Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | sodiumfree's commentslogin

Well, then you'd miss out on a lot of great products from third-party sellers, and with this latest push that is the subject of this article, you'd see less and less showing up.

...and you can do this after you do a search and see results and get to where you have additional filtering options. I'm guilty of using "Show only Prime offers" or whatever that one is called. After becoming a seller that does FBA and seller-fulfilled, I use that filter less. There are great small businesses that still ship very fast, and at competitive prices and since I'm one now, I feel their pain and want to support them too. I can also be patient on a lot of my shipments and don't require 2-day shipping.


> There are great small businesses that still ship very fast, and at competitive prices and since I'm one now

The problem is that there are also a lot of scumbags doing the same thing, and it's impossible to tell the great small businesses from the scammers. I've been burned by that a few times, and it's why I don't buy anything from Amazon unless Amazon is fulfilling the order (where I have at least some recourse).

If I'm buying directly from small sellers, I'm either using their website directly or I'm doing it on eBay.


I thought we paid for warehousing regardless. Though I think there are situations where if your selling inventory is turning over quickly, they may waive warehousing fees. The incentive is definitely there to manage inventory at optimal levels.

If your inventory sits too long in their warehouse, the fees go from "regular" storage fees to "long-term" storage fees. Those fees are much higher, which incentivizes the seller to put the stuff on sale to blow it out of their warehouses, or you can have the inventory sent back to you.

Also, fees vary by category and season. Around the holidays, you'll see them making a push to increase long-term storage fees to make way for the stuff that will actually sell, and on categories which are hot for the holidays, you might see them providing incentives with lower storage fees.

I'm not the primary person that deals with Amazon FBA, but he sits next to me. Don't take what I'm saying as the gospel, but this is based on somewhat second hand experiencing and reading some of the emails that come through. My partner pays more attention to those details.


Yes I was talking about the long term storage fees which they used to charge if inventory was rolled over after 30 days. The items we used to sell needed to be purchased in high quantities to get a decent price so we would ship items to FBA on a monthly basis trying to estimate demand. Eventually, Amazon itself started selling the same item and it just wasn't worth it especially with higher fees for FBA.


> ...most suppliers do FBA which tacks on a more expensive shipping charge than you would have otherwise with USPS.

This is not universally true. As a seller on Amazon, using both FBA and seller-fulfillment, there is a lot of "it depends" in all of this.

Some items we can ship cheaper, especially to local zones. But as we're on one coast and we have a lot of customers on the other coast, FBA can be a real saver on the shipping charges.

Size and weight of the package affect the shipping charge, but on some products we sell, we find the fulfillment fees to sometimes get as low as less than 1/2 of what it would cost us to ship direct, even by the cheapest method we can use.

If you're looking at the fulfillment fees compared to what you get charged to ship a package, make sure you're also considering that Amazon helps distribute the products to regional fulfillment centers. It's Amazon's employees that pick and pack the orders. Amazon pays for the box it ships in. Amazon handles customer service and return processing, or reshipment if the item is damaged in transit, amongst other things.

Admittedly, this is not easy to consider all of the pros and cons, expenses and savings. FBA can also be a difficult beast to deal with when they don't check in your inventory, temporarily lose 300 units. Having to deal with Seller Support will cost you in terms of stress and its effects on your receding hairline, or your liver if you need to keep a bottle on your desk as you try to get problems resolved.


Are you considering the PayPal fees you pay for payment processing when you sell on eBay? That's on top of the approximately 10% that eBay charges. eBay also charges listing fees and final value fees. I haven't done a deep dive on my own selling data to come up with an accurate comparision, but I think they're comparable.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: