Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

As a side note, I dislike the term "government money," since it makes it easy to forget the the money ultimately comes not from the government but from the people. "Taxpayer money", on the other hand, has a pejorative connotation, since it is often used derisively. Maybe "public money"?


There's no such thing as "public" money; it always comes from private pockets and ends up in (different) private pockets.

I can't see what's pejorative about taxpayer money. That's whom it comes from.


Just saw this comment.

>There's no such thing as "public" money; it always comes from private pockets and ends up in (different) private pockets.

That is just a play on words. Of course individuals are "private"; it's in their capacity as taxpayers (rather than volitional payers) that they collectively constitute the public. "Public" and "private" are terms from economics with established meanings.

>I can't see what's pejorative about taxpayer money. That's whom it comes from.

I don't want to get into a big discussion on this, but this is a good example of the distinction between connotation and denotation (http://classweb.gmu.edu/bhawk/101/semiotics/decon.html).


And what's the connotation with "taxpayer money"?


Except for that the money doesn't come from the people, since it is fiat money as opposed to money being collected via taxes.


Except for that the money doesn't come from the people, since it is fiat money

Don't you mean "seigniorage" money? http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Seigniorage

as opposed to money being collected via taxes.

Isn't seigniorage a type of tax? http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Seigniorage

seigniorage is also referred to as an inflation tax [...] the "inflation tax" is paid by those who hold the existing currency, which results from their holdings of currency becoming devalued through inflation because of the introduction of additional money supply.


"Isn't seigniorage a type of tax?"

Yes, but it's not a tax on the people, it's a tax on dollar holders.


That's a fair point to make in relation to a loan that must be repaid. But actual government debt has to be backed by a claim to someone's labour and that someone is the tax payer. If there is no such backing all that fiat money will quickly lose its value.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: