Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

This is the same as asking Apple to ignore Chinese market, when China has more active iPhone user than the whole US population.

I am not entirely sure I buy the Spy thesis. And Alice's husband knew this all along. Which makes the whole thing more doggy.

And Jensen's view isn't wrong. There is no way you could contain China via import restrictions. Not when they are the second-largest economy and still rapidly advancing. There are better ways to handle this, one huge ban isn't one.

But I wholeheartedly disagree with ousting Jensen. And given the timing of all these releases, I wouldn't be surprised someone inside the government wants to bring him down.

 help



  But I wholeheartedly disagree with ousting Jensen. And given the timing of all these releases, I wouldn't be surprised someone inside the government wants to bring him down.
I think there are a lot of people who want to bring him down. His competition - AMD, Broadcom, Google. OpenAI and Anthropic also have advocated for banning chip exports to China because of Chinese lab LLM competition. Then there are both Republican and Democrats who likely support the views of OpenAI/Anthropic.

Finally, because he's of Han Chinese origin, I bet they thought they could get the media to coordinate a narrative around him that will force him out. Of course, he sort of made it easy to pin something on him.

There are a lot of Game of Thrones going on in AI. Everyone is jockeying. Everyone has different incentives. Super high stakes game.


The thing is that at this point, even if this was all a plot to take him down, it worked! Can't go back to the information not being public.

He's operating in a highly charged political environment in which his credibility is a key asset. He can't effectively advocate for NVIDIA's interests if his credibility is damaged.

And this goes directly to his credibility on the most politically charged issue of all: The geopolitical rivalry between the US and China, and NVIDIA's role in it.

I agree it's a tragedy for NVIDIA, he seems to have been exceptional as a CEO, it's just too late now.


It definitely worked. It shows just how powerful the media is at creating narratives.

This one looks highly coordinated with multiple mainstream media outlets piling in.


To be fair this is the kind of thing the media and the public love to follow. Public powerful figure, sex, spying, political and business schemes, and additionally most retail investors being exposed to NVDA, it has everything. Doesn't mean it wasn't coordinated at first to get it in the spotlight, but there is no need for that now I think.

Yeah, this is pretty much peak eyeball soap opera drama kind of "tea", as they say. It has my parents talking about it, and they couldn't be less in tune wih tech and AI and GPUs. And apparently US intelligence was aware of this for over a year; they were simply told to not dig deeper.

Hanlon's razor seems to apply here, so I don't really think it's a psyop. Simply information many (top secret) parties were aware of for a while that other people who are incentivized to tell everyone eventually caught up on.


Hanlon's razor: please don't attribute malice to us poor billionaires and the intelligence community (or hold us accountable), we're just so gosh-darn incompetent.

I'm tired of hearing hanlon's razor tossed around. How about the inverse: I attribute malice if doing so makes the system better and explains your behavior. Even if you are just a fool, your actions impact others and have the same consequences of malice. I hold you to account like a criminal if you act like one.


If it's all an act, then American leadership these last 10 years has done an amazing acting job of pretending to be stupid.

Yes, there is malice in the actions. No, I don't think there was some grand conspiracy to reveal it now. That's the Hanlon's razor.

>I hold you to account like a criminal if you act like one.

I agree. Stupidity is the reasoning for the actions being revealed, not an excuse for the actions. Even if he was "one of the good ones" I still want billionaires held accountable for crimes they do.

I just realize these dsys that these aren't some grandmasters being beaten in some political game of wit. Just people who live a fundamentally different lifestyle who never "got in trouble" because they believe money will bail them out everytime.


I guess corporate is different, but Italy's PM was directly implicated with running by proxy a prostitution ring involving minors, abusing his power to cover up, sabotage investigations, buying and corrupting testimonies, changing laws to introduce technicalities to warrant a closure of the case by rendering evidence not admissible, etc.

Yet he went on to get back on Government, and his Party, and parliament seats, were even inherited by his children.

There's probably more to it.


To clarify: the PM being referred to is the now-dead Silvio Berlusconi: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Silvio_Berlusconi

Really unbelievable stuff.


> It shows just how powerful the media is at creating narratives

As far as I can tell, most of the reports were just recounting factual information. The narrative was already there. The media didn't create it.


We can't be so gullible that we think this wasn't deliberate right?

This X post makes a lot of sense: https://x.com/antfeedapp/status/2120454507448651933


> We can't be so gullible that we think this wasn't deliberate right?

What do you mean by "this"? One thing I agree with is that we knew about this story for months. I've read about Jensen's affair with Alice Huang and her ties to the Chinese government at least five months ago.

The thing that triggered the current reporting was the new sourcing about U.S. intelligence findings that came out in late October. So mainstream news started reporting on it once they had sources they found trustworthy.

The confusing thing, though, is not that the story suddenly became big, but why it didn't become big much earlier.


> U.S. intelligence

Did they ever find the uranium in Iraq? Good luck with those guys.


Are you saying Jensen didn't have the affair he admitted to having?

Of course it’s deliberate. The timing is especially interesting and noted in your link.

Whenever I see these kinds of stories I think of this, written a century ago:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crystallizing_Public_Opinion


Further, some of this has been out in the open and questioned for a year or two and the media said little if anything.

What narrative did the media create?

- He is married and had multiple affairs

- He slept with a subordinate

- He slept with a business partner

- He was compromised by a Chinese spy

These are all just facts - the narrative writes itself.


The question is why does the board care?

They could have easily just waited a month or two and let this all just go away.


The board doesn't care. They probably knew about all of this and employees knew about the affair with his direct report as well for years.

It's the outside pressure.


So the interesting question is who and how are they applying that pressure.

Does it just come down to virtue signaling pressure? The board preferring to protect it's own image vs what's best for the company?


The outside pressure is probably the investigations, including the securities lawsuit, that have already started. The coordinated media campaign (and, in addition, likely some phone calls about what else is coming down the pipe) is the way to tell the board "hey by the way, this guy is going down", we don't know exactly where "down" is yet, but I doubt this whole thing just blows over with an apology email about an affair. That isn't really what it's about, and now it isn't even just about a Chinese honeypot (I think the second affair is much worse morally speaking).

I'm also personally nowhere near as sympathetic to Jensen just due to the fact that I think he was a good CEO for a long time as some here are. I don't think he should remain on, regardless of the damage to NVIDIA. I have lost respect for him over this because it shows me he is morally weak and easily tempted. Two attributes I revile in a leader. His good performance up until now was nice, but I think upholding moral standards is to me more important than upholding my 401k.

I think you can't fully seperate your personal life from your private life as a CEO of a major publicly traded company. Attempting to do so is a mistake. Your morality is something that will be questioned and held to much higher standards because of the responsibility and wealth you've been given. Yes, being wealthy makes it easier to be a hedonist perhaps, but the public is not more trusting of hedonists simply because they are wealthy and so "of course they started doing hedonist things". If anything, that's a good reason to fire wealthy CEOs as liabilities of the moral sort when it becomes clear they can't not use their power for hedonism, especially in the apparently quite public way that Jensen was doing it here.

I recognize, that in the US, we largely view corporations and CEOs as amoral entities, but I think that's not universal and not something that was a good idea in the first place. There has to be some good end to what you are doing as a company for me to think you should have a right to exist. I'm not a pure 100% turbo max capitalist in disposition. Similarly with CEOs, he may have had the end of making his investors and himself a lot of money, but the means by which he took to achieve that end are now under question and will be investigated, and likey turn up more stuff, hence the preempting in the media and probably tipping off the board that more is going to come of it.

So, I'm in favor of his ouster. Especially because of the second affair, which is even more concerning than the Chinese honeypot one from my personal moral perspective on elite sexuality and my opinion that cheaters suck and they suck even more if it was a boss doing it with a subordinate and a very powerful boss at that. There are ways to frame that where it isn't even consentual and I don't think it's been established yet that it was even consentual, and indeed it would be hard to establish such a thing, which is why it is such a big HR NO NO thing. The power imbalance makes even a consentual relationship look like it could've been something worse when refusing could get you in trouble with your boss. So, I think, if Jensen is basically unable to put 2 and 2 together and keep it in his pants enough to avoid the potential of rape allegations had this gone even more sideways, he is not responsible enough in his own personal moral life to be leading a company.

So, I wish Jensen the best, and I am thankful for his many years of good leadership. But he needs to get some control over his personal proclivities before returning to being a CEO of a major publicly traded company. Some time off, some confession time, some trying to get a handle on whatever other addictions have cropped up due to the money, would be a good thing for him, and I am wishing him well, but do not think it is in his best interests to continue on as CEO and end up looking like a total villain.


Again, repeating my comment from the Jensen thread a few days ago: this is like directly from the David Fincher movie "Gone Girl".

I recommend watching it if the power of media interests you.


The moment where Rosamund Pike looks at the camera in that way (being vague, but I think people who've watched it will remember) is just incredible.

https://www.wsj.com/politics/national-security/huangs-cozine...

> WSJ reports that details of the affair were known to top officials, including SoS Rubio and CIA Ratcliffe, “going back to last year,” and were brought to President Trump; the administration took no action to blacklist Megaspeed.

Does this this sound like people who want to bring him down or people who wanted to protect him?


Also likely all gamers and home GPU users in general.

He's a strong advocate for gaming. That's why he started Nvidia in the first place.

I think whoever is next will not always have the affinity for gaming. Any finance person who looks at the unit economics of gaming would conclude that they should allocate next to no chip supply to gaming GPUs.

An RTX 5090 is the same die size as a server GPU.


as nvidia goes into making purely big-business hardware, some other player will arrive to provide the chips to the masses. then, the researchers will use this mass-market hardware for research, supplanting nvidia itself.

nvidia got their strong position in AI now by providing CUDA to researchers who couldn't afford their own supercomputing cluster. and now the entirety of machine learning revolves around CUDA.

once you fixate on the business and lock out the masses, you instantly elect to become a fossil like IBM.


Not instantly. It'll take a very long time to fall. As IBM stubbornly fails to completely do.

> Any finance person who looks at the unit economics of gaming would conclude that they should allocate next to no chip supply to gaming GPUs.

And that is the NVIDIA's secret sauce. Historically there were bunch of parallel processors comparable to NVIDIA GPU, none of them survived without presence in gaming and entertainment.

Did you know that NEC had a line of 2-slot GPUs with 48GB of HBM VRAM with 1TB/s bandwidth since 2017, that had gone absolutely nowhere? Probably not, because it was never sold as gamer toys. It was for lucrative serious customers only, and nobody bought it.

Only Huang played the game in the way it's meant to be played. Apparently nobody else can.


They stopped manufacturing the 5090 even under Jensens control. And no the 5090 die is only 750mm squared big, a B200s die is 1628mm squared. That is more than twice the size of a 5090.

A B200 is two dies glued together. A single Blackwell GPU die is the same size as an RTX 5090 basically.

An RTX 5090 is a reticle sized chip.


the 6000 pro definitely counts as a server GPU. coreweave seems to think so, anyway

Wasn’t the CEO of AMD his cousin? I guess it would match the GoT comparison…

Oh look! We have a list of suspects :-)

That’s what I think it’s going on… the “allegations” are ridiculous at best. He is the most “normal” of the bunch by a long short.


He’s is the CEO of NVIDIA since 33 years, he cofounded the company. This allegations are really minuscule.


He seems to have broken the law. That should have consequences. That he cofounded the company should not matter. Neither should it matter that many rich people get away with breaking the law in other cases.

It’s not about that, it’s about the cloud compute loophole of export restricted chips. NVIDIA sold billions worth of chips to Megaspeed, a Chinese company spin out in Singapore founded right after the export ban. Neocloud Megaspeed rented most of their compute to Chinese companies like Alibaba circumventing the sanctions. The investigations didn’t find any wrongdoing per se even if it’s very obvious that the whole Megaspeed operation is Chinese state orchestration. Labelling Alice as a spy put an immediate hold to all of this.

What law did he break?

IF Alice was a spy, and IF he was blackmailed into selling gpus to an ally of the CCP, thus breaking sanctions, he did break law. But both of those are a stretch atp

Foreign laymen here: if these are true, would they be considered treasonous?

Not in the US. The US has a very specific definition of treason in its constitution, and this case would not fit it.

"Treason against the United States, shall consist only in levying war against them, or in adhering to their enemies, giving them aid and comfort. No person shall be convicted of treason unless on the testimony of two witnesses to the same overt act, or on confession in open court."


Trump knew about the spy. For a Year. So any selling of GPU's might have had some under the table agreement. The US allowed it. Maybe this is why China helped with the oil crisis.

He coordinated with an agent of a foreign state to bypass sanctions.

Like, internal Nvidia KYC policy changed per Huang to facilitate GPU sales to Megaspeed.

Whether or not he realized it, cared, or was aware and doing it on purpose, he was acting as an enormously powerful lobbyist and influencer on the US as an agent of China.


The mass population hate AI and billionaires and are perfectly happy with seeing an AI billionaire FAFO.

> There is no way you could contain China via import restrictions.

You can get like 200% margin on selling GPUs to PRC smugglers in Taiwan. It's a very busy industry with lots of players so the margin gets spread around. Recently a big ring of them was busted and sent to prison here so most people try to have as many middlemen between them and the guy that puts it on the boat as possible, because apparently the prison sentence is quite long.

I had someone offer me 10x whatever I bought for (not even MSRP just whatever I paid) for "as many GPUs as I could get my hands on." I asked hundreds? Yeah. Thousands? "Can you get us thousands???" It's fuckin nutty.


Exactly, it is the same thing in Hong Kong, Japan or South Korea or any other nation in the region. Just like how they used to smuggle iPhone into China. It is a hidden distribution network that has long established.

> And Jensen's view isn't wrong. There is no way you could contain China via import restrictions.

This isn’t about right or wrong. If he knowingly broke the law he should be punished.


As I understand it, he didn't though. The law had a loophole you could navigate a supertanker through, and there is no duty to adhere to the spirit of a poorly written law.

It's not the same. Nvidia is way more buyers in the US than they have product to sell. Apple doesn't have a problem keeping supply to meet their demand, and so they need to find additional markets.

It's existential for Nvidia. Jensen understood that the longer he can freely sell to China, the less opportunity/incentive there is for Chinese companies to produce their own silicon and compete head-to-head with Nvidia.

This is exactly how it played out, too, which is why Huawei chips have started taking inference workloads in China and we're now starting to see them in training too.


This was going to happen anyways no matter what the US or NVIDIA did. China has done or is doing the same thing in every industry.

If you're z.ai in 2025 with $10 million to spend on GPUs, what's better:

1) buying B100s by the palette with 15 years of stable work on CUDA, or 2) some rinky-dink Huawei chip that's 3x slower, no software framework and crashes 50% of the time?

It's a no-brainer. If there were no export controls, Nvidia would be taking all that oxygen out of the room. Chinese chip efforts would be put back by at least 5 years, and probably more like 10.

Sure, they might get there eventually but Nvidia would still have that lead when they do.


> If you're z.ai in 2025 with $10 million to spend on GPUs, what's better:

> 1) buying B100s by the palette with 15 years of stable work on CUDA, or 2) some rinky-dink Huawei chip that's 3x slower, no software framework and crashes 50% of the time?

Whichever one the CCP representative on your board tells you to do. You don't get a choice on things like this.

There's no way having the option of buying chips from Nvidia would have hurt China. You can't bait them into acting against their own interests by giving them stuff. If the harm to the domestic chip industry would really outweigh the benefits, the CCP would issue the order and no-one would buy the Nvidia chips and that would be that.


> Whichever one the CCP representative on your board tells you to do. You don't get a choice on things like this.

Clearly untrue, because many companies are using the gimped H20s and the full H200s (both legally imported or smuggled) despite official government policy being silicon-self-sufficiency. It's a bit more complex than "CCP issues order and everyone immediately falls into line".

> There's no way having the option of buying chips from Nvidia would have hurt China.

I'm not saying it "hurt China", I'm saying there's a fine line to tread between supporting Chinese AI models now, at the expense of the Chinese silicon industry in 20 years' time. The US export ban forced the issue and took the alternative off the table.


"You can't bait them into acting against their own interests by giving them stuff"

Generally this does work. China is pretty resistant to it as countries go.

See how difficult it is for the US Chip market to get off the ground, because it is so easy to just buy from other countries. A government directive to "Build It", only goes so far. So the Chinese Gov directing its companies to build chips, would have headwinds if Nvidia chips were available.


Yes it is Chinas MO. But it probably possible to influence their timing and/or degree. I do not thing they have anywhere near replaced western/Taiwan x86/ARM CPUs, for example?

It's kinda bad business to fully pull out of a giant market, with a massive customer base, because of a major boom cycle in your product.

Do you know how difficult it is for a company to expand their business to new markets? Do you know difficult it is the build up a customer base in a market?

This isn't just doing addition and subtraction on n GPUs/year. This is business. We wouldn't have so many businessmen if business was that simple.


it's worse than just that. in this case it creates an even stronger incentive for a domestic chinese competitor to rise up and as soon as a chinese competitor can offer a similar product to what nvidia is offering, then nvidia's clock is already ticking. its probably too late already

> And Jensen's view isn't wrong. There is no way you could contain China via import restrictions. Not when they are the second-largest economy and still rapidly advancing. There are better ways to handle this, one huge ban isn't one.

There are many regulations, sanctions and restrictions I disagree with. That doesn’t mean I can or should try to bypass them on a large scale.

He may have been right, doesn’t mean he gets to break the law.


Affairs suggest problems of candor and trust. A second affair with an executive-level subordinate confirm them. The fact that one was with a foreign agent calls his judgement into question as well.

It may be the case that his ouster helps certain people. That has nothing whatsoever to do with how the blame should be apportioned or what the sensible course of action is.


> The fact that one was with a foreign agent calls

That she is a "foreign agent" is not an established fact whatsoever. Sure does make for a good headline though, especially if you want to oust Jensen.


Such a framing does not work when established facts are

- he lied about one affair

- That affair was with a major customer

- the other one was with a direct subordinate


Put bluntly, it’s a sign of arrogance beyond what’s safe for an executive, and shows a complete disregard for previous examples.

BK fafo’d at Intel with a report and that was that.

Jensen seemingly took that as a challenge and doubled down.

If this level of ego is what’s necessary for this system to thrive, let it all burn to the ground.


> This is the same as asking Apple to ignore Chinese market

There are a few major differences. Apple's devices aren't under export control so Apple takes no risk selling. Nvidia had to take legal risks to do this.

On the stock side, Apple devices are almost never supply constrained. Nvidia's never get to sit on the shelf. Nvidia can jack up the prices to the sky and still not keep up with demand.

Between these 2 things, the risk to sell to China looks like more than only profit motivated.


Surely this totally undermines his ability to negotiate in good faith about export restrictions and so on or advise on national security in any capacity. That's not good for the company, shows really poor judgement, I don't see how they can keep him after this. If it was just the affair sure whatever, but it obviously matters that she's an intelligence asset, whether that actually led to anything or not. You can say what you want about export restrictions but his relationship to the US government and the general perception of his judgement matters a great deal for the business.

>There is no way you could contain China via import restrictions.

What the fuck are you talking about - it's obvious this guy broke the export bans - the affairs are just a media circus to distract from that fact - not only should he be ousted he should be going to jail if there's any sort of legal system in the US left...


The whole affair circus to distract from the export control circumvention is another example of "It's a big club and you ain't in it". In which you is all of us non billionaires.

> This is the same as asking Apple to ignore Chinese market, when China has more active iPhone user than the whole US population.

Is it so unreasonable to expect American tech companies to 'ignore' the market of a country that is supplying materiel to the countries that America is currently engaged in a proxy war, and actual war with?

If not, exactly what would China have to do for this to be a reasonable expectation, and something that we would expect American companies to do under their own volition?


What’d we go to war for again?

Yes but Apple is not Spying on Chinese users on behalf of the Chinese government. They just share information. lol.

Apparently the government was informed of his activities with this alleged spy about a year ago and at the time decided to ignore the issue. Why would they suddenly, after elections decide that they want to follow up on the allegations?

> But I wholeheartedly disagree with ousting Jensen.

And then news came out that he was having an affair with a direct-report. Unfavorable and pretty unforgivable even before the spy story.


Did you mean to type "more dodgy" rather than "more doggy"? Or perhaps you know more than has been made public!

Yeah typos lol. Sorry I was on my phone typing that in between breaks.

Only 17% of Apple's revenue is from China, whereas 42% is from the US and other countries in the Americas.

> I wouldn't be surprised someone inside the government wants to bring him down.

Absolutely. Since the midterms, many politicians see going after Jensen as a way to appease the pitchfork mobs of anti-AI/data center voters (it doesn't matter if that position makes no sense).


Trump knew about the Chinese Spy for a YEAR.

So was Huang playing along as part of some other US-Chinese plot?

Was he a pawn, or go-between, in US-Chinese relations.

Maybe the cheating was a cover, or pawn with benefits?

Maybe this is why China helped with the Oil Crisis, the chips were sold with approval.


I mean, it's a MASSIVE fraud we're talking about.

Pretending there was no China revenue in the books?? That's an insanely huge financial lie


No need to author a grand conspiracy, it's likely exactly what it looks like. Jensen like to dip his pen in all sorts of ink and China used a honeypot to blackmail him.

China has all the incentive in the world to disrupt a major US AI firm to slow the US down.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: