But I presume you light up Christmas lights in December, drive to the theater to watch a movie or fire up a campfire on holiday.
That too is "wasteful". It's not needed, other, or far more efficient ways exist to achieve the same. And in absolute numbers, far more energy intensive than running an LLM to create 9 clocks every minute. We do things to learn, have fun, be weird, make art, or just spend time.
Now, if Rolex starts building watches by running an LLM to drive its production machines or if we replace millions of wall clocks with ones that "Run an LLM every second", then sure, the waste is an actual problem.
Point I'm trying to make is that it's OK to consider or debate the energy use of LLMs compared to alternatives. But that bringing up that debate in a context where someone is creative, or having a fun time, its not, IMO. Because a lot of "fun" activities use a lot of energy, and that too isn't automatically "wasteful".
But I presume you light up Christmas lights in December, drive to the theater to watch a movie or fire up a campfire on holiday. That too is "wasteful". It's not needed, other, or far more efficient ways exist to achieve the same. And in absolute numbers, far more energy intensive than running an LLM to create 9 clocks every minute. We do things to learn, have fun, be weird, make art, or just spend time.
Now, if Rolex starts building watches by running an LLM to drive its production machines or if we replace millions of wall clocks with ones that "Run an LLM every second", then sure, the waste is an actual problem.
Point I'm trying to make is that it's OK to consider or debate the energy use of LLMs compared to alternatives. But that bringing up that debate in a context where someone is creative, or having a fun time, its not, IMO. Because a lot of "fun" activities use a lot of energy, and that too isn't automatically "wasteful".