Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Interestingly, in the German-speaking scientific literature and science communicators, there is a movement to call it "conspiracy ideologies", "conspiracy myth" or "conspiracy narratives" (they have not found a consensus yet), because they're not theories according to Karl Popper and generally lack any properties that we would usually expect a scientific theory to have.

Personally, I disagree. No one feels flattered being called a "conspiracy theorist" and I don't really see the need to differentiate, especially if a general audience is being addressed.



Indeed, a theory must be testable. If it cannot be falsified then it doesn't count.

Not all such have to be "conspiracies", so the existence of gods or flying spaghetti monsters also don't count.

The perfect "conspiracy theory" is unfalsifiable. They survive by evolution, since lesser (falsifiable) conspiracies get debunked.


You could argue that conspiracy theories are falsifiable, and it's just that conspiracy theorists won't accept any proof. The flat earth theory for instance is easily debunkable: just take a flight from Auckland to Santiago de Chile.


You're absolutely right of course, about flat-earthers. Those sorts of people delight in dismissing incontrovertible physical evidence.

Compare that with "Who really shot JFK?". Let's say that tomorrow we read a deathbed confession by the highest ranking CIA or KGB officer, setting out exactly how it all went down. At least half the people would just not believe it. Especially in the age of "deep-fakes". The narrative would just "slip sideways" into "how the whole fake confession was engineered". It's like chasing that last pea around the plate with a fork. The sharper the instrument, the less use it is. With time it's essentially become an unknowable thing.

So that's what a I mean my "perfect conspiracy theory". JFK is a much more perfect "conspiracy" than flat-earth or faked moon landings which have elements of timeless physical evidence.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: