Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | vlan0's commentslogin

Right, hence their comment about uplinks. They cheap out, that saturates, then we buffer

bufferbloat is actually more than that; it’s actually that the buffers are oversized, which is typically not what you want. This causes a lot of jitter and increases latency.

basically, for realtime stuff, you want to prefer packets being dropped rather than buffered.

this includes your home router, but also your ISP’s router, and maybe even your ISP’s uplink router. again, this just means getting a good one that actually cares about this stuff.

this is an excellent resource on the subject: https://www.bufferbloat.net/projects/bloat/wiki/Introduction...


That's why auto_qos was invented...

And it makes echo cancellation terrible.

I think you are getting at something here. The benefit piece. The proximity to community. But the society in the US is not structured in a way to make this happen. Municipality is basically a bad word at this point. But imagine localized network, compute, green energy, battery etc.

Even then I still think I'd rather see the money flow shared. The less funnels that go to a few people, the better for all of us.

Th best folks I know wouldn't touch a government job, no matter the pay.

There was a period of time where it seemed (as an outsider) that they were attracting good talent. This was when Megan Smith was CTO. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Megan_Smith.

Bruh do you remember snowden? The government is HEAVILY sub-contracted. Accenture? Really? My guy...

>Of all the options for "use money to make this go away so I can focus on the problem" paying $10 surcharge for doordash is by far the cheapest.

Exactly this. They know humans will likely pick the path of least resistance. And we are generally bad at problems that have compounding long term outcomes. They are essentially preying on our societal circumstances. My story: Brain will resist using energy for creative solution from within if external solution exists for $.


My example is _not_ preying. That $10 does nothing to help our lives if invested in diversified etfs, for example. The _best_ use of that $10 is to alleviate the instantaneous stressors for 4-5 people all at once so we can relax and solve larger problems (my spouse works for pro-social non-profits, for example).

Yes, doordash can prey on laziness, and people will fall into laziness, but in my example the _availability_ of the service is providing a price-adjustment for urgency that matches my own rational prioritization of the evening's needs. It's the most rational, mutually-beneficial argument I can make, and it's real in my house from time to time.


>And how many more times do we need to read this before we replace Web PKI with a system that isn't as completely insane?

You say this like it's easy and simple and we are simply not choosing to do so.


If only someone had invented a technology for a decentralized ledger that could be used to store public keys back in 2009, but alas


It's been obvious for a while now that root-of-trust schemes create juicy targets, and that juicy targets attract all sorts of bad behavior that wouldn't be economical if we used a web-of-trust.

Building a web-of-trust scheme that works might not be easy, but also it's not like we've been trying exceptionally hard lately either.


Web-of-trust doesn't work. Even before the PGP web-of-trust broke down several years ago, analyses of how the web-of-trust actually ended up working out showed that it basically boils back down to CAs: people rely on a few highly central keys to do most of the signing rather than signing keys themselves, and these keys effectively function like CAs.

The broader issue is that users don't want to (and probably don't have the ability to) actually make any trust decisions; they much prefer to delegate all of the decisions on trustworthiness to somebody else. The PKI root CA system does have its flaws, but on the whole, I suspect that people like Mozilla are better stewards as to whether or not the person vouching for somebody else is trustworthy than the average or even the above-average user.


PGP is indeed a problematic implementation, but it's just one of many possible ways to do a web of trust. It's not 1991 anymore. How many more of these failures must we endure before we consider alternatives to trees as a data structure for handling trust?


> Even before the PGP web-of-trust broke down several years ago

I'm not sure I'm familiar with what moment this is referring to; can you elaborate?



Web of trust has been working between humans for over a million years. If we've failed to make computers do it, it's probably just for lack of trying.

To your second point, that might be true in a world where the consequences of making a bad trust decision was some kind of hassle related to changing passwords or reporting your cards stolen. But we seem to be moving towards a world where it lands you in a detention facility or some other dire consequence. I think that sooner or later, users are going to realize that they want that control and will be willing to do the corresponding trust hygiene work. Besides, isn't making that kind of work easy the point of technology? We just need to do better re: making it usable rather than investing in systems we know to be unsafe.


> Web of trust has been working between humans for over a million years.

I'm not sure that's really true. Human social organization has, until around 10,000 years ago, been centered on small groups of people where everyone literally knew each other. The ethnographic studies on non-state complex societies generally tends to show a lot of kinship-based networks that developed, and even in state societies that are facilitating long-distance trade, trade patterns and introduction into new areas is heavily reliant on membership of these kinship groups. State societies generally deemphasize these kinship groups, eventually doing away with them like in modern society, but the mechanisms for developing social trust are based on a very centralized development of the legal system--the government essentially enforces that people have to be trustworthy, or they face the wrath of government otherwise.

Essentially, in short, the idea that humans have regularly been trusting people based on asking their close compatriots who they can vouch for doesn't seem to accurately model how trust develops in societies for most of human history--you either have vouching based on direct observation (in small societies), vouching based on identity (larger non-state societies), or centralized authority vouching for people (state societies, including today).


I don't think people do trust others on the basis of the government vouching for them. The government may like to think so, but when Dr. Fauci told us to wear a mask we didn't do it because the government said he was trustworthy, those of us who did so (if we didn't have the education to validate it ourselves) did it because we have a friend or a relative who works in healthcare and they said that Dr. Fauci was right on this one. People don't trust what they see on Facebook because a root certificate indicated that it was served on a page that Facebook controls, they do so because their friends liked the thing. We don't trust that the food in the supermarket has been kept at a safe temperature because the health department claims to have inspected the facility recently, we do so because we know somebody who works at the grocery store and we know that person would tell us if it were not safe to eat the food there. We rely on the grapevine heavily.

That's not to say that we can dispense with these institutions, but they are not whence the trust comes, rather they're a sort of nucleation site around which the peer to peer trust we've been relying on for hundreds of thousands of years can coalesce. The institutional structures are an index of things that we may or may not trust, their utility is that the index lowers the information processing burden of doing so in either case.

The friend-or-foe decision started to become computationally burdensome as populations increased, and it has indeed failed to scale, but it's still in there doing its best, making it look like the centralized attempts are working because often they're aligned.

But when the people in charge decide that they no longer care to protect the people who they're in charge of, that alignment slips, and suddenly the most powerful organization on the planet can't win a war against pond scum.

The trust has always been peer to peer. We can find ways to improve it, so it works better for us, or we can continue the charade that it's replaceable with a central authority, to the peril of those who embrace the substitution.

Ultimately this is a synchronization problem. EMudhra has lost their standing in the web of trust we've been using all along, and because the path between them and the average user is so circuitous, third parties need to step in and revoke that trust in the centralized trust stores that we're using to approximate that web. If our technology better aligned with how our actual trust worked, those paths would be short, blast radii of this kind would be small, and the urgency of action could be assessed more accurately because the actors would be protecting themselves from risks they understand, rather than acting to protect users that they don't know and who don't know them.


Humans are generally considered to have been around for only ca. 300'000 years.

Also, the interpersonal web of trust is IMHO quite clearly failing in the age of mass media, and not just recently.


Sure, but what do we do from here? Attempt to augment it with technology so that it starts scaling again, or give up and replace it with something centralized?


Right...but putting everything behind the great firewall doesn't solve the true problem. Which is these devices are shipping with garbage and no accountability. We'll break into your moat if that's what it truly takes, is my point.


>It's very difficult to have informed opinions on a black box with an ambiguous, ever-changing and nominally unbounded set of capabilities.

Hah, welcome to what it can feel like to manage people.


Programmers leaning on agents have switched from engineering into management, but not all of them have accepted this yet.


What it most reminds me of is working with a team of outsourced developers. One of those ones at an outsourcing company with high turnover so you can never really build up any level of shared vision or tribal knowledge base, so constant micro-management is an outright necessity for any medium- to long-term project.


this is, arguably, why senior managers are so all-in on AI

you send an email to get something done and you get an unreliable answer from the peons... is it truly that different from an unreliable AI?


Nah, these are the same folks that have never watched earthlings.

If we made it so before one could eat meat of the animal, it had to personally kill and watch the animal die, we’d eat less meat.

It should be a requirement


It used to be that pretty much everyone who ate meat butchered it themselves. They still ate as much meat as they could.


It used to be that kids as young as five year old were made to kill small animals like bunnies and chickens as a learning experience, but a bunch of people found this problematic so it isn't as common anymore.


I grew up this way. Did you?


People willingly turned a blind eye to concentration camps which killed millions of human beings in their back yards. Distraction, denial, and indifference are more comfortable reactions than horror.

People tend to seek the feeling of blamelessness when they should seek the condition of blamelessness. Often doing the right thing will make a person feel guiltier than doing the wrong one.


I would be fine with that, but I don't think it would be quite as effective as you think. I don't like hurting even bugs for no reason but still grew up eating our own raised cows and hunted meat and still do to this day. Atleast half of that I had a personal hand in the entire slaughtering and packing.

If anybody has even the smallest negative thought to eating meat these days, the very first internet search they do will bombard them with pictures of slaughter houses in the most negative light and animal abuse pictures. If that doesn't stop them eating meat itself, very few are going to be turned by a legit farming and slaughter practises.

My sister is vegan and it wasn't our slaughtering of animals that pushed her away from eating meat, it was the internet showing the worst of large corporate practises. For a long while she merely didn't eat corporate meat and only local or home grown or hunted meat.


Depends how it is done, but can also have the opposite effect of making people more used to cruel behavior.

I do like what they did for example:

https://www.nytimes.com/2017/01/13/world/europe/norway-schoo...


Genuinely, how the fuck can you believe that when people have personally slaughtered the meat they consume for most of human history?

My wife grew up in a country where people would still personally slaughter pigs to roast at major holidays. Didn’t keep her or any of her family from eating meat.


We eat far more meat now at a time when far far fewer people are personally slaughtering animals than ever before in human history, so I think the claim checks out.

People who kill animals themselves regularly are probably subsistence farmers who consider meat a luxury, and what's more, the way they killed them was probably nothing like the incredibly high volume processing that goes on in a modern slaughterhouse.

I definitely think that if most people had to visit a modern factory farm and see the life cycle of one of these animals, kill it and process it, they would probably be shocked at what is legal.


> We eat far more meat now

This statement is thrown around a lot, but it doesn't really check out. Per-capita meat consumption in most of the west is only around 66kg/year (increasing to 100-120kg/year for meat-heavy countries like Spain, Argentina, and the USA).

That's about one pig and a handful of birds - even many peasant populations could afford to raise that much meat each year. The well-off were consuming massively more meat that this throughout history. Not to mention the incredible quantities of fish consumed by coastal populations.

Records from Durham and Westminster cathedrals suggest monks were eating in excess of 400kg/year of meat and fish. Records from Italy in a similar period show labourers and even widows receiving in excess of 80kg/year of meat. And so on...


>Records from Durham and Westminster cathedrals suggest monks were eating in excess of 400kg/year of meat and fish.

I feel like I eat quite a lot of meat. And even I find that number rather suspect. Over a kilo a day? They did also do labour, but still that sounds extremely high even for pure carnivore diet of today... Or then there is some sort of significant waste.


Interesting to poke around in: https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/per-capita-meat-consumpti...

It sadly doesn't go back further than the 1960s. If you select Western Europe, the number seems to be falling (back from almost 100kg, though). USA, not so much.

Note though that for what your parent describes, you'd want numbers to go even further back, then you could likely see the whole effect of post-WW2 boom; though WW2 itself would obviously also extremely skew the data in the 40s.


Most people in "developed" countries do not eat whole animals, but only selected parts of them.

So the number of dead animals per year needed to sustain a typical human is much greater.

For example someone who is a much more moderate meat eater than most, might eat at least half of their protein intake from vegetables, with the remainder from healthy chicken breast meat, eating around 1 kg of raw chicken breast per week, i.e. from 2 dead chicken.

That means 100 dead chicken per human per year, though it is likely that other less choosy humans would eat the thighs and a few other parts, so the 100 chicken would actually sustain between 2 and 3 humans for a year.

That is not a "handful" of birds.


Right, but that's purely reflective of a shift in meat preferences - a single pig would provide the same amount of meat as your 100 chickens. And historically, everyone ate pork and beef, not chicken (chicken doesn't become a major source of meat until after WWII).


The rest of the chicken isn't just thrown away.


> Genuinely, how the fuck can you believe that when people have personally slaughtered the meat they consume for most of human history?

...There's an argument to be made that the average modern human is too cowardly to be capable of butchering their own meat.

Is that true? ...Unfortunately, there's a non-zero proportion of people that will fit that mold. But I hope that it isn't the case for at least 90% of the population.


Slaughterhouse staff must all be vegans by now.


Perhaps some do eat less meat as vlan0 suggested. Perhaps some don't change their habits, trying to cope with the mental burden.

> It was found that [slaughterhouse workers] have a higher prevalence rate of mental health issues, in particular depression and anxiety, in addition to violence-supportive attitudes. Furthermore, the workers employ a variety of both adaptive and maladaptive strategies to cope with the workplace environment and associated stressors. Finally, there is some evidence that slaughterhouse work is associated with increased crime levels. The research reviewed has shown a link between slaughterhouse work and antisocial behavior generally and sexual offending specifically.

https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/full/10.1177/15248380211030...


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: