Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Storing your addicted+homeless population in a prison is not only inhumane, it's not effective. And just moves the costs elsewhere. (And often increases them, since incarcerating someone is not cheap. Where will this money come from?) The problem has been swept under a rug, not actually solved.


There are two conflicting claims floating around in this thread:

> "And just moves the costs elsewhere" / "the good old 'bus them out of town, let them be someone else's problem' non-solution."

And

> "The King County homeless census[1] found the overwhelming majority of homeless in the area were living in the area before becoming homeless."

It's pretty obvious both aren't true. Either Seattle's homeless are produced primarily by Seattle, or Seattle's homeless supply is from other cities. If the homeless are coming from other cities, that supports the idea that Seattle is making itself attractive to the nation's homeless (and should stop doing that.) If Seattle's homeless are predominately from Seattle, not other cities, then Seattle should seek to emulate cities that produce fewer homeless.

Personally I believe the later theory is false. I don't believe that most of the homeless in Seattle are originally from Seattle. However many in Seattle buy into that narrative. I think Seattle is filled with homeless because other cities kick them out and Seattle welcomes them with open arms.


> If Seattle's homeless are predominately from Seattle, not other cities, then Seattle should seek to emulate cities that produce fewer homeless.

The way to do that is to just stop having well-paid jobs be created.


You're gonna need to expand on this for anyone to understand your point.

Are you suggesting that gentrification from an influx of out of state people looking for work are to blame?


The problem is homeless are ruining my city and negatively impacting my day to day life. How is getting them away from here somewhere else not effective at literally solving my only problem with them?


Because you live in a society and a society isn’t all about just your needs.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: