Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> It is tragic to me that a person can't see culture as anything but a marketable good.

with respect, thats not what I am saying, I'm saying it has a cost. If people do not have the means to spend that money on making culture, then it is not created.

Juvenal was a client of someone, and complained about it

Tallis, Allegri, Purcell, Bach, Mozart were all professional composers

The great seats of learning (Ashurbanipal's libary, Venice, Alexandria) are all paid for by a ruler wanting to show off how good they were

Wilde, byron were all rich people wafting around bored and making art on the way.

In the 60s-80s it was possible to live in NYC working at a bar or something, and still have time and money to create art. Where can you do that now?

Now you need to be rich, or have time, or get patrons. The internet is a great way to either lower the cost of entry (see music) or get support to create (see Patreon)

> This is just deeply wrong. Culture existed before money

Culture existed when we had time, food and resources to stop worrying about being cold wet and hungry.



Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: