Wait until those big corporations start using LLMs to learn how to lock things down even further, or implement checks that disable your car when it detects alterations to the software “for safety reasons”, or go after drivers who do these things for loss of revenue, etc. A ‘94 Jeep will be fair game but a new car might not be.
They've been doing that for a decade. I think overall the balance will shift in our favor but Big AI labs will do everything they can to try and stop us.
Claude is quick to refuse to help with reverse engineering and I suspect it's only going to get worse over time.
Yes, they have been on that road for years. Tesla showed everyone the way with things like always-on connectivity or not being able to change a headlight with another original one without Tesla’s blessing. What I meant is that whatever I can do with an LLM they can do more. And if they can invoke “safety” that'll keep the law on their side for some time.
As far as I can tell no manufacturer disables the car yet when detecting modifications, or take drivers to court for doing it, yet.
> What I meant is that whatever I can do with an LLM they can do more.
That's true but we have the benefit of unlimited time, having physical control, the analog hole.
> As far as I can tell no manufacturer disables the car yet when detecting modifications, or take drivers to court for doing it, yet.
As far as I know cars are a special case in much of the world (US, EU, others?). Right to repair laws laws usually give you the right to use non-OEM parts.
Aren't DMCA anti-circumvention provisions the bigger concern in the US? I think the EU has an exemption to allow reverse engineering for the purposes of interoperability and repair.
> we have the benefit of unlimited time, having physical control, the analog hole.
We do, but everything is "software defined car" now and loopholes usually get closed with mandatory software updates done with the mandatory inspections. They put everything in one basket together with safety critical systems because that justifies any lockdown.
> Right to repair laws laws usually give you the right to use non-OEM parts.
Manufacturers already make that very expensive. Mechanics have to be certified, they need special and very expensive tools, everything is wrapped in cryptography and the manufacturer has to be in the middle of everything, for a price. [0] So go ahead, use your OEM part, you'll still pay thousands for the mechanic that has the necessary prerequisites and for the manufacturer's services.
I pray I'm wrong but we need strong regulation and enforcement, and the manufacturers can still maliciously comply.
Nothing prevents you today and technically. What prevents most owners is that they lose a lot of big features they paid for. Who wants to pay for the full car and rip out much of it? This isn't an acceptable solution for most people. They might as well not buy the car at all. And even the technical possibility can change so easily in the future.
>big corporations start using LLMs to learn how to lock things down even further
Why would they? They just need to fund lobbyist to make it illegal for any AI to reverse engineer anything copyrighted or with IP.
Sure, you can use open source AI to do it but not everyone will/can do it.
So, they don't need to ban everyone, they just need to make sure the final code isn't available freely on GitHub. That would minimize the damage, it's not a perfect solution but more than enough to protect the company.
Yes, but the more sophisticated it is technically, the more expensive to create and maintain while only making it harder, not impossible, to break.
Unless your company's moat is in the thing that was reversed engineer, I don't think most company cared enough to spend huge amount of resource to prevent it technically. The only thing that they need to prevent is the liability that comes after the product is used inappropriately or illegally.
And it you can defend something with AI, there's no reason why you can't attack it AI.
Lockstep processors, hardware security modules with immutable unreadable keys, and PKI keys that the mfg holds the private for that can only be accessed on their online services.
It’s locked down now and this started in 2018 or so. It’s just worse now.
To automotive, there is really still no right to repair. They get around it by selling “3 day passes” to their service, but with their hardware and at their prices.
They’re all moving the Tesla system of more centralized brain systems which will be even more protected.
Sad to hear. I am not a car owner, but lived in the EU for most of my life. The consumer market owes quite some consumer rights to the EU, so I guess all we can do is hope that they'll eventually crack down on these measurements again.
> The consumer market owes quite some consumer rights to the EU
Let's be clear that it's just incentives. If the EU economy was based on creating companies and new products there would not be as many incentives for consumer "rights" there.
> The consumer market owes quite some consumer rights to the EU
Not for car owners/consumers in the EU. Auto makers and dealers get away with a lot of shady shit fucking over their customers in the EU all the time. For example we in the EU don't have the same trigger happiness of NHTSA mass recalls the Americans have, but matters of such auto issues/defects is left to individual member states or even at individual case by case to decide what action is needed, and responses are a lot weaker and more limp-dick than in the US, almost never leading to mass recalls, even for the same issues[1], mainly because the US is more litigious making car manufacturers to be on the edge and proactive to issues.
Like sibling said, there are incentives to regulate stuff that has no impact on EU businesses, shit like USB-C or replaceable batteries, but they won't touch the auto industry to mandate easier repairs and less lock-downs.
Brand & Models | Defect | US Action | EU Action
------------------+--------------------+----------------+------------------
BMW (2011-2018) | Coolant pump plug | NHTSA recall | Excluded from
N20/N26 engines | short / fire risk | (720k+ cars) | recall
------------------+--------------------+----------------+------------------
VW / Audi (08-13) | Timing chain | 10yr/100k mi | No recall; case-
2.0T EA888 | tensioner failure | warranty + $ | by-case goodwill
------------------+--------------------+----------------+------------------
Ford Focus/Fiesta | DPS6 PowerShift | 10yr/150k TCM | No recall; few
(2011-2016) | transmission fail | + buybacks | buybacks/payouts
------------------+--------------------+----------------+------------------
Hyundai / Kia | Theta II / Nu GDI | 3M+ recalled + | No mass recall
(2011-2019) | bearing/fire risk | lifetime wrty | (diff specs/plants)
------------------+--------------------+----------------+------------------
Tesla 3/Y/S/X | Autopilot nag & | 2M+ NHTSA OTA | No EU recall
(2021-2024) | UI font compliance | recalls | (UNECE rules)
I'd also add the big driver for repairability is the US EPA which under Clean Air Act powers requires any emissions-related repair to be able to be done by third parties. They have mandated SAE J2534 for module updates and publicly available service manuals, for example.
Pure battery EVs are considered to have no emissions-related components, which is why Tesla gets away with that they do.
You want to use it? Go ahead and buy a 1,3,7,30 day pass to the mfg’s service. Then, good luck with your J2534 because they only approve a couple, and better find a windows machine because their .NET program only runs on Windows 10.
I'm hoping the slate truck will be different, and that whatever problems emerge out of giving consumers real control over the hardware they purchased doesn't hamstring the company somehow.
They are now required to do just that, if they want to sell to the EU market. When you hear the term "cybersecurity," the real subject is the protection of revenue streams from attack by end users.
I agree with all you said. Except... some whimsy might truly make people enjoy the thing more.
Like audiophile cables, the placebo effect contributes to the experience. Or maybe it’s the lack of nocebo that helps. Either way, someone convinced the whiskey tastes better from that glass will actually taste something better in their subjective experience.
Whimsy's totally fine. By all means indulge: buy the glasses you like, which is kinda my point. But I think there's, much like audio, an awful lot of overwrought marketing that could make people think they must own this dude's ugly glasses --- in whisky a lot of the "mystique" come from the distilleries themselves and the mythology they've manufactured around the whole experience of drinking it.
My grandmother was using a similar saying long before that, translated approximately: "there's never just 1 mouse in the barn". I'd bet these expressions have been common across the world for centuries (maybe substitute for local rodent).
The memory training happens before UEFI is initialized proper, though it provides a minimal framework for handling such parts - it's mainly so that every bit of very early code can properly pass information later on.
As for reusing the training, that's what normally happens, but there are various things that can trigger retraining beyond swapping anything in memory modules, and it's perfectly possible the vendor somehow managed to write an add-on that triggers that on every boot (just like intel managed to wreck NVRAM on every netboot, for example)
The training reuse is already happening on machines with regular user-replaceable DIMM modules. It's why there is such a scary long wait on the first boot of a newly-assembled system, but not subsequent ones.
So even if it can change, starting out with a simple "Are the same modules still installed?" check saves a lot of time.
except this should only happen _once_ (until you remove/replace components, reset the BIOS etc.). Which is why it normally doesn't happen for laptops, it was run once in the factory and DDR being soldered one mean they can just "fixed" disable the retraining avoiding bugs in the "retraining needed" detection
but yes, there are pretty bad motherboards out there, like the one I have turned out to be a complete shit show with multiple sever design issues I unluckily "lucked out of not running into" in the first 2 years of usage making a return unlikely and a replacement is useless as this is are fundamental issue affecting all models AFIK.
> everyone is sounding like a master of drafting emails
> this is pulling up people's thinking to have a structure, minimalism and sequencing of expression
I see the same for the former but the opposite on the latter. Everyone sounds like expert drafters because the AI is doing all of that.
True to the "use it or lose it" principle, the people's thinking skills about the emails have weakened. They rely on giving the AI some bits of info, a document they never read, some vague instructions, and the AI molds the message with structure and sequence. Then I get to experience live the joy of discussing with these people face to face and they still just spit out disparate bits of information with no fluid structure and sequence for the ideas because the only time they thought about the topic was when the AI wrote an email about it.
> This is the same as asking Apple to ignore Chinese market
There are a few major differences. Apple's devices aren't under export control so Apple takes no risk selling. Nvidia had to take legal risks to do this.
On the stock side, Apple devices are almost never supply constrained. Nvidia's never get to sit on the shelf. Nvidia can jack up the prices to the sky and still not keep up with demand.
Between these 2 things, the risk to sell to China looks like more than only profit motivated.
Those ~20 year old comments compared HN to Reddit of that time, which was insulting to HN. In the 20 years that passed probably HN at some point crossed the threshold of old Reddit. But now the insult is to compare it to current Reddit.
On the other hand putting it in the rules that you’re not allowed to say X and then quoting the rule as evidence against X is at the very least not an intellectually interesting way of making a point. Imagine if everyone put in their profile that they’re never wrong and kept pointing at that when challenged.
> Is it an intellectually interesting way of pointing out that a comment violates the guidelines, and more important, is just boring?
Intellectually it's like refuting someone's argument because they made a typo, like on Reddit.
When HN puts something in the rules it sets the tone for the whole community. I was being charitable calling it "intellectually uninteresting". "Embarrassing" is a more accurate description of that particular move. Imagine if Trump signed an EO demanding that he only be called a stable genius. If it's utterly embarrassing when it's done by the people you don't like, guess what...
If you give away trade secrets by intentionally giving them to another party without an explicit agreement of secrecy no statute in the world will protect it.
You have to take “reasonable” measures to protect trade secrets. Uploading them to a service without any confidentiality agreement or worse, where the provider officially has the right to use that data, defeats the definition of a reasonable measure.
Human drivers pay one insurance, for themselves. It’s easier to swallow because most drivers think they are above average skill. Not so easy when they need to cover someone else’s coding mistakes. And if the company has to pay for every car that self drives that can get ugly fast, one bug and half the fleet has a fender bender.
Chances are they just self-insure (like they are now) and eventually will have some group insurance if they can actually prove it's safer over the next half decade.
reply