Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

In Canada, I had the full pickle 4K account and my girls in another city used my account. When the new rules kicked in, I cut my plan and pay half now. And I'll cancel it this month. The service is just not worth it with all the crappy content.


This is the most mind-blowing aspect of this. Kids away at college use their parents' accounts for entertainment. Those kids graduate, then get their own accounts.

Netflix is shooting themselves in the foot. These kids will just adopt content from other providers.


Kids away at college will just get their own accounts now. Compared to the cost of college with room and board, a monthly Netflix subscription is nothing, especially with the cheap ad-supported tier. Kids away at college do things like eat at restaurants and buy clothes which require money too, and if that money's coming from parents then so will a separate Netflix account.

It's not like it's some great American tradition that kids at college use their parents' streaming account. Nor did kids ever start getting their own Netflix subscription after graduating. If they were using it during college, they would continue after college, because why wouldn't they?

In other words, being at college doesn't have much of anything to do with anything.


> Kids away at college will just get their own accounts now.

Or they won't and they'll just watch literally any other service which doesn't harass them about their precise location day to day, or worse they'll just go back to downloading all their shows like starving college kids used to until netflix showed up and was actually affordable and more convenient than piracy.


Or all services will do this, and students will just pay.

Sure, there will be college students who are more technical and comfortable paying for a VPN and who will invest in an external hard drive and will download torrents in advance of watching, as there always has been.

But that's way too complicated for most folks. And between the price of a monthly torrenting-friendly VPN and enough storage, the ad-supported tier of Netflix probably winds up being cheaper anyways.


I think you've forgotten what the community at college was like. If one person on your floor knew how to pirate, the entire floor knew how to pirate by the end of the first semester.

Streaming had begun to fill the niche of being convenient enough to not needing to bother, but broke college students are going to save money in all the places they can.


> If one person on your floor knew how to pirate, the entire floor knew how to pirate by the end of the first semester

This is not how it worked. Some percentage, say 20-30% knew how to pirate, and everyone else on the shared network profited because the 20-30% made public folders.


> In other words, being at college doesn't have much of anything to do with anything.

Being in college is associated with not having money for all luxuries and having to prioritize. Plenty of students will think about whether their Netflix account is worth it or perhaps they should invest some time into learning this "torrent" thing.


As both a recently cancelled subscriber and as parent with a child in college I can personally attest that my college student has simply moved on from Netflix


If there's one thing I know from experience, it's that college students definitely won't turn to explicit piracy. Never happens, don't worry about it.


> Those kids graduate, then get their own accounts.

Pretty sure those kids graduate and keep using their parents accounts (source: I graduated >10 years ago, still use my parents account). Unless they have kids of their own and need their own account.

But most gen Z and millennials are pretty broke (half living paycheck to paycheck: https://fortune.com/2023/05/19/quiet-quitting-side-hustle-se... -> https://archive.is/u415s ), so many wouldn't be able to pay for netflix on their own

Shared netflix has been a nice way for boomers and gen X to do something nice for their struggling kids. Really curious if Netflix will even make more money from this. Even if revenue doesn't change or decreases, they might also benefit by paying less in bandwidth per paying user.


With kids and parents, what may very well happen is that the parents start subsidizing kids' individual accounts while they're already in school. It's not like the few extra bucks a month is meaningful compared to the low 5 figure sum it takes to send a kid away to college.


They are helping kids study now. when my cousin asked for the password on her first day in college, i said no.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: