Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> objectively morally wrong

I wonder how the conservatives, or the taliban, or communists, or ... call their version of "objectively morally wrong". Oh wait ... probably exactly the same.

> There are religions that allow same-sex marriage ceremonies

Are those religions "objectively morally right", or should all their adherents be fired from their jobs ? Or maybe all the other religions ? Atheists perhaps ? Come on, who do we fire ? Who do we burn ? Do tell.

> With those 3 replies, I will waste no more words on this damn topic.

Exactly, you advocate firing people for their political views, and you've gotten your way. Remind to refuse any job offer or business opportunity or cooperation I ever get from you. Let's not pretend that this makes you anything but a bigot and a total asshole.



The difference, obviously, is that Prop 8 denies rights to some people and does not affect anyone else, aside from offending them.

I don't understand your point about my comment about religions that permit same sex marriage. I think it's pretty obvious I was trying to say that morals can differ and in a pluralistic society, we err on the side of permitting individual freedom. Same-sex couples should not have to live by certain interpretations of the Talmud. Charismatic/Evangelist Christians should not be compelled to use birth control. Sikhs/Muslims/LDS members should be permitted to wear religiously significant clothing. Is that controversial?

Finally, I have actually defended Eich's promotion at some length in non-HN forums. I believe that Mozilla stands for privacy protection and the highest quality open/free software. In that regard, his viewpoints/goals and mine are very close. As strongly and fundamentally as I disagree with him on other subjects, I felt his leadership would be beneficial to Mozilla. I regret he was forced out, I think it was a bad decision.

Now, that being said, don't worry about turning down a job offer from me. I can disagree civilly, but you've called me a bigot and an asshole, and I am done with you.


You seem to have rethought your position on this, your previous post defended the firing of Mozilla's CEO based on his political opinion.

I am glad that you consider that wrong and I just misread you, or you changed your opinion for the better.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: