Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | tuvix's commentslogin

That’s not music


Suno probably puts out better music than most folks who take up music. I mean statistically it has to, right? So once we go with "suno doesn't make music" then we also have to progress to "99 percent of human musicians don't make music", and all us amateur hacks will start objecting lol


Only in the same narrow way that a camera makes better art than a painter. Or the idea that a generic landscape print is better than a Rothko, because it looks more like other paintings that you like to look at.


The camera just records reality, its by definition sort of neutral artistically speaking, its what it records that matters. Its quite different from this AI music thing, and I would consider it a very difficult task to discuss topics with someone trying to pretend it isn't.


Exactly. The point of a painting is not to reproduce reality. The camera is good at reproducing reality (better than 99% of painters!), but the camera doesn't make art.

In the same way, Suno can produce music-like audio very well. It doesn't produce music. It may be possible for somebody wielding Suno to produce music, but the average use of it certainly isn't it. It's certainly worse at producing music than almost any musician.

It can churn out muzak like no tomorrow, though, same as ChatGPT can render you barely-tolerable images of any art style you ask for.


How many "musicians" can play through even a basic song like Transilvanian Hunger, a dirt simple 3-4 chord song? There comes a point when people let their anti AI psychosis get to the point when they start stating obviously and absurdly insane stuff, like how a music generation app that makes decent quality music is "not music" or worse than atrocious crap most learners and amateur musicians vomit out.


You miss the point so entirely that I'm not sure you opened your eyes when reading the post. A 7 year-old excitedly honking on their recorder is better at making music than the AI-generated shit getting made.

Technical ability does not define if music is 'better' or not. Art is a conversation between the artist and the audience. If there's no artist there, there's no conversation, and there's no art.


Of course I know thats what you were trying to say, I am just saying how deranged that view is. If people care so much about human to human conversation they should be able to.interested to find out and list all the artists and credits of random chillhop playlists. Are they able to?


Fragile egos. Someone in one of these AI threads mentioned the three great blows to human narcissism. I loved that. Modern AI is the fourth one. This ones so bad otherwise reasonable people are regressing to naked magical supernaturalism.


How does an absurd comparison between two completely different genres make sense? Is Morbid Angel better than Lady Gaga because Morbid Angel sounds more like other music I like to listen to? Does this question make any sense to you?


It’s not about it being “better”. It’s not music, it’s sound.

Music is made by a human


Music is what gives people joy. If people get joy from factory like lounge records in the 50s or an AI generated "chill" playlist, then its good. For most music, people don't give a shit who or what created it. Its different when someone goes out to see a band yes, but not when they are listening to mood music etc.


That's up to consumers to decide.


If the consumers had criticality they’d be people, not consumers, and we wouldn’t have marketing the way we do now.


Consumers have, overall, rejected AI "art".

But of course, every time consumers voice their preferences is actually "a loud minority" or an "echo chamber" :)


Consumers have rejected AI art when they are aware it's AI art. With how it's been flooding the platforms, most people listening to algorithmic mixes have likely unknowingly been exposed to AI-generated music.

It's already prevalent in gyms, restaurants, etc too. I can tell because I know what I'm listening for, but the average person isn't thinking anything of it. It certainly passes for serviceable background music.


And computer-generated code is not code? ;)


Come on now Voyager wasn’t that bad


Kind of amazing how completely Yen misunderstands Protons customer base. It’s pretty much entirely security conscious people who want to divest from big tech right?

Why would he throw all that away?


Because there are only so many paranoid nerds around, and way more people who love the hype


They had a safe stable business with a loyal user base in a market niche they completely owned, could have basically just sat on their asses and de facto collected taxes from paranoid nerds and journalists for decades.

I just don't understand why they'd want to trade all that away for a chasing the same nebulous "something something AI" business plan as literally every other company in the tech industry right now. The odds they'll be competitive in such an endeavor and see a fraction of the success they had again is minuscule.


Maybe they know fundamentally what they do is trivial? Making something shitty and complex for the sake of it while still maintaining a facade of functionality takes guts and balls.


Outside the security conscious crowd and the digital sovereignty crowd, they don't stand a chance.

He seems to no longer understand that, and he might run a decent business to the ground with his delusions.


Yeah that’s my read too. Mistakes like this might fly under the radar with the general public but I think a much larger portion of Protons user base, as opposed to Zoho or Google, reads 404 and HN.

I’ll definitely not be renewing my subscription to their service, I can tell you that much.


I feel like this is an internal bias I’ve actually built up over time. If I see another company providing a service come out after something I already am using, I subconsciously gravitate toward it.

If they’re coming to market when there’s already a dominant player, they must have improved something, right? Not saying it’s logical.


Just recently created an md live viewer/pdf exporter after feeling some of these same frustrations[0]. Always wanted something that allowed me to use vim while viewing the markdown exactly as it would render to pdf, kind of like overleaf.

[0] https://github.com/john-marinelli/docm


Got stuck in a loop with my work account recently after setting up a passkey. It would cycle through something like 12 different pages, loading then redirecting before eventually ending at “You have been signed out”. Awful


This is the primary reason, to me, that open weights are so important. If OpenAI and Anthropic want these models to be as autonomous as possible they also need to provide the means to understand them fully.


They also ring when a non-associated iphone is moving with them for some time.


> “shooting somebody in the face with a gun”

If you try to visualize this in action, replace somebody with a bad guy. And you quickly see there’s nothing inherently wrong with the idea.


This is sweet! Is there like a way to contribute and build these or is this just a list of cool things someone has made?


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: