Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin
Why are the tech elites embracing a philosophy meant for slaves? (mattruby.substack.com)
4 points by azizsaya on Aug 24, 2021 | hide | past | favorite | 3 comments


Stoicism is not meant for slaves. One of the most prominent writers on Stoicism was literally the Emperor of Rome.

Another prominent writer inspired by the Stoics was Boethius, a prominent official who was executed for treason. He wrote The Consolation of Philosophy as a way to comfort himself while in prison. That is the target for much of Stoicism: the people with a lot to lose.

The name is derived from the Stoa, public places where people could gather to listen and discuss. That did make it more accessible than the academies, but still aimed at people with the time and liberty to be there -- not slaves.

The current fad for Stoicism is a pretty bastardized version of it. Which is well in keeping with long tradition, where every philosophy X gives rise to a neo-X a few centuries later, updated to the modern conditions, and then a neo-neo-X after that. Marcus Aurelius and Epictetus wouldn't recognize it.

The the author shouldn't get snooty about it if he doesn't know anything about it, either.


I think it has to do with people struggling to find meaning in the absence of inherited religion or any other guiding philosophy. The forces of capitalism and democracy have stripped away many communal traditions, but people still have a need for some kind of meaning, so it's not surprising they might turn to a philosophy that is highly individualistic and doesn't require an organized church.


Disclaimer: I know very little beyond what I've superficially experienced. Not being a spiritual person, I had a hard time thinking common Christian systems made much sense. It seemed too much concentration was given to the hierarchy or building. I then met the Quakers. What I experienced there was much different. I'm not familiar enough with their customs so I'd rather not give bad information. I will suggest visiting a Friends Meeting if you have the opportunity.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: