Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

The "fit" itself is the goal. It is not like water flowing in a direction guided by the terrain. Trees produce thorns to keep away animals. You could say that thorns worked best among multiple options that were tried. But the question is, why is the tree trying out with option at all. Why should it protect itself from animals? Why should it grow and reproduce? A rock boulder, lying next to the tree, doesn't seem to have these goals or intentions.

The water flow has the motivation driven by gravitational force. What is driving the motivation behind the growth the reproduction of an organism? In fact, life, growth and build go against the principle of least action that governs the physical universe.

And I'm not sure why someone has evolved the intention of downvoting me.



The "motivation" behind growth and reproduction is that lifeforms that reproduce more will dominate, while lifeforms that do not die out. This is called natural selection.

Mutations in DNA can have a positive or negative impact on the ability to reproduce. Because of natural selection, positive mutations tend to be preserved while negative mutations tend to disappear. There is no intent behind this process; it is simply a consequence of how life works.

While we can't yet say for certain how life got started, it is likely that the first "life" was made up of self-replicating RNA. Because this RNA self-replicated and produced imperfect copies, it was already undergoing evolution at that point, where the RNA strands which were better at copying themselves (due to mutations) were more plentiful.


> It is not like water flowing in a direction guided by the terrain.

I understand it doesn’t seem intuitive at first, but evolution is actually quite similar to that.

> Trees produce thorns to keep away animals.

It's not that trees consciously produce thorns to keep animals away. Rather, trees with thorns (due to random mutations) are more likely to survive because they are less likely to be disturbed by animals. Over time, those trees are more likely to reproduce and pass on those traits.

Just like water flows down the path of least resistance, evolution naturally selects for traits that improve survival. The "selecting" we are referring to is used in the same sense that water "selects" which route it takes. It doesn't actually select anything, it's just following the laws of physics.


You are still anthropomorphizing. The tree doesn’t want anything. It is a structure of chemical reactions. Sometimes there are mutations that lead to new features. Sometimes these features confer success in the environment at the time. Sometimes that success leads to this new mutant taking over relative to the others. Fast forward billions of years and we go from a sludge of singe celled microbial life to every tree you can see.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: