Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> I don't think a sitting US President is afforded the luxury of a personal life while in office

It's not his personal life I'm thinking about, it's his political life. He's the top elected official, and the top representative of a political party. His political speech shouldn't be played around with, even if we can somehow rationalize political censorship for everyone else.

I think that's different than an official White House account, though, because the actual government belongs to us. In his function as head administrator of the Executive Branch, he's an employee. In his function as the winner of a presidential election, however, he's the anointed representative for a majority of US voters (more or less, because of our antiquated system), and silencing him is antidemocratic.



> In his function as head administrator of the Executive Branch, he's an employee. In his function as the winner of a presidential election, however, he's the anointed representative for a majority of US voters (more or less, because of our antiquated system)

OK, but then how do you determine when he’s acting in which capacity?

> and silencing him is antidemocratic.

These context bubbles are supplemental and apparently provided by users. They’re not hiding anyone’s speech. It’s more like boosting the most succinct, relevant reply.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: