Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Why do I sense a schadenfreude here? It's like people are rooting for their failure.
 help



> Why do I sense a schadenfreude here? It's like people are rooting for their failure.

You sound surprised. Why?

After all, they have been selling their product on the basis of driving the value of human labour as close to zero as possible (your labour included). Why wouldn't people want such an endeavour to fail?


> driving the value of human labour as close to zero as possible

Tech and automation exists to drive the marginal cost of labor toward zero. It's just happening faster now.

> (your labour included)

Right, it's disrupting you now instead of just dumb people.


This is false. Other forms of tech were not designed to replace humans with some kind of successor species, as they're trying to do here.

Other tech was developed as a productivity boost, and for jobs it may have displaced, it ultimately created more.


I expect people here to root for the future. In the future AI overtaking humans is inevitable.

The ordeal feels like 2yo who hasn't learned yet that the pee will come no matter if he wishes to play or not.


> I expect people here to root for the future. In the future AI overtaking humans is inevitable.

I can't really make sense of this sentiment, because I don't really understand what it is you mean by "overtake".

Do you expect AI to replace human's who think for a living?


There is no inevitable. It's all political and ideological choices.

The future is what we make of it.


> It's all political and ideological choices.

And we already know what choices will be made.


This is not a passive process. The choices are all of ours. We are not spectators in history, we're its actors.

No. It is no more your choice than tomorrow's weather. Sure you could in theory directly or indirectly persuade someone with direct access to aircraft-based cloud seeding. But in practice your personal effect is going to be negligible.

My point is - humanity as a species has already effectively made its choice.


They're trying to enclose all of human knowledge so they can sell it back to us, all while displacing human labor and centralizing control of the economy.

They're telling us human endeavors are no longer needed if they succeeded, they also warn us that they might accidentally cause the end of the world in the process.

Why shouldn't we root for their failure?


Among other reasons, because it's been evident that the numbers won't add up from the beginning. It's always delicious when reality catches on a major scam.

They've been rooting for ours, it's only fair.

Some of us truly are.

I'm sorry... should I not be happy when someone that says it is terrible that I own my own RAM has a terrible day???



Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: