Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

The perception that I have of AI is two goals:

1) A keyword to game out investment capital from investors

2) A crutch for developers who should probably the be replaced by AI

I do believe there is some utility and value behind AI, but its still so primitive that its a smarter auto-complete.



> but its still so primitive that its a smarter auto-complete

Is it 10x smarter than auto-complete on your iPhone or 10000x smarter?


It's not comparable it's to your iPhone auto-complete, because it's code completion.

It's a mixed bag, because it often provides plausible but incorrect completions.


OK, how mixed is that mixed bag?

Is it totally useless or is it the greatest thing ever? If neither, where in the middle do you put it?

How often does it provide plausible but incorrect completions? Is it every few minutes or is it a couple times a day?

This is my biggest issue with the AI complainers on here. It's always the broadest and most vague complaints. I'd rather somebody just say, "You know what I just don't like AI" rather than try to convince me it's bad through vagueness.


> Is it totally useless or is it the greatest thing ever? If neither, where in the middle do you put it?

For code completion, I think it's close to useless in my experience, traditional code completion feels much more useful.

> How often does it provide plausible but incorrect completions? Is it every few minutes or is it a couple times a day?

It varies with the workload but closer to every few minutes than a couple times a day. For example while writing rust the majority (like 95%) of the code completion suggestions are incorrect. When writing a python website it gets better but you still get bad suggestions that look good, several times a day.

The killer feature is generating code, not as completion but after an explicit prompt. Most models are okayish on that task. But still you have to pay attention.

That's all in my experience across like a year, your mileage may vary.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: