Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Then why did you reply? I didn't ask you.


Everybody has a voice here, buddy. I'm exercising mine. You don't get to pick and choose who gets a say.


I'll be honest I misread your username before; I thought you were a random person responding to my question. That's why I responded like that.

Still seems weird to not share your opinion...


When did I get to be 'not a random person' around here? Heh, I know I have a high karma but my HN glory days are long behind me.

Anyway, since you asked:

> If you don't want people to theme your software (or rather, you don't want your software to be themed by distribution maintainers), why not write your own license forbidding just that? No one will want to touch it with a 10 foot pole, but hey, you won't have distribution maintainers theming your software.

This is just... Well let's just say it's you that doesn't understand free software. First off changing the license to deal with this is like solving a problem with your business by nuking your competitors from orbit. It's way way way too heavy-handed an approach.

Second, I dunno if you've ever actually worked in software before, but the people churning out the features, in this case the themes, more often than not don't really have a say in what they're building, even in the case of open source. Opening a public conversation like this is exactly how you solve this kind of problem. It's a democratic commons. Talk it out. There's no one person you can just email and say, hey, this is hurting us, knock it off.

You're basically just telling these people to shut up and take it. You don't care about their needs, or what they're going through every day. They make a website like this to stand up and be heard, and they hear your voice, hey, you over there, you're out of your lane, shut up and code.

It's... an immature response. The kind of immaturity that makes me believe that explaining why past the most basic observation would be an exercise in pissing upstream.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: