Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I agree with mahouse and of course are some of these password legit. But this is nothing new, don't store sensitive data in git. Everyone know you can search this stuff on GitHub and if we look back - Google was a nice password search engine too (and still today)


Don't store sensitive data in git, or don't store sensitive data on public github repos?


Don't even store sensitive data in git, it can be a bad idea: http://www.jamiembrown.com/blog/one-in-every-600-websites-ha...

Store credentials in environment variables.


How would you go about making a repeatable, automated deployment if you don't store configuration information in source control to load into the environment variables?


Depends on what you're using for your deployments, for example if you were using Puppet you might use something like https://github.com/TomPoulton/hiera-eyaml


Sorry, how does this prevent you requiring configuration in source control, or are you just suggesting that those credentials should be encrypted?


Consul and Vault go a long way to achieving that.

https://consul.io/

https://vault.io


Doesn't this just push the problem up (down?) a level in the hierarchy? I mean, you still need to deploy these and configure them with the information the rest of your deployment requires right?


That link is talking about a problem with e.g. .htaccess and basic directory permissions, not a problem using git per se. But yeah, put that stuff in envars.


If there's any question, I think the rule has to be the former. There are standard, auditable ways to keep sensitive data out of git: .gitignore, environmental vars, etc. Once it's in git, any attempts to keep it out of a public repo will probably be manual and ad hoc.

If the organization is "closed" by default, i.e. it only rarely releases code to the public, this may not matter as much.




Consider applying for YC's Winter 2027 batch! Applications are open till November 2.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: