Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I know a lot of people who love to quote Smedley and Eisenhower's farewell address, and to a person they support military intervention in Ukraine. Also, people who unironically were saying "The USA shouldn't be the world police!" 10 years ago.


It's almost like supporting an ally whose sovereign territory is being violated is some kind of different situation than the US unilaterally performing military actions in a variety of locations. Amazing!


Wasn't every gun and rocket given to Ukraine a theft from the hungry and the cold?


Probably not, since most of what we sent over was existing stock. The money had already been turned into weapons of war years ago. You can't really turn a gun or rocket into a loaf of bread.


And all of the money that was used to produce new arms?


I'm not attempting to justify all military spending by the US, and have no desire to do so. I am not one to quote Smedley.

I am saying that support for Ukraine is pretty different from the kinds of behaviors that make people say "the USA shouldn't be the world police!"


> I am not one to quote Smedley.

Then why are you arguing with me? I was pointing out the contradiction of people who do that. I feel like you think I'm saying the US shouldn't support Ukraine. I'm all on board with the US supporting Ukraine. I'm saying the US needs a powerful military if you want it to support Ukraine, which is at odds with people who are fully behind the quotes that come from Butler and Eisenhower's farewell address.

> I am saying that support for Ukraine is pretty different from the kinds of behaviors that make people say "the USA shouldn't be the world police!"

And yet, to even consider helping Ukraine in any meaningful way, the US needs an extremely strong, modern military.


I don't like it when unlike things are treated as being the same, hence my reply.


They aren't unlike things being treated the same. They are two separate and conflicting opinions which are concurrently expressed by some people.


"Some military action can be justified" and "much military action that has been done was not well justified" are not conflicting opinions.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: