Particle physicist here. I've worked on direct detection DM experiments in the past, and personally know some folks who work on the LZ experiment. That direct detection experiments, such as LZ, have not detected a signal does not contradict any predictions.

Indeed, relevant to what an experiment like LZ might see, there really isn't much in the way of "predictions" which can be "contradicted." What we have at this point are mechanisms to calculate the interaction rate _given at least one free parameter_. If we were to detect a non-zero rate, then we would "know" the free parameter of a single-parameter theory underlying that calculation. If we were to continue to detect a non-zero rate, then we would try to do so using different materials, and look at the time dependence of the rate (or, really, the dependence of the rate on the Earth's direction of travel in our local galaxy). That would help us choose between different theories, pin down the free parameters, and confirm that what we're seeing is consistent with "heavy stuff just sitting out in the universe."

But, from a particle physics perspective, right now there are no predictions to contradict - just an opportunity to detect something.