Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

You have me genuinely puzzled at how you somehow claim that because the term 'state' in this context is 800 years old, it means that law made later than this is somehow weak. I genuinely don't get this age-of-etymology argument you're using.

In any case, age of a law is not an automatic trump card. There are multiple sites on the web listing silly laws from the 19th century that never get enforced, for example.

> to see if it would stick, or something.

What, you mean like saying that the individual US states are as sovereign as China?

Also, "I've got a BS and my partner has a PhD in topic X, and I can verify my point by my reading of Wikipedia"? Seriously? Well, my reading of Wikipedia says that you're completely wrong! I'm also King of Namibia and my bestie is the Pope. Just take my word for it.



Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: