Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Be careful when reading such blogs:

> Note that the dosage in the mouse experiments is quite high — 0.1% of the body weight every day, meaning about 2 ounces a day for me (70 kg).

Mouse and human metabolism are very different. A better starting estimate would be 5g/day, not 57g/day. I hope people dont accidentally overdose themselves because of lack of a pharmacology background.



Scaling mouse doses to human by body weight is a common rookie mistake.

A better estimate for dose scaling uses body surface area. Even with that, inter-species differences don’t allow prevent extrapolation.

Scaling by body weight leads to the common mistake of dismissing mouse studies because the casual observer does the match (by weight) and thinks the dose used was excessive.

It’s such a basic topic in medicine and scientific research that I don’t trust anyone who scales by body weight.


lol, that one was really a howler.

You're spot on. But for the rest of the forum:

The most commonly accepted mouse-to-human conversion is: (D)*(3/37) = H

Where D = the mouse dose in mg/kg. H = human dose in mg/kg.

So if a 25g mouse eats 0.1% of its bodyweight in taurine, that comes out to 1000mg/kg. It translates to 81mg/kg for a human. If you weigh 100kg, an equivalent daily dose for you is 8.1 grams/day.

The rat equation is similar, but 6/37 rather than 3/37.


In plain English: scale by body weight then divide by 12.


Lack of pharmacology background doesn't seem like the biggest issue when extrapolating from mouse to human.


> Be careful when reading such blogs

I followed a link to another blog post of theirs in which they go on a rant claiming there was a conspiracy to suppress chloroquine and ivermectin as COVID treatments. I dont think anyone should be taking health advice from this person


Amusingly, this was a very common if not the most common stance on this very website some time ago. Surely, don't look for assistance on the internet regarding memory issues.


I just learned this the other day, but its called allometric scaling. Definitely far off linear.




Consider applying for YC's Winter 2027 batch! Applications are open till November 2.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: