Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> So is this really newsworthy? The options available for purchase have changed.

Yes. They changed the game you paid for by removing content. What if your cable provider removed a bunch of channels you pay for, but haven’t watched yet, and turned them into PPV channels. Would you be upset? I would.



They're also constantly changing the game you paid for by adding massive amounts of content. When you get GTA Online, you know it's an evolving experience.

It's not a static game you pay once for and then expect to remain the same.

(And I haven't subscribed to cable TV in a long time, but when I did, the channel lineup was absolutely in flux, with channels getting added and removed as time went on.)


It'd be a ridiculous expectation for society to keep.

I've been paying for Netflix - this month they probably took off 20~30 movies due to licenses ending.

You're gonna say, hold on, I haven't had a chance to watch all those yet.

Or if I paid for the costco membership for a year and then they take some product off the shelf and I say - hold on I haven't had the opportunity to purchase that yet.

Nothing in our society works this way


Items from Costco don't work that way because there are a physical item. It has to be produced, can potentially spoil, and can take up a lot of space. Movies on Netflix get removed because of licenses, not because they can't be copied and stored trivially. If you can't see the difference between these then I think we'll have a hard time coming to an agreement here.

Also: it is entirely reasonable if I decided to cancel a Costco membership if they stopped carrying items I want. The same goes for Netflix, but they have less of an excuse from this perspective because as a consumer I don't care about licensing. At all.


yes, but we’re talking about video gamers who aren’t ruled by logic or reason. they’ll endlessly bitch about this and then rush to preorder the next thing.


What if your cable provider removed a bunch of channels you pay for, but haven’t watched yet, and turned them into PPV channels.

They have, at least for content if not entire channels (don't have MLB Package or NFL Sunday Ticket? Too bad...enjoy the blackout). So have the streaming services. I'm mildly upset by it, but they've made it clear my only alternative is 'FU...cancel if you don't like it'.

edit: spelling


> What if your cable provider removed a bunch of channels you pay for, but haven’t watched yet

Isn't this about people getting upset over Rockstar removing cars they didn't pay for though?


Just seems like forced outrage.

They’ve added tons and tons more content than they’ve removed. Net-net you have more content than you bought.

Like adding 10 channels and then taking away the hallmark channel.


They also changed the game people paid for by adding vehicles, but nobody is complaining about that here.


When I had cable they removed channels at the time. Usually because Viacom tried to strong arm them


Guess they should quit playing then.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: