Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | timbotron's commentslogin

I can understand criticism of docker specifically from a "requires root and daemon" perspective (rootless daemonless container runtimes exists) but this is such an odd take, using outdated software is completely unrelated to whether or not you use containers. Why would long lived VMs be better if they're also using old versions of software?


> Why would long lived VMs be better if they're also using old versions of software?

It's more difficult to break out of a VM and take over the host, unless a container has a very strict seccomp policy that limits the exposed kernel surface area. The Linux kernel's high rate of feature churn has resulted in an endless parade of root exploits. Locking down a container takes effort as you risk breaking the application by removing access to fancy kernel features du jour. VMs have bugs, too, but it's a better situation, especially if the interface between guest and host is limited to a few virtio drivers. Firecracker, for example, takes this minimalist approach; relative to containers it's more of a "secure by default" situation as far as host protection goes, and unless the guest environment requires direct access to peripheral hardware, everything will still work as intended.


So anyone using Docker on mac or windows is safe from this scary stuff because they run all containers in a vm? Cool!


So the problem is Linux, not Docker, then.


I'm curious why you said you don't find MongoDB interesting?


I lived through the MongoDB hype cycle.

For document databases, I'm more interested in things like PoloDB and SurrealDB.


I agree mongo is overhyped and attracts a lot of web newbies who only know javascript and don't want to think through schemas, although one interesting newer feature of mongo is time series collections -- unfortunately they are a bit buggy but they're getting better seem like a legitimate non-relational use case.


Ex-Surrealer here. Thanks for listing us. Never thought someone on HN would cite us esp when it comes to MongoDB.


but "works on my machine" is exactly the problem docker solves -- if you still have those issues then you're not building your images right


That's why there is the meme. Docker doesn't always solve this, or even often on its own. You can't just "build image to docker" and expect things to go okay and pretend you can be agnostic about its prod environment (you kind of can, but usually requires an ops team supporting whatever assumptions your image made).

It's been addressed in other comments but you have:

- differences in architectures, CPU, memory

- if the docker image has a volume attached, unless local perfectly represents prod, you're going to have issues

- networking and firewall rules can be drastically different than a production environment and the assumptions made there

- differences in RBAC/IAM/etc. between local and prod could go on and on.

In reality, this is a nice idea, in practicality, it almost never works 1:1. The common refrain is "well just make the local/dev/sandbox exactly match prod" and my point is this is often unrealistic to the point it cannot/won't happen. If you can do it, good for you, I just personally have never seen this work as simply the author describes it in a system of any kind of complexity.


"widely different" seems like a stretch e.g. ECS is pretty directly translatable to docker compose, and if you do cross-platform builds with buildx then I don't see why doing the building locally or on a cloud service matters much.


there's a pretty direct translation from ECS task definition to docker-compose file


At this point their 99.99% SLA is a total joke, make sure to claim your service credits https://slack.com/terms/service-level-agreement


If you like git annex check out [datalad](http://handbook.datalad.org/en/latest/), it provides some useful wrappers around git annex oriented towards scientific computing.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: