Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | timcobb's commentslogin

AI gonzo?

I think it would not be difficult to instruct an agent to write all its prose in the style of Hunter S. Thompson.

I struggled to produce this with gpt-4

Jensen's behavior is also very consequential...

The point is he didn't behave rationally on one big really important point from a shareholder value standpoint. He didn't just sleep with someone and his arrangements in this regard are irrelevant

Viewing people like this is unhealthy. Nvidia could have failed instead of 3dfx, and that it didn't involved some luck, not just the magical clairvoyance of one individual.

And anyway, whether Nvidia created CUDA and deep learning are all moot at this point.


There's a nearly 20 year lead up to the current CUDA dominance including working with developers, but on the gaming side there's also a parallel with the dominance of nvidia's gaming tech versus how much ATi/AMD were able to get their tech to stick. Nv invested not just in capable hardware then throw it over the fence to leave developers to figure out, but software solutions easily integrated by others and engineer support to show off their hardware in the best light.

More directly on topic, I can't help thinking this is also a question of "what have you done for me lately" versus "what are you going to do for me tomorrow". It's hard to doubt he and the company as a whole have executed a vision and reaped the rewards, but have they been planning and doing the groundwork for another act.


> planning and doing the groundwork for another act.

A nontrivial part of which is pumping up an infrastructure bubble with NVIDIA money. It wouldn't shock me if that very aggressive and increasingly questioned strategy plays a role in whatever happens to Jensen.


No chance of that - it wasn't luck. I was there. Nvidia was simply a lot better and Huang must get a lot of credit but he hired good people.

This well researched video I endorse. Sure Nvidia was touch and go a the very start but beyond that, they were just locked in.

How Nvidia Won Graphics Cards - Asianometry https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TRZqE6H-dww


Cuda was first but there was also openCL shortly thereafter. The idea was bound to hatch.

> whether Nvidia created CUDA and deep learning are all moot at this point.

Why? There were the reason why NVIDIA GPUs became so successful at the first place.

Who knows whether Jensen's current leadership isn't generating today's CUDA for NVIDIA?


The design of cuda is basically just brookGPU from stanford (supported by IBM, Sony, ATI, NVIDIA and DARPA), CUDA isn't so important beyond the fact that a hardware company can use it as a moat if they want to be anti-competitive. Google bought PeakStream, intel bought RapidMind.

The situation only exists because regulators in the 80s-20s believe that hardware should be a sanctioned monopoly. Intel, AMD, NVIDIA, Sun Microsystems, IBM, HP, and Microsoft were all involved. If it's not Jensen it'd be someone else, there is a good reason NVIDIA is called NVIDIA and not JENSEN. Jensen's leadership is as much resonsible for CUDA as G. W. Bush's.


I don't understand, what am I supposed to search for now when I have a question? A lot of that stuff has been saved in scrapes and llms but pretty weird that they're just taking it offline?

Are they going to replace it with anything? Where will people discuss their Apple support issues?


It was presumably a fun part of their life and they won't be able to look at it anymore.

That's MCP, or a CLI

Agentic (seriously)

Sol/Astra are sweet but they also have pretty much no discipline or executive function, which is where Opus 5.5 comes in, and I've not seen that capability in it nerfed too bad in my experience.

I have high hopes for Carbon here -- Argon is not quite Opus 5.5 but it's pretty darn good.

> since everyone is assuming it's a winner take all market. That's probably close to correct.

why? I keep seeing this over and over again but I've not seen an explanation. I would really appreciate some insight into this line of thinking, since it's not obvious to me. What is the benefit of holding hundreds of billions of computer hardware when it's not proven that it's even needed.


Lets say the total market for an arbitrary winner-take-all industry is $100 Billion/year in profits. Just so that we have a round number. And for another round number, lets assume the fair market PE ratio is 20x. This over-simplification would then have a fair market valuation of $2 Trillion total.

Just simple napkin math.

Now, lets say there are 5 companies competing to be the winner. Only one can be the winner, but all 5 are trying to be the winner. How much should each company individually spend?

Well... starting-bid is $2 Trillion, or ~$10 Trillion in the aggregate. Its basically the waste of competition. Because everyone is vying for monopoly power, the only fair for them to all invest over $2 Trillion in the hopes of being the dominant one at the end. Even if $8 Trillion is wasted, that's "other companies", your competitors, who lose out.

But wait: if one company spends $2.1 Trillion, that one company likely becomes the winner and the other 4 companies lose out. So then another company spends $2.2 Trillion, to get ahead of that war. Etc. etc.


I've read this 3 times and I think OP's question still stands. How is AI winner-take-all and not just a commodity market?

> Now, lets say there are 5 companies competing to be the winner. Only one can be the winner, [...].

Here you just stated what a winner-take-all market is, in the problem statement? Why can only one be the winner in AI's case? Even better: why can't they all be the losers if they spend as if this was a winner-take-all market? If one of the players suspects that's not the case, isn't it wise for them not to play the game as stated? What if ROI is logarithmic? What if the losing competitors go open source?

I have so many questions.

Is this a spherical cow?


> Is this a spherical cow?

Yes.

> I have so many questions.

I'm not saying this is correct. I'm just saying a lot of other people believe this. If they are wrong then they will lose a lot of money. If they are correct, most of them will lose lots of money but one of them will make money.

I agree with you that the chance of "everyone is a loser" is higher than the current Zeitgeist believes.


The idea is, innovation will concentrate where the necessary ingredients are.

When AI replaces human workers and researchers, the "frontier", with which you can earn money and gain an edge over your competition, resides in those data centers with the highest concentration of computational power.

If you own those data centers, you control the frontier of human knowledge, the edge where money and power is being carved out.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: