Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | valine's commentslogin

I always thought if Apple did touch on the macbook it would come with a redesign to merge macOS with touch elements from the iPad. As it stands this feels like more of an afterthought.

If there’s one killer feature though, it’s iOS device mirroring and the iOS simulators. I’ve instinctively reached up to touch the iOS simulator so many times.

I wonder how they do the glowing apple logo with no backlight.


I thought that they would basically replace macbooks with ipad pros. Sort of like microsoft surface, a tablet-laptop combo. Not sure what their plan is now.


The bitter lesson is finally coming for the self-driving cars. The vision stack, 3D maps, lane selection grammar, occupancy networks, it’s maybe all about to give way to a single GPT looking at camera feeds and predicting the next steering wheel adjustment.

It’s mostly a latency problem at this point. The models are too big to run locally, but given that open-weight models like Qwen already exist, an open-weight, low latency equivalent to Astra can’t be too far out.


You might be interested to learn that the bitter lesson has already been grok'd by generations of autonomous car company engineers, and many or all have incorporated learned components (at minimum) in all their vehicle stacks.

There's also a very tangible limitation of the bitter lesson.

If, over time, compute climbs, and so compute-bound data-driven general architectures beat bespoke architectures (this is the bitter lesson), then it is not necessarily true that the most general architecture now beats all available bespoke architectures now (or even in the near/mid future - the crossover point is "eventually").

Bitter lesson is most tangible for long-running research directions. Sometimes you need something working as best as possible now.


Yeah. Every major self driving model that I’m aware of is fully e2e at this point. Going from fused sensor output to control+debug vectors.

This is more generalised.

But also since there’s a huge volume of data it’s too expensive to just keep scaling compute up (per car overhead) so there are necessary tricks involved.

I do think having a large model that can do this means that a small specialised model could be distilled form it though. Which is probably the most feasible path to production IMO.


This seems like it would be way too dangerous for all sorts of security reasons.


A later entrant can potentially side step those investments if their now is later. Since self driving car ventures aren’t profitable yet and need to make up their investments over time, thats a real risk for them.


But what might happen imo, is that these huge models might be much better at learning from data in an unsupervised manner, so a model based on Astra might become a much better driver in a short period of time (and given a smaller set of training data) - this is due to it understanding much more of the inputs, and being able to draw conclusions from it much more efficiently, thus the information available for training it is greater per sample.

Then the big model can teach a small model to become almost as good a driver. This might be substantially more efficient way to train stuff, and might be fairly quick and straightforward.

In practical terms, I feel this means we can see huge jumps in capability overnight. And this is a general indicator of AI progress, not only in this narrow scope.


You're making a "might" argument for a more general, more CPU/Data intensive process, which I just call "bitter lesson". I wouldn't even say "might" i'd just say "yeah, eventually so!"


I'm not sure how you take that from the original article. My 4 year old would drive that course in an automatic car, if only he could reach the pedals. Heck, he's done harder things at Lego land.

I wouldn't let him loose on the road though.

I think, at the very least, the guardrails would have to deterministic, ideally with super human senses, for people to accept self driving cars on the road.


Your four year old has billions of years of learning embedded in his weights/architecture for generalized motor control :)


Maybe 4 year olds already have the brain power to learn to drive if they so desired.


Almost certainly, there are 4 year olds who ride small motorbikes etc. I think the main problem is that they can't really be held accountable if they have an accident.



They also have really poor judgement. A 4yo will find out how high you can get the car airborne.


Animals are born walking. Humans are somewhat deficient and need more training postpartum.


Interesting. Is your 4 year old raising capital?


He sold $20 worth of lemonade the other day, which comes to about $175k annualized.

What's your ARR, anyway?


Nope, no "deterministic guardrails" for you. The domain is simply far too broad and unstructured to allow for that.

Unless you mean "a typical AI with all the computation constrained sufficiently to always unfold the same exact way, given the same input". In practice, that just kicks the can to "given the same input" street.

The noise in the system is going to come from the input plane. Which is, I remind you, facing the real world. It's full of noise.


If I'm reading the chart correctly, it took over 5 minutes to drive 135m at a cost of nearly $8.00 in tokens. I don't think that's really in the realm of practical yet.


Tesla's already solved this - their vision model does this phenomenally well.

And they've demonstrated adding a sidecar LLM to it as well, mostly for these kinds of "read these 3 street signs, what should i do next?" sort of situations.


The same Tesla that pulled radar to go vision only and a person was killed because the vision model didn't recognize a truck? https://www.bbc.com/news/technology-36680043

Not sure that counts as phenomenally well.


That incident and article is from ten years ago.



From that same article - "The agency said it has identified nine crashes potentially linked to the issue, including one fatality and two involving injuries. It is also reviewing six additional crashes that may be related."

Fifteen crashes - though not to be trivialized - is not a damning number at all in this context. What's more, per the article it's unconfirmed that the crashes are related, so it's hardly fitting to dismiss Tesla's approach based on this.

I think it's great that serious efforts are being made in different approaches to autonomous driving - and in this thread's context, it seems possible that Tesla's approach might eventually be revealed as the optimal approach given modern AI.


This is from ten years ago. Tesla's vision only FSD is extremely good now. It has been for at least 18 months or longer.


Only for 2024 or maybe late 2023 cars and later (HW4). The older the car is the worse the FSD software is because the old hardware can't run the latest software.


Right, and over time the number of HW4+ cars will increase, right?

I can't speak to FSD's quality on HW3, I never had FSD on my Model 3. I did have EAP and it worked really well on highways.

But what is your argument? newer tech will bring improved outcomes? I'm sure HW5 will be even better. But that doesn't change the fact that FSD (on HW4 vehicles of which there are tons), is really good.



Anecdotes. Only accident rate per mile driven (compared to human drivers' rate) is a relevant comparison. I don't think that any self-driving system will ever be absolutely perfect (all such complex non-linear systems are to some degree probabilistic and chaotic), but as long as the accident rate is lower than the human accident rate, I would consider it solved.


It's Lego mindstorm logic level to drive a car on the motorway, so per mile is an absolutely insanely bad metric in general.

Per mile inside cities or other difficult scenarios are what may get close to an actually meaningful metric. That's why Tesla is very misleading and waymo is much more legit.


Cute, but no. Can't compare a self-driving system that's only willing to work in a subset of conditions humans drive in, to humans driving in all those conditions.


> Only accident rate per mile driven (compared to human drivers' rate) is a relevant comparison

This is such an insane take I see all the time from self-driving boosters

If a self driving car glitches out and crashes in some edge case pathological scenario we don't just accept that as totally fine because its hidden under big statistics

The reason why a crash happened does matter, its not just about aggregate statistics

As a thought experiment if I have a perfect self driving system but I add some code that purposefully crashes 1 in 10 million rides are you ok riding in it since the aggregate statistics look good?


> As a thought experiment if I have a perfect self driving system but I add some code that purposefully crashes 1 in 10 million rides are you ok riding in it since the aggregate statistics look good?

Do I know about the purposefully added harmful code? If yes, I would demand you remove it, because why not. If I don't know about the code, I would be OK with it, since it's clearly still more safe than the alternative and apparently cannot be made even better.


You seem to be neglecting the important part of that scenario where you're other option you have to compare it to is a human driver that will randomly get it a crash at some higher rate.

You're making it sound like the obvious answer is the irrational one.


You added "totally" - as others have said, I don't know if anyone will claim a perfect system with no fatalities, enough stats show that it is already much safer than human drivers.

And the true third party validation is that insurance companies are starting to offer lower premiums the more you use FSD. So their risk models are showing enough improvement that they're putting their money where their mouths are.

The idea that Tesla's FSD is not ready for the mainstream is quite outdated, given that tons of Tesla owners are already using it daily, not just your early adopter types.


Note that the article has no info on whether it's FSD or Autopilot and whether they contributed to the fatal crashes. "Verified engaged" means ADAS was active at some point in the interval from T-30s to the end of the accident. The total number of collisions is not normalized by the miles driven.


It also has no info on what hardware+software version was in use. The older cars are significantly less capable but there are far more of them on the road.


$o $olved


What do you think Tesla has been doing this for so long?


Busting unions, discriminating against black employees, and funding Musk’s virulent white supremacy.


Lying and they still are.


> The bitter lesson is finally coming for the self-driving cars.

Maybe, but the opacity level of models is not acceptable for cars. "Why did it drive under the semi?" "Model said to." "Why did the model say to?" "shrug"


But if the model is an LLM, you actually COULD ask it why it drove under the semi, and it would give you an answer. Now, you may argue that it will just be generating a whole new, backwards-rationalized post-hoc explanation of its own behavior given the logs that it managed to take before the crash. But then I ask you: how do you think a person explains why they did what they did after a crash? I direct you to all of the unsettling split-brain neuroscience literature demonstrating that humans are incorrigible backwards rationalizers who make for unreliable witnesses.


That's a bug, and it would be an awful mistake to replicate that bug rather than fix it.


> Maybe, but the opacity level of models is not acceptable for cars.

That depends on actual performance of the model. I would prefer an opaque model with clearly superhuman driving abilities to a human, or to a non-opaque model with worse performance.


It really doesn't.

https://knowyourmeme.com/memes/a-computer-can-never-be-held-...

No self-driving cars that aren't transparent about exactly how they work. (Ideally, no anything that isn't transparent about exactly how it works.)


This take can perhaps appear to make sense in a situation when clearly superhuman opaque AI models don't yet exist. But once they do, good luck convincing people that they should not save lives or reduce their personal risks, just because they always supposedly need an explanation for any accidental deaths, lol.

In our scenario (self-driving), the one who would be ultimately "held accountable" would not be the computer, or the company, but the person who died after singing a waiver/EULA and getting into a statistically superhuman autonomous car, then having a stroke of incredibly bad luck. Such events will happen, but they will be very rare.


The bitter lesson tells you about the trend in the technology. It does not get product to market with today's technology.


Yeah cause every car needs 8xH200 pulling 10kW to run a VLM at realtime speeds. Would be unfortunate if 4G dropped out under some trees while using the API after all.


Power usage isn't an issue. 10 kW is 13 HP. The size, price, and fragility of the components is the issue.


Steady 10KW load means 40 less miles after an hour of driving if your EV gets 4mi/kwh. That kind of draw would use up nearly 1/6th of my EV's battery in an hour.


Man, EVs are very efficient. I was thinking from the perspective of my 120 HP Hyundai Venue, where it would be only an extra 10% of peak power.


At the same time it's pretty crazy to look at my Ford E-Transit's power draw while on the interstate and think about just how many electronics I could power with the 20-60KW of power draw it takes to maintain 65mph on a relatively flat stretch of highway.


GPUs/XPUs are small and solid state so it’s only really price that’s a huge liking factor.

And the disinclination of these companies to push the weights of their cutting edge models into people’s cars where they can be dumped.


> Yeah cause every car needs 8xH200 pulling 10kW to run a VLM at realtime speeds.

When the models stop improving, we will get model-specific ASICs that are much more power-efficient.


> When the models stop improving

Soo, never? Granted Cerebras is a thing, if the process can be commoditized.

At the moment the area of edge inference at speed seems pretty bleak though.


As somebody working near the field, I do enjoy the fun of dreaming bespoke vision and autonomy algorithms (if I didn’t, I wouldn’t work in the field to begin with!). But I would drop it all in a heartbeat for a robot that works well. Robust, resilient robots would be such an incredible advance that the ‘how’ doesn’t matter. All of the nonsense from the current AI hype cycle would be worth it if it cashed out in Robots That Actually Work.


I can't wait for a robot that does my household chores and cleaning.

Not to mention construction, infrastructure, agriculture, manufacturing, logistics...

--

AI hype cycle? It's working today.

It's optimizing ML model graphs for me while I type this, and it already cut inference time from 30s to 18s.

--

Some people act like there was no way for the AI labs to make back the $800B being invested in data center construction this year.

If we look at global GDP, it's $126T, and even a 5% productivity gain would correspond to $6T.

Is that impossible? Is it guaranteed to all crash? I don't think so.


How do you justify all these data centers when models are becoming good enough to run locally and other models are being directly "burned" into chips (model on chip)? Open weight models are almost as good as the closed ones now and they are free/uncensored.

The only thing DCs will still be need for is training, everything else will be done locally on your own hardware.

This bubble will burst and it will be ugly.


Open models are still behind February's Mythos.

Whether they can narrow that gap in the future, or OpenAI and Anthropic widen the gap with access to more compute and their better models assisting in the research process, remains to be seen.

At this time I see no reason to believe these data centers won't be in high demand.


> OpenAI and Anthropic widen the gap

Extremely unlikely seeing what the Chinese have been able to do with the limited resources they have. The creativity in finding improvement such as what deepseek has released is incredible. At this point it's a bet on the looser if you think the open models won't catch up and surpass the closed ones.


How do you know that what OpenAI and Anthropic have isn't even more incredible?

Rumored breakthroughs in efficiency were reported a few times.


Why do we need robots when we already have people?


> Why do we need robots when we already have people?

Is this a serious question? Use your imagination...


To do what people do, but cheaper seems to be what it boils down to.


And that would be the incorrect conclusion. Yes, cheaper is better, but worse and more expensive is still in the running if your boss doesn't have to deal with the human aspect and the tasks still get done. Early cars were worse than horses, but they still won out because there wasn't the biological aspect to contend with. Think about it, a human has all sort of mushy human crap to deal with. They're going to come in hung over or just tired from the weekend/last night, all sad because their mom/brother/sister/partner got cancer/died and get into fights/trouble with HR over something a coworker did and have lower output. A magic box you can put the same tasks into and get sufficiently good output back out, and not have to give it time off because it's Christmas/their daughter's ballet recital, that you can spin up 30 copies of and spin them back down with no remorse is worth way more than simply being able to pay the box $18/hr vs $20/hr to a real live human. That's why businesses are salivating at the idea of AI/robots. Not because they'll eventually be cheaper.

The robot loses an arm because your factory is unsafe? vs a human losing an arm?

What we're not ready for is replacing GDP as the important metric. There have long been known problems with GDP, and robots are only going to make that worse. A robot maid, purchased once, saves, say 20/hrs a week in household chores. That's a meaningful quality of life upgrade, but doesn't result in the GDP bump that getting a raise and hiring a service to clean your house does.


To do what people do, without exposing humans to harms, dangers, and unnecessary risks.

Also to do the things humans don't even want to do.


So that humans can live in harmony and prosperity, where no one has to work anymore and surely every resource will be distributed fairly.

It will surely not devolve into the ultimate class war like Elysium and similar.


I think there will be a bad time, but no I don't think it'll be Elysium. There was a lot of scarcity in that plotline.


There is a type of person who thrives on risk and danger. Should we say they aren't allowed to work?


No, but they should probably work for themselves.

I don't want them working for my company, at least. I want my workers safe & sound.


For dull, dirty, and dangerous jobs!


Seems to me that AI is coming for clean well paid office jobs long before it comes for anything dirty and dangerous.


I think robotics AI revolution will come just a few years after the knowledge work AI revolution. We already have very promising robotics systems in active development.


When AI does all the good jobs who is going to afford a robotic butler?


I just want a robot butler. It doesn't have to prove mathematics theorems, just do my laundry and make lunch.


Me too but unfortunately theorem proving seems to be easier than doing laundry.


Hire a housekeeper for 2 hours a day.


I want a 24/7 robot butler. And I don't want any human strangers in my house, seeing my mess or seeing me naked.


>It’s mostly a latency problem at this point. The models are too big to run locally, but given that open-weight models like Qwen already exist, an open-weight, low latency equivalent to Astra can’t be too far out.

But this is a bit of a ridiculous take, no?

You don't need Astra for self-driving. Astra is able to build complex 3D worlds, do your taxes, shop for you, and, apparently, drive a car. A self-driving car just needs to be able to drive a car. By the time you trim down Astra to just have the minimum capabilities needed to drive a car, you'll be looking at the same models these self-driving car companies already use. Then you get to deal with the actual hard problems, like handling failure cases (which will still be present with Astra).

>The vision stack, 3D maps, lane selection grammar, occupancy networks, it’s maybe all about to give way to a single GPT looking at camera feeds and predicting the next steering wheel adjustment.

Self-driving cars have been able to do this for a long time. The problem is that it isn't robust enough given the context. I mean, if Astra can drive a car with a single camera, then presumably Astra can drive the car even better with multiple cameras, and even better than that with 3D maps, etc. And when you start to consider the expectation of performance of these systems, you realize that these features really can't be omitted. If you're a company producing self-driving cars, then you do not want to face a lawsuit for you car killing someone because it physically would have never been able to see what it was doing because it lacked a camera.

I think the real gain here is that something like Astra can be used to help build these autonomous stacks. If it is able to drive itself, then it is able to generate novel data, analyze large quantities of data, and use context that isn't typically available when processing this data to make improvements to the actual autonomy stack which is ultimately responsible for driving the car. But thinking that these car companies are going to run an LLM in a car and call it a day is just naive.


No, no - all that “useless” knowledge is the good stuff. There is no clean interface boundary for driving a car, because the only interface that has been enforced is “if a human can navigate this situation, it’s fine”. Real world driving situations can be arbitrarily complicated, and if you want >human level driving, you need human level semantic understanding of the world around you. If you see a kid about to throw a model airplane across the street in front of you, you have to bring all your “useless” world knowledge with you to recognize that as a developing hazard. If you’re supposed to bring your passenger to the city building on main and you encounter construction outside with a detour sign saying “for tax dropoff park in rear”, suddenly all of your useless knowledge about the English language, what taxes are, and the likely goal of your passenger given their destination become useful.


The key thing Astra is doing is a loop... (my understanding) To figure out where things are... It's basically use more compute, self-driving cars are usually using on-device hardware where a "loop" might be a little too risky especially if it takes too long on local hardware... I wouldn't want my AI driving model to be over the air either, yikes in the case of lag or network outages.


Doesn’t Google own Waymo? I feel like they would have connected the dots.


I believe every single company in that industry has connected those dots since years. I don’t understand how you all seem to believe that’s an original idea, they all have models already


This recent post form Waymo suggests they already use large general models: https://waymo.com/blog/2026/08/10ailessons/


That post reads like spiking the football in Tesla's face.


Astra is the first chat model with really strong spatial reasoning. Gemini is nowhere close. Hard to say what google has going on internally, but if they have an astra like model I doubt they’ve had it for very long.


Probably not. In humans, the visual processing circuitry is very different from the circuitry for language processing. There is no reason to believe GPTs will be effective at it.


Oh god, this move-fast-break-things thinking is going to kill so many people. We already have aftermarket problems with people adding in untested, unregulated self-driving features.

https://arstechnica.com/cars/2026/09/aftermarket-driver-assi...


Think this dramatically simplifies the problem. AI existed before GPTs and the AI in self-driving is optimized for self-driving and the latency you already mentioned.

Regardless of how the AI is architected, you aren't going to be able to use a generic LLM like Qwen to perform reliable self-driving, you need a highly optimized, highly specific AI.


I'm no expert, but I think the future is more about extremely low latency and low power chips with LLMs etched directly onto them. You can create specialized chips that function as "neurons" in a larger system, generating the needed reactions with a very clearly defined set of constraints.


Can you please explain what does it mean by bitter lesson in this context specifically? I keep seeing this term here. I know there is an article of the same title but I still don't understand.


Sounds really expensive. I think OpenAI and Anthropic should really not dismiss making smaller capable models that they can license out in this space on the other hand.


> The bitter lesson is finally coming for

This is hilarious, and good: Those who were too lazy/stubborn/arrogant to adapt, get disrupted and buried.


Are you using GPT without a harness? Also latency.


I think this a slight different lesson. There is one algorithm that is called transformer, rest is irreverent/performance optimization.


lol. Wait until your cloud frontier LLM stalls / disconnects due to load / interference while your car is on highway OR making unprotected left turn OR approaching pedestrians.

It is easy to make car driving *demos*.


Self-driving tech is more about reducing liability than the driving itself. The lidars and 3D maps and world models and everything else is needed to get reliability from 99.9% to 99.99% on public roads. This isn’t a SaaS product where the target is to be “good enough” at the cheapest cost.


> The two modified satellites will test hardware planned for Starlink V3 and will attempt to scan Starship’s heat shield and transmit imagery down to operators to test methods of analyzing Starship’s heat shield readiness for return to launch site on future missions

Hope we get to see those images. Would be awesome to see a 3rd person view of starship in space.


Apple silicon has been an unmitigated success so it makes sense they’d go with Ternus. On a related note Apple needs to add Ternus to their spell check dictionary


Apple Silicon wasn’t under his purview, that would be Johny Srouji.

Not saying that Ternus wouldn’t have been involved in or part of the decision making process in moving the Mac to Apple-designed silicon, but I haven’t seen any indication he was any more involved than other execs at the company.


He also got promoted


they made a bet on EUV on better commercial terms than samsung and intel could do for themselves. another point of view is that TSMC's cost structure, of having highly educated, overworked, and wildly underpaid Taiwanese employees, is the real unmitigated success.

you could say apple silicon was almost 2 years ahead of its time, or you could say that intel lost years on bad bets. there are only 3 consumer-scale, leading node foundries in the world!

is apple a, "making good commercial terms with poor counterparties" company? yes, to their core. whether it is their employees whom they worked to the bone, their suppliers in the ASEAN trade network, or the US politicians who starkly are too broke to regulate giant US corporations, for whom too little money goes too long of a way.

my point is, who the hell knows! there are many, many points of view. it's not any one thing. but one thing's for sure, i don't think i'm upgrading my phone until it blows up anymore, and this is the simple, greatest risk to their business.

so they're going to become a company that breaks phones to get people to replace them, regardless of what they are today :)


Ternus had essentially nothing to do with Apple silicon. That's all Srouji and his team.


So let’s start with a really simple decoder transformer with a single layer and single attention head, and train it to predict the next token in a sequence of text. To predict the next token you need a few things: a query for the very last token in the sequence, and a key and value for every prior token. You take your query and compute a dot product with every prior key (two large vectors in, scaler attention score out). That scaler attention score first goes through softmax, and then becomes the weight you use to compute a weighted average of your values, new value goes through the mlp, mlp output is projected into the logits from which you sample your next token (that’s the general idea at least skipped a few steps).

The last query in the sequence will be new for every new token you predict, but the set of prior keys and values stay the same, ie keys and values are reusable. The key value cache gets bigger and bigger for each new token you add to the sequence, and that’s where compression comes in. You have to store the keys and values in vram, and you’d like to keep the size down by not storing the raw uncompressed tensors. To make this work well your compression needs two things: it needs to be fast so that you can compress and decompress on the fly, and it needs to play well with softmax attention. Prior attempts at compression usually suck at one or the other, either the speed to decompress is too slow and your token/s takes a hit, or you lose important precision and the model output quality suffers. The claim in the paper is that they’ve made progress on both.


So limiting max context length also reduces VRAM needs a bit? If cache is 20% of total, 1/10th of context as a limit would mean 18% total memory reduction.


Yup exactly, in principle it helps with both inference speed by reducing memory bandwidth usage and also reduces the memory footprint of your kvcache.


I lived my whole life in the twin cities and have a lot of friends, US citizens, who are too scared to go out to eat right now because of the ICE raids. If that wasn’t the point it is certainly the effect. I applaud Walz and Frey, and I will be ranking Frey first next time he’s up for reelection. Something tells me though he will be on to bigger things than mayor of Minneapolis.


[flagged]


The allegations of fraud made by the people invading my home and terrorizing my friends? I’ll take those with a grain of salt.

And for the record, I’m not afraid of ICE, never said I was. ICE is racially profiling people, arresting them without cause, and deporting them without due process. I happen to be white, so that doesn’t apply in my case. It’s also coincidentally the same reason I feel safe posting a comment like this online. Free speech is being chilled in communities that ice targets, and I feel responsibility to relay what I’m hearing.

ICE also just gunned down a US citizen in the street, and that should scare everyone.


[flagged]


I have a hard time to understand that. The woman just accelerated from 0mph to what, 4mph? The officer was aware of the car. The car was taking a turn away from the officer.

That was no life threatening situation. If the officer had not shot, what would have happened? The woman would have left the scene while the officers already had the license plate information. So I am not sure what your take is here.


[flagged]


What caused this alleged "internal bleeding"? He wasn't hit so this is clearly a lie.


Also Minneapolis emergency services reports indicate that Jonathan Ross was not taken anywhere, but instead remained at the scene and then left with the feds.


[flagged]


I saw that video and a video of him recording and shooting, he wasn't hit by the car.


I genuinely feel sorry for you that you're so utterly cut loose from reality.


Yeah, it was filmed from three different angles. She was told to drive, she drove into him, he ended up with internal bleeding. You can see the moment she looks right at him and hits the gas.

It is absolutely frightening that you lot can watch something so physically simple and somehow not understand what happened.


What you write is fully compatible with what I have written.

So you think the officer defended his life in this situation or that he thought he was? I don't think so and I think it's clearly visible that's not the case.


> It is absolutely frightening that you lot can watch something so physically simple and somehow not understand what happened.

You are trying very hard to lie to yourself and believe it


> ICE shot someone who wasn't complying with several orders to stop her vehicle, to open her door,

The first one ordered her to leave, the next one told her to get out of her vehicle and reached into her vehicle without a warrent or justification.

Neither had any legal grounds for doing so, at least according to a civil rights lawyer who defended MAGA people deplatformed during the Biden administration.

Traffic enforcement is not within ICE's remit, particularly in this case when wide angle footage with long time frames show traffic passing both cars that are across a single lane.

> Now hitting the gas pedal and hitting an agent with your big fat SUV:

Perhaps avoid the false hyperbole.

> It's basically the same story: the left using anything it can to create martyrs

The "martyrs" are being created by the incompentance and over reach of ICE.


They’ve shot and killed American Citizens


Police shoot and kill American citizens all the time.

Obama authorized the bombing of American citizens.

Those who are authorized to commit violence tend to do so. That in itself is not really saying much.


I don’t understand why you’re bringing up Obama. Nobody is defending him, and I think you might be inferring some sort of tribalistic defensiveness without any evidence. I see that sort of thing a lot, and I’ve never understood it.

Please correct me if I misunderstood the point you were trying to make.


The point I'm trying to make is that highly respected and even lauded individuals kill American citizens and people aren't generally afraid of them, so the fact that "they've shot and killed american citizens" on its own doesn't explain any fear. But I had misread the original question so my point was not quite relevant because the question was stated with justified fear already implied.


They flashbanged a family of American citizens and put a baby in the hospital


See here, ICE chasing an American citizen: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=h6UWUXkzQVA


How does that boot taste?


I feel like it’s gotta pretty deep into their mouth. Idk how they’re not gagging


Because if an ICE agent violates your constitutional rights, you have zero recourse. There is no freedom.

If you're not afraid of that, you got your head in the sand.


Currently going on? You mean the ones which were prosecuted a few years ago? Or are you talking about that "journalist"'s YouTube video that was hyped by the government to cause misinformed rage?


Yes I am talking about that "journalist"'s YouTube video, like I said the evidence out there is accessible on the Web. If there is a nanometer evidence that implies your tax money goes to Somalians bank account, you need to investigate that.


I'm pretty traditional conservative and I don't feel that our tax money should be funding child care directly like it does these days. I want to reduce the debt and taxes.

Looking at the "journalist", I really don't understand what people say he uncovered. He showed up with a bunch of people and expected to enter a non-public facility with children to investigate and when he was denied entry, made huge claims about how over half of the state's funding is going to illegal Immigrants. I saw zero proof of anything in their "reporting" nor did I see anything credible in their approach. I fully support investigative reporting, but there's a bar that needs to be meet to be considered a journalist and rage content creators do not meet that bar.

If you want to link to specific videos that you feel do meet this bar, I'm happy to watch them, but as of now, I do not believe their reporting one bit.


This same guy, Nick Shirley, traveled to Ukraine and made a video about how there really wasn't a war and the Ukranians were just spending our money on luxury cars. A reporter, Caolan Robertson, who has spent years covering the war got an interview with him and called him out on his bullshit. If he lied about Ukraine, I am very disinclined to trust him about Somalians.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VaZYMeYWMic



I'm not sure how this relates to what I said. The links you gave were to fraud found in Brooklyn. Did Nick Shirley uncover these cases?

I do believe that there's some fraud. I even believe there's a substantial dollar value of fraud going on. I do not believe that they uncovered 9 billion dollars in fraud visiting 5 Somali run daycare facilities and being denied entry into them with a camera crew and armed security.


Well, it seemed to work well enough on you. Maybe try and think harder about your information sources. They seem to be lying to you, and you don't seem to be able to tell.


I'm way more concerned about my tax money going to Donald Trump and his family and cronies. Followed by it going to billionaires and corporations. You know things that are actually happening today. I'm not very concerned at all by fluffed up recycled true crime by d tier content creators that the administration has turned into propaganda and people like you are pushing at every opportunity.


Seriously. What percentage of my taxes are going to a "Somalians bank account" as opposed to the greedy, blatantly corrupt pigs in power? I’m guessing there’s an order of magnitude difference, if not several. They are draining the coffers and laughing in our faces about it.


Your question is essentially equivalent to "Why are you scared of the Gestapo if you aren't a Jew?"

It's not a coincidence that a winner of the Nobel Prize gifted his medal to the then Propaganda Minister Joseph Goebbels[1], exactly as María Corina Machado gifted her Nobel medal to Trump. History doesn't repeat itself, but it sure does rhyme. If you close your eyes to all these similarities, you're going to be in for a big surprise.

[1]https://www.nobelpeaceprize.org/press/press-releases/the-nob...


[flagged]


> Obama deported 3 million immigrants with ICE while he is president

Obama did it the right way, didn't he? Obama's administration managed deportations effectively and humanely, prioritizing criminals and recent arrivals through programs like Secure Communities for over 3 million removals while upholding due process, minimizing community disruptions, and avoiding widespread violence or errors like wrong-country deportations.


> The woman who got shot thought she was on a movie set, tried to act cool and then attempted to run over an officer.

Citation needed. Absolutely wild to claim to know the thoughts of a dead woman. Do you speak for the dead also?

Shills keep bring up Obama deportations. Obama's administration primarily followed the law, observed due process and habeas corpus, didn't send people to concentration camps in other countries, and didn't shoot mother's in the head and then call them terrorists.

It should be clear why the response is so different, there's no need to act naive


[flagged]


1. US Police is very well known to act on emotions instead of actual law or protocol

2. Killing her didn't make the officer safer, now he was being approached by an effectively driverless vehicle.

3. If you put yourself infront of the car for fuck all reason that is your fault, especially as a "LEO" you should know better, but I guess that is what you get when you employ power hungry people with 0 training.


For what it's worth, the ICE agent who shot Good, Jonathan Ross, worked for US Border Patrol for eight years and has been working for ICE for a decade. Further, "Ross testified in December that he was 'a firearms instructor, an active shooter instructor ... a field intelligence officer, and ... a member of the SWAT team, the St. Paul Special Response Team'."[0]

So, not only not untrained, he is a trainer.

[0]: https://www.wired.com/story/ice-agent-jonathan-ross-renee-go...


And yet he put himself in front of a vehicle that had a driver and a running engine, and partnered up with other agents who acted as a group with zero cohesion, issuing conflicting instructions, escalating the tension of a traffic infringement they had no actual legal authority to engage with.

Every trained professional I've communicated with in regard to this incident has effectively shaken their head and referred to it as a clown show of epic proportions, a textbook example of how not to engage with the public, an example of how authoritarian states deal with people they have no regard for.

Let's be honest, a great many US enforcement types come to firearms use with an any excuse approach coupled with an absence of ability to de-escalate situations. They act like walking cans of petrol looking for a tinder to throw themselves on.


Just to be clear, I think the situation is disgusting, entirely unprofessional, and intentionally violent. Maybe the shooter didn't make those mistakes to have a reason for murder, but the idea that someone of his experience would make such a completely foolish mistake is absurd.

Nobody, as far as I know, has any intention of hitting me with their car. Yet, for about a dozen simple reasons, if I'm crossing a walkway, driveway, or whatever with a car also trying to enter the road by driving through the area I'm walking, I often will walk behind the vehicle. People make mistakes. There are blind spots. Maybe they're having an emergency. Maybe they're intoxicated. Or maybe they do want to hit someone with their car.

It's just absurd to think this was appropriate behavior by a seasoned professional. It's not even the appropriate behavior for a reasonably developed child.


> The woman who got shot thought she was on a movie set, tried to act cool and then attempted to run over an officer.

Your mind-reading abilities are malfunctioning. There's clear video evidence which disproves your claim. That raises serious questions about your good faith in this discussion.

> keeping the United States safe

From who exactly? Perhaps we could have a foreign country perform an operation to remove the people directing ICE to behave like an occupying force attempting to frighten US citizens into submission. That would help keep the country safe for democracy.

Do you think democracy in the US is worth preserving? Because it sure doesn't seem that way.

> For the other comment, you can check yourself if you don't believe in fraud.

This is a completely irrelevant distraction that just adds to the impression of bad faith from you.


Imagine being in favor of “papers, please” in America


Humans don’t learn to write messy complex code. Messy, complex code is the default, writing clean code takes skill.

You’re assuming the LLM produces extra complexity because it’s mimicking human code. I think it’s more likely that LLMs output complex code because it requires less thought and planning, and LLMs are still bad at planning.


Totally agree with the first observation. The default human state seems to be confusion. I've seen this over and over in junior coders.

It's often very creative how junior devs approach problems. It's like they don't fully understand what they're doing and the code itself is part of the exploration and brainstorming process trying to find the solution as they write... Very different from how senior engineers approach coding when it's like you don't even write your first line until you have a clear high level picture of all the parts and how they will fit together.

About the second point, I've been under the impression that because LLMs are trained on average code, they infer that the bugs and architectural flaws are desirable... So if it sees your code is poorly architected, it will generate more of that poorly architected code on top. If it sees hacks in your codebase, it will assume hacks are OK and give you more hacks.

When I use an LLM on a poorly written codebase, it does very poorly and it's hard to solve any problem or implement any feature and it keeps trying to come up with nasty hacks... Very frustrating trial and error process; eats up so many tokens.

But when I use the same LLM on one of my carefully architected side projects, it usually works extremely well, never tries to hack around a problem. It's like having good code lets you tap into a different part of its training set. It's not just because your architecture is easier to build on top, but also it follows existing coding conventions better and always addresses root causes, no hacks. Its code style looks more like that of a senior dev. You need to keep the feature requests specific and short though.


> About the second point, I've been under the impression that because LLMs are trained on average code, they infer that the bugs and architectural flaws are desirable

This is really only true about base models that haven’t undergone post training. The big difference between ChatGPT and GPT3 was OpenAI’s instruct fine tuning. Out of the box, language models behave how you describe. Ask them a question and half the time they generate a list of questions instead of an answer. The primary goal of post training is to coerce the model into a state in which it’s more likely to output things as if it were a helpful assistant. The simplest version is text at the start of your context window like: “the following is code was written by a meticulous senior engineer”. After a prompt like that the most likely next tokens will never be the models imitation of a sloppy code. Instruct fine tuning does the same thing but as permanent modifications to the weights of the model.


Image generation and image input are two totally different things. This is about feeding text into LLMs as images, it has nothing to do with image generation.


Yeah but IIUC they're both just representations of embeddings in a latent space, translated from one format to another. So if the image interpretation of a text embedding is full of hallucinations, it's unlikely that the other direction works well either (again, IIUC).

That said, I'll be interested to see what the DeepSeek model can do once they've trained it in the other direction. It'd be great to have it output architecture diagrams that actually correspond to what it says in the chat.


Here's my version, took about 5 minutes to create inside the ChatGPT web interface. https://valine.github.io/vibe-coded-ant-game/

I don't know if this game was vibe coded, but it certainly could have been. Most notable thing about this post is probably that vibe coded games are good enough now to fool HN.


I love the "Don't trust everything you see on HN" banner.


Both Claude and GPT5 can single shot this type of game. The score counter looks exactly like the type of thing Claude spits out.


OP made the game with its own engine so I think that makes it very unlikely


Fair enough, it is impossible to know. I'm making an assumption based on the fact that the use of AI wasn't mentioned anywhere I could see, and people usually mention it.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: