That's a poor characterization of the article and they don't need peer review to be science. By definition the planets circled earth because before peer review said so and they didn't have the tools to measure it.
Science in modern sense of the word is almost certainly a cult like religion. Try speaking out against it and people who care more about protecting its name are the loudest in the room instead of the actual scientists pushing boundaries and making new discoveries.
A committee of truth keepers is entirely a political entity, not scientists.
Peer review, under the zealot conceptualization, is a committee of people advising other readers to take the committee’s word for it.
More honestly, scientists must be independently literate beyond what peer reviewers endorse, both because peer reviewers cannot cover every report ever produced and also because peer reviewers sometimes get it wrong.
Every scientific reader must function autonomously, engaging critically and thoughtfully with the intellectual material they consume. Maybe a child would expect everything to be curated for them by tastemakers and then handed over on a silver platter, but lazy consumption is not the purpose of being a scientist. Scientists are meant to participate actively in the scientific process, not to merely receive wisdom from others.
Why though? If you own a company, you delegate purchasing to human employees, too. And sometimes they buy crap and make poor decisions. It comes with the risk, and you mitigate by budgeting. You will have to asses your employees for competence, same as you do with agents. You don't give a new and unknown employee a big budget, while your trusted ones slowly get more and more control.
This is what everybody gets wrong: Agents aren't bad or evil. Nor crazy. They don't steal. They pretty much work (after some setup and periods of supervision) as expected. And yes, sometimes they might be wrong and spend more. Same as the human. From a business standpoint it is just risk/reward structure.
True and calculations are changing inside large corps that run BPOs. You just don't see the news on HN, cause HN hardly surfaces what is happening inside Enterprise Software stacks.
None of them are able to put two and two together that this was a deliberate coup
And it seems like nobody is paying attention to what Jensen Huang was fighting for. He was against regulation of open source local models. He was against regulation shifting liability of local model developers as well as frontier models.
All in all without Jensen, it isn't just about NVIDIA, there's no one to champion for open source models and running them locally is going to get a lot harder and expensive. It's actually going to accelerate the monopolization of closed models and they will have to pass on the costs to consumers.
It's an L across the board and I'm noting the degraded quality of discourse on HN and that nobody is seeing through the veil here.
Jensen Huang was against regulation of open models because he was *for* selling GPUs. He was so for it, he might have helped an Alibaba corporate cutout launder a bunch of them against US trade regulations.
You may think that's a ridiculous bigger picture, but that's the bigger picture I'm looking at. I think your bigger picture of, "this is an inside-the-industry coup to remove the one champion of open weights models," is even more ridiculous.
Both of these notwithstanding, what makes you believe nvidia's new permanent CEO won't also be a champion for open weights? An open weights ecosystem is better for their business long term.
Or they’re simply clear eyed enough to not reach for conspiracy theories as an answer when one man’s ego and inability to keep it in his pants is the obvious explanation
When some people have the desire to oust you and suddenly find a plausible excuse, is that a conspiracy or just grabbing an opportunity that is presented?
I think this is what makes a conspiracy theorist personality diverge from rational thinking; they will focus on the active part of the people who benefit from the outcome and imply that have planned it all along and schemed secretly and "who knows how much else we don't know about".
They almost certainly have nothing of value other than just reading their own posts and feeling good about themselves instead of engaging constructively the very topic at hand.
I really dislike engaging with HN throwaways on this site. They add nil in terms of value and its disappointing to see that with all the moderation that is done on this site it has created just a wildly polarized echo chamber for people to feel good about their own virtue signaling .
Fortunately, that random law you pulled itself says there has to be beyond reasonable doubt conspiracy and malice intent. This doesn't seem to be the case seeing Jensen himself was caught offguard by the nature of his relationship.
The same legal system that protects you applies to everyone else billionaire or not.
> This doesn't seem to be the case seeing Jensen himself was caught offguard by the nature of his relationship.
There are two separate aspects to his relationship that are important:
1) Did he know she was a Chinese spy? Maybe not. I have no idea. It would certainly be hard to prove.
2) Did he know her company was diverting stock to the Chinese market? Almost certainly. He would have to be an actual moron to not realize this years ago, and he isn't a moron. I'd be shocked if after investigation that enough evidence didn't come to light to prove without a shadow of a doubt that he knew about the diversion the whole time.
#2 is where his real legal troubles lie. #1 is just the dramatic clickbait intrigue but not really what is likely to sink him.
The only way #1 is really important is in that it is drawing a lot of attention to looking into #2 (which was, by many reports, already a widely known open secret despite the illegality).
The stuff they are selling aren't for consumer GPUs those have completely different supply chain economics and they are not coming down for reasons why everything else is elevated in prices
I don't get it what does his personal life has to do with him running NVIDIA? Also despite what is being disseminated in the mainstream media, he lobbied to make China reliant on much older chips which were approved and puts America at a huge advantage, but narratives are being wildly twisted to sell that Jensen Huang acted dishonorably against this country.
There is a nasty smear campaign against Jensen Huang throughout social media, cheating on his wife is one thing, political maneuvering before we even learn of what the actual damage if any was done and kneecapping an enterprise while America has a lead over others in AI is sabotage.
> what does his personal life has to do with him running NVIDIA?
Jensen banged a customer and Chinese spy while advocating for lifting exports controls on China and corruptly quashing investigations into her firm [1].
He couldn’t have turned this into more of a public spectacle and concern if he tried. (Coming clean right after the Congress flipped didn’t help.)
He also wanted to lift export controls to China before he met her. It's unclear that she actually influenced anything in that direction. His bread would already have been buttered for selling to additional markets.
Selling to her data center in Malaysia, a Token Speak-easy as Mo called it, may be a bigger deal in actual effect.
This isn’t about his personal life. This affair led to compromised business decisions that affect global politics. And he covered it up for a full year.
It was not illegal to sell to Megaspeed. It should have been in my opinion (lets be real, Singapore=China in this context), but it was not. NVIDIA is obligated to comply with export controls and they did. Megaspeed wasn't black listed. The good business decision is to sell more chips not less.
That wouldn't have changed the fact that they legally sold Megaspeed chips though.
Megaspeed was not blacklisted. If Megaspeed did become export controlled and NVIDIA sold them chips then that's definitely a carless business decision. But lobbying the government not to blacklist a customer is not.
I don't see a compelling reason for NVIDIA to fire Huang. If stuff comes out and he was doing something fraudulent and evading export controls then I would agree that's a bad business decision. It puts NVIDIA at risk to say the least. And what NVIDIA and Huang did could even be bad for the country.
> wouldn't have changed the fact that they legally sold Megaspeed chips
It very well could have, apart from the corruption.
Congress wrote a law designating certain categories of companies illegal to sell chips to. Commerce was in charge of implementing it. If Nvidia fucked with Commerce, that could make the sales illegal even without a destination—the law the Congress wrote controls.
Singapore is not an export controlled country so they either need to be on the blacklist or be a Chinese company, of which they are neither.
>If Nvidia fucked with Commerce, that could make the sales illegal even without a destination—the law the Congress wrote controls.
This is not true. Congress did not export control Chinese companies and even if NVIDIA "fucked with Commerce" it would not retroactively make their sales illegal, because Commerce is the one setting the rules.
You have the relationship wrong with the 2018 export control law. Congress granted the power to the executive to set export controls. Congress didn't define specific companies nor broad categories of companies to export control.
>Congress has delegated to the executive branch some of its express constitutional authority to regulate foreign commerce by controlling exports.
> Singapore is not an export controlled country so they either need to be on the blacklist or be a Chinese company, of which they are neither
It is illegal to "export...when you have 'knowledge' at the time of export, reexport, or transfer (in-country) that the item is destined for a destination, end use, or type of end user" that is prohibited by law [1]. Using a middleman to evade export restrictions is not a get-out-of-jail card.
> Congress did not export control Chinese companies
Fair enough. The existing law does, however, prohibit the sorts of transfers Nvidia made to Megaspeed without a license, which Nvidia didn't obtain [2]. (And again, quashed investigations into.)
AG, CIA, DNI, incoming chairman of DHI all says she's not a spy today. So many people like you cheered for the spy story to be true. Turns out you shouldn't arrive at conclusions based on anonymous stories published by new york times who's poor journalist practices are widely known.
One possibility is lobbying Trump, who has pushed for easing export controls to China, against the advice of the national security professionals. There's that 15% revenue share that was negotiated around the same time Trump was informed about Megaspeed, Alice, and Jensen.
selling $7 billion of your company’s product to your affair partner - despite export restrictions - certainly seems directly related to how he runs NVIDIA.
Getting caught publicly making egregious unforced errors in judgment is hardly a smear campaign.
There is a very good chance he could* (if not a billionaire) go to prison for the rest of his life if he knowingly evaded sanctions and was involved in a conspiracy to do so.
He is already in jail.
He’s no longer a free man and never will be again.
He’s now the US Government’s bitch.
If they are confident he knowingly facilitated the transfer of restricted technology or sensitive information to Chinese interests they can charge him any time with treason and float having him publicly executed on livestream if they wanted to.
"Treason against the United States shall consist only in levying War against them, or in adhering to their Enemies, giving them Aid and Comfort."
If he knowingly aided China, and personally profited, I think getting a 4.8b payday from those weapons-grade technology transfers is a pretty good indicator that he knowingly aided China, while keeping a relationship with a foreign adversary’s intelligence asset for over a year and in that time reportedly tried to influence the commander in chief to allow for more exports of weapons-grade technology to said foreign adversary. That’s textbook treason.
Aiding them in acquiring chips they then could use to hack the us energy grid in a confrontation, develop better missile capabilities to hit US warships in a conflict with Taiwan, etc., or simply develop better cybercrime capabilities, makes you an enemy of the State.
Also, you can’t get more compromised than Chinese intelligence having sextapes of you doing weird shit naked in your black jacket to one of their intelligence assets.
The US Government owning your ass for the rest of your miserable life in a golden cage is not very fun.
How’s life for Snowden in Russia, you think?
I doubt they will let him resign, he needs to travel and be their AI clown, and every time he comes back he will be a good dog and tell his masters everything he heard and seen from all those important people he has access to.
Who in their right mind is going to sit in the same room as Jensen Huang and be confident that whatever he hears or gets from you is not going to end up either in Beijing or Washington?
How do you continue doing business with Nvidia like this, if you for very good reasons, need to have zero trust in their CEOs confidentiality?
The outrage is mostly about people's hatred for the tech sector and it's leaders. Being friendly with Trump, absurdly rich, ai adjacent, etc. There is a perception of oligarchy, corruption, exploitation, stealing from the poor, etc.
It will be glorious watching the downfall for sure. This guy enabled the robbery of human civilization. He was doing his best to prevent local AI from taking off. Basically, he's an all around ruthless piece of shit, like most CEO's.
He wasn't just trying to get some honey on his stinger. He's much more nefarious than that.
> He was doing his best to prevent local AI from taking off.
I'm not so sure about that angle. Or like, that's a very specific direction. As CEO, his responsibility is to make a product that people will buy so the company gets money and can continue. If local AI had money, he would and should have gone towards that. Companies having money and contracts doesn't mean he went out of his way to ensure local AI doesn't happen as a personal beef against some... thing?
yes, yes. and then president ¡Ocasio! will enact a global moratorium on abominable intelligence, launch nukes at Yandex's data centers, and the world will return to the glorious ZIRP times when the hardworking folx in San Francisco could earn $500k a year for lovingly handcrafting artisanal webshit frameworks.
or maybe this artificial controversy will be forgotten long before the orange man leaves the office.
You're using the term outrage, I think others just see it for what it is, very stupid, very juvenile, very untrustworthy and this all makes him very compromised?
>You're using the term outrage, I think others just see it for what it is, very stupid, very juvenile, very untrustworthy
I'm using the term "outrage" to describe the public's reaction to his actions. You are using the terms "very stupid" etc. to describe his actions, right? I don't see any disagreement between us.
2) I do not agree outrage implies overreaction. Here is a local news article from 2 days ago about the outrage some racist gesture caused. Do you think they are implying the negative reaction to racist gestures is overblown? https://www.wtva.com/2026/11/09/ole-miss-students-doorbell-c...
You are splitting hairs. People feel strongly about what he did and what sort of punishment he should incur.
You can substitute in "People feel strongly about what he did and what sort of punishment he should incur" for the term "outrage" above and you will understand my meaning.
> basically both sides now dislike that he flip flopped
No, the dumb thing is the idea that there are "sides".
> basically both sides now dislike that he flip flopped
Literally the only people with this opinion of Tao are internet forum warriors who have no expertise in the field and who's opinion of Tao don't matter in the slightest.
> who's opinion of Tao don't matter in the slightest.
Similarly, Tao being ‘on the warpath’ does not matter in the slightest when it comes to formalizing math and finding proofs to important unsolved problems with AI.
“I’m on a war footing,” he said while grabbing coffee during a two-day math workshop at the University of California, Los Angeles, that was rife with talk about the existential crisis that artificial intelligence has created in his field.
reply