Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

The first sentence says they’re not going to win a beauty contest but I think they’re kinda cute! Presumably the low hood helps a lot with visibility.


Personally, I think it looks really bad. Especially after seeing a different angle on the Wikipedia page[0].

0: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oshkosh_NGDV


That picture makes it look even cuter to me, like it’s a Pixar character.

It won’t win any beauty contests but I like that they put function over form here.

Edit: corrected my phrasing about function over form. Thanks!


> put form over function here

Surely you meant "function over form" here? I'll assume you did, and yes I can agree that delivering mail doesn't require anything pretty. Apparently the cartoonish height came from USPS requiring that anyone as short as 5'2" can see over the hood and someone as tall as 6'8" can stand in the vehicle. Still doesn't look that great or practical (for narrow or rural routes) to me, but I guess we'll see.


> anyone as short as 5'2" can see over the hood

Sure beats those huge trucks that are slaughtering Americans in the thousands.

https://www.economist.com/weeklyedition/2024-09-07


It would probably be worth adjusting our esthetic preferences if it means safer roads for everyone.


I definitely see that! Lightning McQueen vibes.


I'll bet it looks fantastic from the inside with those huge windows and tiny hoods.


Those huge windows and tiny hoods also probably make them significantly safer for little kids and pets.

USPS trucks are regularly driving through highly residential areas including fairly quiet ones where little kids may possibly be running around close to the street or even on them.


So this is basically just what cars should look like.


Why is it so extremely loud inside, though?


It looks distinctive, in 15 years it will be how everyone imagines mail trucks are supposed to look. That is a universe I like, I think.


Really the only flaw is trying to mirror a conventional car headlight design; if they went with something a bit quirky like an LED grid covering the entire front or something it would become something totally unique.


Huh, I think that design would fit right in in Japan, but it's pretty odd by American standards.

I wouldn't say it's bad, but it's definitely a bizarre choice for a US government design.


It looks... bizarre, like someone gave a box truck the lowrider treatment. And is that a hint of Chevy I see at the top of the grill, although it's based on a Ford?


Ha! That is very strange. If you colored that area in, it would totally look like the Chevy bowtie logo.


It is the OshKosh logo…


i also think they're ugly, but they're ugly in a disarming, endearing sort of way. and maybe it's just becuase i know it's a mail truck which is a useful thing, but i think the ugliness makes me like it.


Michael Jackson "bad" or... These seem people friendly like government is supposed to be.


I agree it looks ridiculous. It is sad that such bad design will continue uglification of our streets.


Not sure that "vehicle that doesn't kill children or injure its employees" qualifies as "bad design" because ArtemZ thinks it looks ridiculous


To me, they look like they are from the movie "Up".


Yeah, these are awesome. It’s SUVs that are ugly.


…and dangerous!




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: