Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | vegor5's commentslogin

Should have gotten the lethal injection.


It seems to me that this is an example of exactly the kind of shenanigans that are why we should not allow the government to execute people. If a single judge can wrongfully imprison 4,000 children - and not out of ineptitude, but for profit - then how can we possibly trust the rest of the judicial system not to convict innocent people of capital crimes?


It seems to me that if anyone deserves the death penalty, it's people like this judge.

Ordinary citizens don't have the power to deprive citizens of their civil rights at such a scale, it requires the extraordinary power of the state. The trust we need to have in judges makes such corruption not only more likely, but much more dangerous. So for cases like this, the punishment ought to be as extraordinary as the power needed for the crime.

I personally oppose the death penalty, so the suggestion is only half-serious, but I find the reasoning for reserving executions for egregious political corruption to be more compelling than for more common crimes.


> I personally oppose the death penalty, so the suggestion is only half-serious, but I find the reasoning for reserving executions for egregious political corruption to be more compelling than for more common crimes.

I'm with you there. The way I see it, crimes like these threaten the very premise of our justice system. It is hard for me to imagine a worse crime than destroying our ability to handle crime at all. Punishment for all those other horrible crimes relies on the system people like this are threatening.


Or sent him to the same prison before all those kids got released for wrongful imprisonment.


Yeah, because we in the States really love to make a big thing and encourage the abuses that can happen in prison.

Wow...


Disturbingly, we kind of do... See common attitudes towards prison rape, and the origin of the concept of 'rape culture'.


Indeed. I was being sarcastic in a disappointed and condescending tone, as I don't think that's something we should encourage.


how about 28 years in the electric chair?


What about one of those skin tight spandex suits with shock electrodes in it? Then give the kids a smart phone with an app that allows them to shock on demand. Every time they feels angry or frustrated at their lives being ruined, then can seemly shock the judge...

"Shock the Judge".... Now there's a game show I'd watch.


Bart! Stop shocking your sister! Bzzzt! (non-lethal version for ongoing fun & games :-))


Ignorance is bliss.


Ballmer likes stack ranking. I don't know why...


The religion inside the company (not my personal view, but what you'll get if you talk to an upper-echelon manager) is that:

- stack ranking leads to competition leads to everyone doing their best,

- at the end of the day you have to offer differentiated rewards to your team, and it's better to offer more rewards to those who earned them (vs. just blanketing everyone with the same rewards)--stack ranking just makes this explicit, and

- it puts pressure on bottom performers to leave the company or find a team that's a better match.

That said, I recently left Microsoft (after 8 years in the Office org, probably near OP), and stack ranking was one of the reasons. For me the toughest part of it was that I felt there was no part of my compensation that was tied to the overall product my team produced--we could have produced a gorgeously engineered, ground-breaking product or a buggy piece of bloatware no customer wanted; it really didn't matter from a review perspective.

Stack ranking is also generally despised by the rank-and-file, often because they are sure it's the reason they haven't had a meteoric rise despite their obvious superiority over everyone else. Folks who have "made it" to the upper echelon often mysteriously acquire the stack ranking religion.


it puts pressure on bottom performers to leave the company or find a team that's a better match.

Stack-ranking makes it impossible for everyone but the top 25% to transfer, though, because no one wants someone with a bad or mediocre review history.

If you need to fire people, fire them. Flushing out good people in the name of stack ranking is a pointless, morale-killing waste.


Also, firing someone based on stack-ranking takes about 2 years (at least it did on my team).


Play poker, gotta know when to fold.


Scrum masters, jira, process. It's even infecting startups now.


What do you think is bad about using jira at a startup? I'm not trying to be obnoxious, but I've only ever worked at two startups (~120 people - I'm 21) and both used jira for bug management.


It's poorly implemented. Slow, rendering kills browsers. Takes too much space in the screen in order to be useful. It's just a shitty product and not built for decent software engineering.. Not for all types of engineering either.

That's my biggest problem. Say iOS developemtn is asset heavy and requires a decent way of sorting your assets with your stories. JIRA is complete shit for that. Trying to explain that to the agile coach or scrum master... yeah.


Jira works, but then you meet people who created their "careers" around using Jira. Then it all goes to hell. The VCs are going to lose a lot of money to them.


Yup, sounds like the Microsoft I know. (Used to work there)


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: