Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> Lead isotope analysis of the bronze alloy provided indisputable evidence of the Chinese origin of the materials used in the statue.

Is there some more detailed source explaining how this conclusion was reached? What's distinct about Chinese lead / how this kind of evaluations are done?



The original article translated from Italian puts it this way:

>the results indicate that the colossal statue is most likely an elaborate reassembly of what was initially a zhènmùshòu (镇墓兽 "keeper of tombs") fused in the Tang period (609-907 AD) with copper from the mines of the lower basin of the Yang-tze River, the Blue River in southern China. This is confirmed by accurate analyses of lead isotopes, which leave in the bronze unmistakable traces of the original mines from which the copper was extracted.

The implication is that the mines themselves have different isotope signatures that have been established in previous archaeological studies.


I'm surprised they're using isotopes and not impurities for such a task.


I believe these are impurities. This is talking about copper mines, producing the copper for the bronze casting.

So they are looking for the signature lead impurities in that copper. They use isotope analysis to find the lead impurities in the copper.


Isotope ratios are very easy and reliable signals compared to impurities. Impurities can be all over the place depending on where the materials were mined. Impurities could have also been added inadvertently during the casting as well.


Perhaps based on time-mapping known regional mining activity



I think they're looking for a study that was done on this particular item, not just info about isotopes in general

There's some more info on the lion's measurements here, but I haven't been able to find the study that was presented in September

https://journals.iucr.org/j/issues/2024/03/00/in5093/in5093....


Those links do not answer the question, separately or combined.


This one is specific to Chinese lead isotopes. Many Chinese bronzes have elevated levels of radiogenic lead. https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-018-30275-2


High lead content? Made in China? What a surprise. /s


They absolutely do answer the question.


I should not have posted a comment that simply contradicted you. My bad.

The first mentions lead once. The second does not mention any region of present-day China, as far as I can tell. I can't see the information there.


Different sources have different isotope proportions and amounts, permitting fingerprinting of region and sometimes specific mines.

The first link explains how we use isotopes in this fashion. The second explains that lead has some useful ones.


I have re-read the question, and this does answer the very last words of it.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: