Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

All your points are valid.

But for Windows, I use the built in remote desktop feature/server and the client is pre-installed on every Windows machine. I'm at work remoting into my home machine right now. But I can also use any number of different Linux, Android, or iOS clients to connect to it. It does require two seconds to setup port forwarding and I use a dynamic DNS service.

The performance of an RDP-based solution is going to be much better than this. But if you're remoting into OS X or Linux then there is no advantage.



Oh, and it's been my experience that Remote Desktop sucks when you're using OpenGL. I've seen several apps go bananas when you RDP into the desktop.

Maybe that's gotten better over time, but it used to suck bad.


The problem is that technology like VNC is so slow over most connections that it's virtually useless. I'll take a random OpenGL failure over frustrating performance all the time.


RDP, courtesy of various licensed Citrix technology, is world's above so many other technologies: I can RDP to a desktop running thousands of miles away over the internet with better performance and responsiveness than VNCing to the Mac sitting 10 feet away, over a 1Gbps twisted pair. I am not exaggerating for effect, but after being spoiled by RDP, VNC is close to unusable.

It is unfortunate that close to no attention is paid to this element.


Have you had opportunity to try NoMachine? I knew them as the NX people - they seem to be giving their tech away these days.

https://www.nomachine.com/


NX (also check X2GO, OpenNX etc) is very good and it's as fast as RDP. Much, much better than VNC.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: