Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin
Light Waves Brought to a Stop in a Crystal Promises New Ways to Control Photons (sciencealert.com)
28 points by Brajeshwar on April 29, 2024 | hide | past | favorite | 8 comments


Perhaps it's impossible to explain this in an ELI5 manner (or even an ELI40+ manner), but as a layman I'm having a really hard time understanding what it means to "halt" a photon. For that matter, I'm having a hard time understanding how photons are slowed traversing through matter, but obviously I understand it's a common experience given that the speed of light in substances like glass or water is slower than a vacuum.

Just curious if anyone is able to recommend any sources that can help explain this to someone with a general knowledge of physics, but not a PhD in quantum mechanics.


When light passes through a medium like glass or water, it interacts with the atoms and molecules in that material. This interaction involves the absorption and re-emission of the photons by the atoms, a process that takes time and thus effectively slows down the speed of light as it travels through the medium.

The research describes "photonic Landau levels." This is similar to how electrons are confined to certain energy levels when subjected to magnetic fields, but applied to photons. By confining photons to these levels, the crystal can effectively "trap" light in place. The light is still present and retains its energy, but it doesn't move forward; it's localized within a very small area of the crystal. The photons are not moving from one place to another as they normally would—they are caught in a sort of "light trap" created by the specific structural properties of the photonic crystal.


Does the trapped light take up space, or can we use this to accumulate large amounts of energy like some kind of crystal-based battery?


This is going beyond my expertise, but I'll give an attempt at an answer. Take this with a massive grain of salt. It's almost certainly some level of wrong:

The trapped light does not take up physical space in the same way that matter does and can lead to an increase in the local energy density within the photonic crystal. However, it is not clear how this energy could be efficiently extracted and used for practical applications. Also, the confined light is subject to energy loss through various mechanisms, such as absorption by the material or scattering and these losses would limit the amount of energy that can be effectively stored in the system over time.


They're mass-less, and are usually thought of as a zero-dimensional object, having no volume and taking up no space.

You can theoretically have an unlimited number of them in a space due to this, but due to other properties of bosons (like photons), there are other limits. In particular, if you accumulate enough of them they spontaneously spawn new particles!

They aren't really physical particles in the classical sense, they cross quantum fields, and to the extent that those occupy space, the photon isn't in any one position, but merely crossing it or spread out across it.


Is an individual photon sitting in place, or is it being absorbed and re-emited in sequence within a localised structure?


Well, given that I just read this story a couple days ago, I cannot miss the connection:

https://www.physics.utoronto.ca/~jharlow/slowglass.htm

It's about a 5-minute sci-fi read, incredibly on-topic, written in the 60s.


Thankyou, great story :)




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: