standards.


I think Celery has a lot of magic happening under it. When the abstractions are so high, it's important they never leak and you don't see anything below the turtles you are supposed to see.

I often prefer designing around explicit queues and building workers/dispatchers. One queuing system I miss is the old Google App Engine one - you set up the queue, the URL it calls with the payload (in your own app), the rate it should use, and that's it.


OP here, thanks for the praise!

Yeah, I mentioned Celery due to its popularity, no other reason ;)


You are a great writer - thanks for putting this together!


I tried django-q and I thought it was pretty terrible. The worst was that I couldn't get it to stop retrying stuff that was broken. Sometimes you ship code that does something unexpected, and being able to stop something fast is critical imo.

Fundamentally I think the entire idea behind celery and django-q is mostly misguided. People normally actually need a good scheduler and a bring-your-own queue in tables that you poll. I wrote Urd to cover my use cases and it's been rock solid.


I've been using Celery for years. What is the major issues you have with it and how does Django Q2 help?

I also use Kafka on other tech stacks but that's another level completely and use case.


Why is celery awful?




Temporal is an AMAZING piece of software, however I don't believe it's a replacement for something more simple like Celery. Even if you write helpers, the overhead to setting up workflows, invoking them, etc. is just too much for simple jobs like sending an email (imo). I would love to work in a codebase that had access to both, depending on the complexity of what you're trying to background.



It's okay till it's not. Everyone I know who had Celery in production was looking for a substitution (custom or third-party) on a regular basis. Too many moving pieces and nuances (config × logic × backend), too many unresolved problems deep in its core (we've seen some ghosts you can't debug), too much of a codebase to understand or hack. At some point we were able to stabilize it (a bunch of magic tricks and patches) and froze every related piece; it worked well under pressure (thanks, RabbitMQ).


Because it’s a seducer. It does what you need to do and you two are happy together. So you shower more tasks on Celery and it becomes cold and non-responsive at random times.

And debugging is a pain in the ass. Most places I’ve been that have it, I’ve tried to sell them on adding Flower to give better insight and everyone thinks that’s a very good idea but there isn’t time because we need to debug these inscrutable Celery issues.

https://flower.readthedocs.io/en/latest/


Although we could say the same thing about Kafka, couldn't we? It's made for much higher throughput and has usually other use cases, but it's also great until it's not great.


At least the last time I used Kafka (which was several years ago so things might have changed) it wasn't at all easy to get started. It was a downright asshole in fact. If you pursue a relationship with an asshole, you shouldn't be surprised when they become cold to you


Yes, absolutely. It's still pretty much that way. Especially if you want to make changes to a running installation, add nodes etc.


Celery is great and awful at the same time. In particular, because it is many Python folks' first introduction to distributed task processing and all the things that can go wrong with it. Not to mention, debugging can be a nightmare. Some examples:

- your function arguments aren't serializable - your side effects (e.g. database writes) aren't idempotent - discovering what backpressure is and that you need it - losing queued tasks during deployment / non-compatible code changes

There's also some stuff particular to celery's runtime model that makes it incredibly prone to memory leaks and other fun stuff.

Honestly, it's a great education.


> your side effects (e.g. database writes) aren't idempotent

What does idempotent mean in this context, or did you mean atomic/rollback on error?

I'm confused because how could a database write be idempotent in Django? Maybe if it introduced a version on each entity and used that for crdt on writes? But that'd be a significant performance impact, as it couldn't just be a single write anymore, instead they'd have to do it via multiple round trips


In the context of background jobs idempotent means that if your job gets run for a second time (and it will get run for a second time at some point, they all do at-least-once delivery) there aren't any unfortunate side effects to that. Often that's just a case of checking if the relevant database updates have already been done, maybe not firing a push notification in cases of a repeated job.


If you need idempotent db writes, then use something like Temporal. You can't really blame Celery for not having that because that is not what Celery aims to be.


With Temporal, your activity logic still needs to ensure idempotency e.g. by checking if an event id / idempotency key exists in a table. It's still at-least-once delivery. Temporal does make it easy to mint an idempotency key by concatenating workflow run id and activity id, if you don't have a one provided client-side.


Temporal requires a lot more setup than setting up a Redis instance though. That's the only problem with it. And I find the Python API a bit more difficult to grasp. But otherwise a solid piece of technology.



In my experience async job idempotency is implemented as upserts. Insert all job outputs on the first run. Do (mostly) nothing on subsequent runs. Maybe increment a counter or timestamp.


From your experience, what is a better alternative guys?


Not the comment that you replied to but I use my own Urd. It's a fancier Cron that you can stop fast. Which is imo what you normally want.

Task queues are like email. It's what everyone is used to so people ask for more of it, but it's not actually good/the right tool.


There’s no alternative (while prototyping), and anything else is better (when you properly defined your case).


DjangoQ2 is a fine alternative during early development


I’m currently stuck with the tech debt of Celery myself. I understand that! Does Django Tasks support async functions?


Computer, load up Celery Man please.


I'm of the opinion that django task apps should only support a single backend. For example, django-rq for redis only. There's too many differences in backends to make a good app that can handle multiple. That said, I've only used celery in production before, and I'm willing to change my mind.


With that logic, the Django orm should only support one database.


Why have a backend then?


Seaford, the city to which this would apply, was once regarded as "The Nylon Capital of the World"!

https://www.capegazette.com/affiliate-post/remembering-nylon...


> Ten percent of respondents who reported having a 4.0 said they had cheated in an academic context while at Harvard.

Imagine how many cheated and didn't admit it! A very sad state of affairs...


Though this implies that 10% of the 4.0s don't deserve it, it's not proof; a single cheat may or may not have affected the grade.


When that single cheat might have resulted in expulsion if it were caught, it implies a pretty significant effect on the grade.

It wouldn’t actually change the result of the metric (because survivorship bias: you don’t count students who never graduated in the graduated student population), but it changes the believability of and the ethic behind the metric. Now we can say that at least 10% of the folks who graduated didn’t earn their grades, and the school’s reputation is less for it.


My experience is that in recent years, cheating is ubiquitous in many elite schools. This goes all the way to the top. Fake research data. Self-enriching financial schemes by faculty. Conflicts-of-interest. Etc.


Cheating is probably the best thing to do. It's a zero sum world.


Sure, if you're satisfied with rampant corruption and dysfunctional institutions. Let's embrace dishonesty and underachievement.


Cheating may be a rational thing to do, on an individual level, if we ignore ethics. Outside of that it breaks down. I wouldn't say "best" without a lot of qualifiers.


HN is truly a market leader in status page technology


A couple of outages that have affected my client i learned about first on HN. We were able to mobilize a team and get on top of it faster than any monitoring team at the client ( a state government ). I feel like HN should invoice us haha


You might benefit from some better monitoring!


I came to HN to make sure it was actually down.


Except when it is a false alarm.

I've seen a few get to the front page.

But when we're right we're right.


10/9 times


HN: All of our amps go to 11.


Even when it's a false alarm it's usually something else is having a problem that is affecting many people and manifesting itself as a particular service being down.


I'll make my employer pay for it if HN starts a paid service. Honestly they should write a blog post about when down times were first reported on Hn.


HN was also down for a moment because too much traffic


I experienced that too


Such a lightweight tool at that! Barely any JS loaded.


*was


Add our current low interest rates to the mix as well and the picture changes dramatically


100%. Though, interest rate based appreciation is likely at its apex, presuming zero is the floor. If we find ourselves with negative rates (after taxes and fees; there was one case of negative rates in Europe, but net inclusive of fees, it was still positive) -- then we're in truly uncharted territory.

At this juncture, it seems most appreciation will arise from supply issues, which aren't new to the post-2008 world. And while we do have lots of unoccupied housing nationally, we don't have it stock in areas where it's most needed: e.g, job centers. You can easily find a $10k home in Detroit if you wish.

The graph would be helpful it broke out metro versus rural areas, in addition to factoring interest rates.


This must result in a non-trivial amount of ink/toner used in the name of security


The last HP Inkjet that I had would go through the Yellow cartridge faster than black, even when printing only Black and White. Which is how I discovered these fun little dots.


They didn't go into too much detail about how the dots are actually printed (what type of ink, how heavy, etc.), but they imply in the article that at least some tracking dots require a UV light to detect.

I'd be curious to know how the dots actually get printed.


Hi, author here! The dots themselves aren't printed with UV ink it's just that the UV light makes it easier to see them due to the yellow ink used.

There were images I sent the magazine of the dots from some magazines I scanned, but they didn't run them. If you scan a page and invert it, the patterns are more legible https://i.imgur.com/x1TXa30.png


The dot patterns are much smaller and more dense than I expected


I don't understand what I'm looking at here.


You should see rows of tightly packed blue dots in repeating patterns - the machine identification codes for a Xerox printer, to be precise. You may have to turn off f.lux to see them


Error: Secret UV ink is empty. Please contact NSA for a new cartridge.


Interesting protip: fluorescent compounds are added to all sorts of things: mouthwash bottles, toothpaste, white paper, laundry detergent, and the “bright” colours of printer ink.


I'm not sure if normal scanners detect UV light, but that would break a good chunk of their tracking purpose these days if they were not detectable in scans.


And how do they get printed on a monochrome printer like a laser?


There are color laser printers.

On a monochrome printer, I guess you can still to steganography by messing with the dithering, I guess? However, since the stated aim of the fingerprinting is to catch money counterfeiters, I guess they are less interested in monochrome.


Are any major banknotes monochrome?


Each layer is, but that's probably more advanced than just "printing a banknote".


That anti feature is absent there. Black instead of yellow dots would be very visible


I believe, could be very wrong, that its only on color printers and uses the Yellow color to print dots too small to see with the eye.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: