Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

We restrict a lot of freedoms for the under-18 crowd though.

Purely in terms of freedom -- without arguing for any other pros and cons -- is this worse than mandatory school attendance, or not being able to vote, or take medical decisions for themselves, or whatever else kids cannot do these days.



The big difference is that those decisions are pushed to the parents and not the state. Minors are not fully mentally equipped to make some of the decisions that adults have the right/ability to make.


Parents don't get to decide whether their kids get to vote (or whether they go to school, in most of the west, without having to at least fill out some complicated forms or having to go to court.)


There are economic reasons for this (most minors aren't mentally fully developed enough to make some life changing decisions such as in voting/medical decisions/etc.)


Do you have evidence that most adults are mentally developed enough for this?


Parents in many Western countries do not have the choice of what their child spends most of their day doing, as well as some medical procedures.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: