Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I thought Mozilla Persona aka BrowserID handled this email validation well with a fallback provider that used the same flow (and also implemented the OIDC work for obvious existing social providers like Gmail/Google Accounts). Though obviously not well enough because that fallback provider was seen as a large expense and shutdown without a replacement killing the Mozilla Persona effort.

But that does relate to I keep wanting an email claim for Passkeys. A user's browser/OS could verify an email address once and then associate it with a Passkey. Passkeys might be a good place for that (as Persona/BrowserID suggested). Obviously some browsers could lie about verifying the email address in the claim and there might still need to be more steps to it, but if you are already taking Passkeys it doesn't necessarily add an entirely different flow to accept a verified email claim from a Passkey (and/or decide you don't trust that Passkey's claim and trigger your regular verification code flow).



Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: