This is very much still working it's way through the courts (in the US at least).
The first major precedent was in 2023 with Zarya of the Dawn comic book, where the US Copyright Office rules the midjourney-generated images were not protected, but the human-written text was.
It's the robo-driver phenomenon. Statistically, humans kill more humans due to human accidents while driving (on a per-mile driven basis). But it still feels more aweful and terrifying when an AI driver makes a mistake and kills a human.
AI writing and creativity is generally crap. In the business world, there was already a massive low-quality human-powered machine that pumped out blog posts, white papers, and reports that no humans ever read. Humans tolerated low quality human creative output (tolerated here just means enough humans paid for it to sustain other humans creating it).
Thought experiment:
Two human authors each publish a book. You read them both, and enjoy them both about the same.
You don't know this, but the first author is what society would call "a monster" who has acted in all sorts of ways you would find repulsive.
Discovering this would probably change your feelings on the book in some way. But before you know all you have to judge the book on is the book itself.
Open AI leads the pack with image gen for the AI layperson.
And yet it is still completely inept at the last 10-20% of nuance and refinement, and it ruts out, requiring me to jump from new chat to new chat to try and get the right final tweaks.
Prediction: we'll soon have manual tweaks for raster images. A pane of sliders to tweak not only things like like color but compositional elements too (rotate the banana and scale it up by 10%).
I'm always surprised when my pro-figma sentiment is met with cries of "fanboy!"
Figma has consistently done better than most at nailing the UX. Maybe I'm enough of a generalist that it always feels great to me, and super specialists lament the lack of their super special needs being met (genuinely, a valid gripe for the specialists).
I've tinkered with Figma AI, and it's just good enough to keep me tinkering. It's not creating magic yet, and it's certainly not outpacing claude design to the point where I always pick figma.
I am enthusiastically optimistic that Figma will push the UX on agentic design to where I come to figma every day again.
I also just went long on figma yesterday and got a yearly subscription. If you iterate on designs a lot it's the best workflow imho. claude desktop + figma is dope.
Yeah. Where I work, we have our UI Controls in an asset library. Claude Design regularly makes crap designs. My current workflow is let the PM do a wireframe in Claude. Recreate it in Figma so it's actually implementable. Iterate on it, use Claude to help manage the workflow so it does the grunt work of "Take component X's attributes in Step 2 and copy them to all the copies of Component X in the page." Works very well and it preserves modes, etc. It also a good job of filling in mock data. We iterate in Figma until PM is happy with UX. I can then point Claude at the Figma and can get the UX about 95% correct the first time.
Any reason you let the PM do the wireframe? I also use claude for this? I really like the old school flow of user journeys -> wireframes -> designs/components. Going to become a moat to do proper handcraft if everybody just slops around
The first major precedent was in 2023 with Zarya of the Dawn comic book, where the US Copyright Office rules the midjourney-generated images were not protected, but the human-written text was.
The active front is Allen v. Perlmutter.
reply